What are other peoples minds according to the Laṅkāvatāra Sūtra?
score:1
Don't quite agree with the other answers so I'll try and flesh out the differences.
First, it is important to understand that the cittamatra view is not the pinnacle of prajnaparamita. It is one stop that some beings need to arrive at before reaching the pinnacle of the perfection of wisdom.
Second, it is important to know that although the Laṅkāvatāra Sūtra is popularly said by some to be a sutra supporting cittamatra, actually it is quite critical of it. You can find in the sutra quite explicit admonitions that some of the concepts popular with cittamatra are actually upaya used by the Buddha out of compassion for those who are not ready to understand conceptually the perfection of wisdom and who are prone to fall to annihilation or extreme fear as they approach the truth.
With those points made I want you to look at the third point in the verse sighted which has been overlooked.
The Blessed One replied: There are four things by the fulfilling of which an earnest disciple may gain self-realization of Noble Wisdom and become and Bodhisattva-Mahasattva: First, he must have a clear understanding that all things are only manifestations of the mind itself; second, he must discard the notion of birth, abiding and disappearance; third, he must clearly understand the ego-less-ness of both things and persons; and fourth, he must have a true conception of what constitutes self-realization of Noble Wisdom, provided with these four understandings, earnest disciples may become Bodhisattvas and attain Transcendental Intelligence.
Now look at the formulation of your question with emphasis on the third point above.
If everything is my own mind, what about other peoples minds? Are they also my own mind?
No, they are not your own mind. Your own mind is not your own mind. Because 'you' do not exist in the way that 'you' think you do.
What you are doing with your question is diving up the world into two; a duality if you will. On one side you have you and your mind. Set aside for a second the question of what 'you' are given that all things are manifestation of mind. On the other side you have the rest of the world and you interpret what the Buddha has said as putting you and your mind as masters of this world. You've interpreted it to say that only you and your own mind are real and all the rest is just a fiction that your mind is making up.
This is just not even close to what the Buddha was saying. Ask yourself... if all things are manifestation of the mind itself (note: not 'your' mind), then what of the mind itself? Is it also a manifestation of mind? Is the Buddha saying that only the mind is real? If only the mind is real, then there can be no thing, no separate non-mind thing, that is the 'owner' of that mind, right? So what does that make 'you'?
Let's just say hypothetically that the mind is real and the only thing that is real. So how do you interpret the third point above? The Buddha in the very same passage is telling us that all people and phenomena are empty. That neither people nor phenomena contain any inherent being. How can you square that with this idea of 'your' mind or even with the idea that 'mind' itself is real?
To truly understand these four points and what the Buddha is after in this passage you have to understand emptiness and what is meant by this third point. It is the teaching on emptiness and anatta that is unique and clears up any and all doubt that the Buddha was referring to some form of solipsism when teaching that all should be regarded as manifestation of mind. Mind itself is empty of any inherent being. Mind itself is not real.
I'm hopeful this is helpful, but if you find yourself just confused by this I'd suggest putting it down and focusing on the method aspects of the path.
Upvote:-1
That’s a very commonly misunderstood idea. Yogacara is not solipsism. What the sutra is referring to is how discrete dharmas (e.g. stuff in the world) is “transformed” by latent seeds in the storehouse consciousness, by the self conceit, and by the executive function of mind consciousness. Things exist independent of our own minds. We just never see them as such because our own conditioning is reflected back to us. In essence, we don’t live in a world of true forms; instead we live in a world comprised solely of the delusions existing in our own minds.
These delusions can take on a seemingly infinite number of forms, but can generally be reduced to existential matters (e.g the hindrances, experience, the three cankers, etc) and fundamental perceptual errors (like the inability to perceive shunyata existing within the field of perception). Yogacara, practically speaking, seeks to unburden us of those two sets of conditioning. In fact, Zen koans, a yogacara practice if there ever was one, operate on those two axises. Some address existential matters, other seek to reorient perception. As we begin to see through our conditioning, bit by bit, the world is revealed in its “thusness”.
So to answer your question, yes, other minds exist independently of our own, but so do bus seats, granola bars, and flat wear. You’ve just never seen them - only the warped image that your own mind creates.
Upvote:2
Thrangu Rinpoche once said that everything we see (all phenomena we experience) is our own projection - except other people's minds. Only other people's subjective experience is not our projection and therefore exists independently of us.
Upvote:2
How to understand the lankavatara sutra and 'mind only' will depend on what practice or practices you are engaged with. At least some Buddhists thought that the "one mind" - Buddhahood -- includes all other minds.
From scholarship by Charles Jones, p113 of Chinese Pure Land Buddhism:
Incidentally, people complain about academic analysis, but I think that's pretty out dated. When Buddhism first came to the West, academics were concerned just with making philosophical sense of it, which was inevitably filtered through whatever philosophy was fashionable at the time (e.g. Hegel). But most of what I've read is very different -- more concerned with reconstructing what historical Buddhists thought and disagreed about.
