What kind of harm can koan answers cause to one's practice?
Upvote:4
I like to compare Koans with poems, or with jokes. Poems teach us to experience the world directly, unmediated by discursive analytical thinking, as feelings and associations. Getting a joke requires expanding one's context, relating alternative frames of reference.
In some professional settings, the experts develop a shortcut way of referring to things they deal with. E.g. in software engineering, you could hear someone saying that a particular design is kludgy, or leaking, or tangled up etc. Not all of these have official agreed-upon definitions, and many are made up ad-hoc, as required for communicating in a particular situation.
The method of Zen is to get practitioner in touch with their immediate experiences (to point them to their own mind). This requires transcending whatever context the person is stuck in, and expanding one's awareness to include "the elephant in the room". To build on the joke metaphor, the point of Koans is to make you "laugh".
Now, you can answer your own question: will explaining jokes help you learn how to laugh? Will analyzing songs help you learn how to feel?
Why did many Buddhists publish koan commentaries for many hundred years? -- I don't know. Because they are slaves of their minds? Because they think it may be helpful to certain types of practitioners?
The other problem with explaining Koans is that a Koan (unlike a joke) does not have a single "correct" interpretation. A Koan is always ambiguous, by design. A good koan commentary may help one explore various facets of the theme. Sort of like analyzing poems in school may(!) help one develop artistic sensitivity. But in context of Buddhism S.E. the danger is, someone might read an answer and assume they now know what this Koan is about.
Many people don't see until they know what to look for. I may not see a frog under my feet until my wife points it out, even though I've been staring directly at it. What we want to learn in Zen is to "see" before knowing. The more you explain Zen, the further you are from "seeing".
More post
- π Pali question: "seven more life times at most"
- π What is the definition of passa ?
- π How does teaching of Buddhism deal with waste? How does teaching of Buddhism deal with acceptance even it causes unhappiness?
- π Tibetan Mahayana
- π gratitude towards & repaying the debt to one's parents
- π Is it useful to meditate upon hunger?
- π What really Sekha means?
- π What are the characteristics of karmaless action?
- π Upaya in Theravada Buddhism and the Pali Canon
- π Are the formless jhanas without any consciouness of form at all?
- π Does Buddha go to Naraka (hell) to save those tormented beings?
- π what is difference between volition and intention?
- π What is an "enlightening being"?
- π How can the details of the mappΕ age be discussed skillfully?
- π Bodhidharma leaving for china
- π Is this desire, to not be friendless anymore, healthy?
- π Why don't animals(animal realm) commit suicide?
- π How does decisive supporting cause (upanissaya paccaya) work? (and some related questions)
- π Where can one find guidance from a teacher next year in 2018?
- π To what extent can ΔnΔpΔnasati be related to VipassanΔ?
- π did buddha accept astrology and other occult science?
- π Can't notice the breath
- π What does "break-up of the body after death" mean in the suttas?
- π What is Anuloma-nana? How does this insight works?
- π What does Buddhism add to a Stoic?
- π Resolving right action & intention in a white lie
- π Modern and original versions of Chan and Seon
- π How does Paticcasamuppada or 12 Links of Dependent Origination relate to Aversion?
- π Work, Love, and Buddhism in the modern setting
- π What exactly is svabhava?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π What kind of harm can koan answers cause to one's practice?
- π What kind of mistakes can a new meditator in his/her early 20's avoid?
- π Can cold showers benefit or harm our practice (our concentration)?
- π What is The eighth jhana and how can i practice it?
- π I believe I have done bad things in a past life can I fix my curse that causes people to turn against me what kind of Karma is this?
- π What are ways "common" and not so known to practice the first kind of proper giving?
- π Any authentic sutta from any tradition that gives guidance on what kind of partner to choose?
- π Can I practice Buddhism without meditating?
- π Can one practice meditation to gain knowledge about the universe?
- π What are the texts that contain words which can be attributed directly to the Buddha?
- π Can meditation cause you to sleep less?
- π What is the best way to practice humility
- π Can I practice Buddhism on my own?
- π What can go wrong in Mindfulness Therapy as used in Clinics?
- π What can be done about fake monks?
- π What are the resources a Buddhist can use during very hard times?
- π Can vipassana cause mental stress?
- π What is the difference between concentration and mindfulness practice ?
- π What Buddha's techniques I can use to uproot deep craving for a woman's love?
- π What kind of vipassana retreats do you recommend in South East Asia?
- π What can be done when one is having difficulties establishing a regular practice?
- π What is the substantial cause of an instance of consciousness?
- π I have some people coming over who practice Buddhism, what should I know?
- π What determines whether a style of meditation can or cannot lead to insight?
- π Can Buddhist practice make you more emotionally volatile?
- π What meditation practice will allow me to sleep less and focus more?
- π What is the most βgenuinely Buddhistβ kind of mindfulness?
- π prior life what hope can we have related to our present life?
- π What can I do regarding Non-Self
- π What is the equivalent scientific term for samsedaja? What kind of beings on earth are born from samsedaja?