Upvote:0
I think it's a very common misunderstanding that karma is something that happens to (other) people as a result of actions (they) did, like some sort of embodying force of justice. Alternately, I might think that things are happening to (me) because of what (I) did and now (I) am being somehow punished. This is a false conception though. Nobody deserves to suffer for what they have done and I am not being punished for past wrongs. There is no judgement, any more than gravity judges the car the drives off the edge of a cliff.
It's not that karma is unobservable, it's just that this mind is easily distracted and I have an ongoing habit of missing the obvious. Meditative practices are one means of working through the distractions and learning how to pay attention. When I'm paying attention, nothing is especially mysterious. When I'm not paying attention, I stub my toe and curse the man who built the table.
Upvote:0
My work (karma or kamma) or my action is my God for self-realization.i.e., only through my action can I see my God.
This Buddhist philosophy is stated somewhat differently in Hindu philosophy:
You have the duty and right only to Karma, no special rights for the fruits of action, not even for the privileges.
Upvote:2
Often intention plays a role in deciding if something is ethical/unethical, has good karmic results, or bad. For example, accidentally killing versus intentionally killing. Outwardly the may look the same.
If intention matters, then karma would need to be able to reason and know our thoughts. These are exactly the sort of things we attribute to god(s).
I think this is in part why karma was eventually personified by King Yama, the judge of the dead.
As other answers have already mentioned, there is an entirely naturalistic way to look at karma. In a way, naturalistic karma is a harsher judge-- killing is killing and has consequences, regardless to intentions.
Upvote:3
Karma is to Buddhism as gravity is to physics: fundamental, inevitable, basic, impartial, all-pervading and so basic it's quite hard to explain. The function of gods in religion centres around intention. Karma, like gravity, is a principle of interaction that is utterly without intent. Nor is it the subject of veneration. Given that many gods are not all-pervasive, I don't think that karma has any qualities that are quintessentially godly.
Upvote:6
Such a highly dualistic analogy is completely wrong, from non-theistic Mahayana/Vajrayana perspective. His points seem to be that:
However, in reality:
Buddhists do not take karma on blind faith. Instead, they know that karma is real, even if somewhat abstract, phenomena that (unlike God!) can be observed, studied, predicted -- and therefore controlled.
Karma is not some kind of transcendental (otherwordly) force. It is a natural tendency of regular action to lead to certain results. Karma does not evaluate our actions against some book of moral rules. Instead, our actions themselves lead to certain results. Our actions IS karma.
It is not like the acting person is one thing, the world is another thing, and karma is third thing. Person is a result of past karma, manifestation of past karma. Karma is just how the world works, so karma is the world. The world and the person are two sides of the same stick.
So no, not at all. Karma is not like God, is not "higher force". Karma is us and we are karma.
Upvote:9
Sure, there is a way that karma could be understood as being "like" a god. It is one of the forces that controls the whole of the universe; it has the world in its power:
kammunΔ vattati loko
The world goes according to karma
-- MN 98
In that sense, it could be understood as sharing a similarity with the concept of god. That's about as far as the similarity goes, though.
The law of karma isn't an entity, it is a regularity of interaction between moments of experience, that certain types of experience (ethically intentional ones) have a creative force, for either good or bad. It is important to remember that the word "karma" just means "action". So, in a way you are asking "Are actions like gods?" which of course is silly. Nonetheless, the law of karma does act a bit like a god would, only a lot more logically.