So anyway, the idea of the one mind including every mind seems very Chinese -- Huayen / Tientai / Pure Land (Amitabha's pure land pervading all minds here already).
The point I'm getting to is that other minds I think are manifestations of our own -- at least our own consummate nature -- but we don't experience them that way due to delusion. Which is not to deny the existence of "other minds", vijñāna-santâna.
Or this, by Yung Ming
More post
- 📝 Reference request: Skulls higher than the Himalayan mountains
- 📝 Keeping rooted in the present in the face of past realities
- 📝 How does Enlightenment feel like
- 📝 What's the role of the detailed descriptions of the other planes of existence? Why it was important for the Buddha to tell them?
- 📝 Are teaching on gratitude and "duty" nessesary?
- 📝 Should detachment, and letting go, be an appropriate response when you are owed money?
- 📝 Is there any benefit in learning Pali or Sanskrit?
- 📝 What are the name and content of this Zen Buddhist koan?
- 📝 Does the Nihilism view (natthika-dithi) actually deny rebirths?
- 📝 third eye experience of mindful breathing
- 📝 Is it a bad heavy karma to criticize or give up your guru?
- 📝 How does the Nimitta occur?
- 📝 Can lay people acheive enlighment (Arahanthship) in this life by adhering to Buddhist principles?
- 📝 Leave pain while enjoying life?
- 📝 When you get a nightmare could the message in it be right?
- 📝 Buddhist pursuit of peace questions
- 📝 feel 'me' inside what should i do for the next step
- 📝 Samsara and States of Being (reference request)
- 📝 Difference between Sampajanna and Vipassana
- 📝 What is intellect-consciousness and why is it different from intellect itself?
- 📝 What is the role of thinking in Buddhism?
- 📝 How do Bodhisattva vow takers avoid stream entry?
- 📝 Sentience, killing, & extremes?
- 📝 Did Buddha saw his two teachers were born, where living beings did not have physical body?
- 📝 Multiple meditation practices
- 📝 Were there earlier western monks before Bhikkhu Ananda Metteyya (Charles Henry Allan Bennett)
- 📝 Why is the first lines of the Dhammapada twin verses sometimes translated using the word 'heart'?
- 📝 Supposed one could give you Cockayne, would you strife for Nibbana?
- 📝 What is meant by the impossibility "A Buddha can not help someone not related to him"?
- 📝 How to actually do death contemplation?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 What are other peoples minds according to the Laṅkāvatāra Sūtra?
- 📝 What are the other Theravada Councils held between the 4th and 6th
- 📝 What are the reasons for and against studying other religions?
- 📝 What are the Three Turnings of the Wheel of Dharma according to Tibetan Buddhism?
- 📝 What are the established rules set for a person to Become a Buddha other than, that, he should have lived as a King?
- 📝 What are the differences between vipassana and mindfulness meditation?
- 📝 What are the common buddhist practices to eliminate sleepiness?
- 📝 What are the differences/similarities in the concept of faith as used in Buddhism and Christianity?
- 📝 What are the texts that contain words which can be attributed directly to the Buddha?
- 📝 What are the scientifically proven benefits of mindfulness meditation?
- 📝 What are the Four Noble Truths?
- 📝 What are the differences between "Nirvana" in Buddhism and "Moksha" in Hinduism?
- 📝 What are the main schools of Tibetan Buddhism?
- 📝 What are the three marks of existence?
- 📝 What are the main arguments in favor of the Anātman view over the Ātman view?
- 📝 What are the Core Teachings of Buddhism?
- 📝 What are the Four Immeasurables (aka Four Noble Abodes)?
- 📝 What are the Pali translations for mindfulness?
- 📝 What are the salient differences between the Pāḷi Nikāyas & Chinese Āgamas?
- 📝 What are the advantages/disadvantages of meditating with eyes closed?
- 📝 What are the suttas in which the Buddha provides instruction on how to meditate?
- 📝 What are any and all of the exceptions to eating after noon if you've taken 8 precepts?
- 📝 From a Buddhist point of view, what are the benefits of supernormal powers?
- 📝 What are the core Mahayana and Vajrayana Sutras?
- 📝 What are the resources a Buddhist can use during very hard times?
- 📝 What are the Ānāpānasati Kammaṭṭhāna as Taught By Ven. Kiribathgoda Gnanananda Thero
- 📝 It is said that arahants never dream. What are the textual sources for this claim?
- 📝 What are the soteriological aims of different traditions?
- 📝 What are the twelve aspects of the Four Noble Truths?
- 📝 What are the funeral rites for Tibetan lay Buddhists?