Does Yogacara and its Alayavijnana fail compared to a Permanent Self?
Upvote:3
Shankara is Advaita Vedanta, a branch of Hindu philosophy inspired by Buddhism, so why are we talking about him? I guess you were reading his critics of Buddhism and this is what you ask?
Your confusion about "infinite regress" comes from your materialistic assumption that separate objects exist in and of themselves, without observers. But in reality, separation into objects is a feature of the observing mind.
The observing mind does not arise all at once but emerges gradually from impressions of interactions. These impressions and interactions are automatic and undifferentiated, they have to accumulate until the patterns in them become obvious enough so that individual objects can be delineated. The mind is nothing other than the sum total of these accumulated impressions giving rise to an ability to recognize.
It's not that nothing exists prior to the delineation, but whatever does exist is not delineated, so before delineation there are no separate objects to talk about. The boundaries between objects are arbitrary and are drawn by the observing mind. Different beings delineate different objects thereby creating their specific subjective realms. The desires beings have are for those subjectively delineated objects.
What you call substratum is nothing other than the cyclicaly dying and reemerging medium of living beings. They are the carriers or the bearers of the samsaric mind. This mind is partially taught to and partially reinvented by every newly born baby. No permanent self is necessary because beings take turns carrying the torch of the samsaric mind and passing it on down the line.
Alayavijnana is the sum total of information carrying forward by the diversity of media that the samsaric mind can draw upon as it recreates itself in the new generations of sentient beings.
More post
- 📝 What does Buddhism say that the laity should do when someone injuries them?
- 📝 The story of Ji Gong 濟公
- 📝 Do Buddhists need affection, physical touch or intimacy?
- 📝 Meaning of the Rooted Sutta
- 📝 What is prajna?
- 📝 There is a conventional self, so is anything conventionally permanent?
- 📝 Action committed through self-interest
- 📝 Kalachakra Tantra (translation of the original text)
- 📝 How did Buddha's teachings about samsara differ from earlier Indian tradition?
- 📝 Is self-mummification considered same as Nirvana?
- 📝 Reunion with the loved one after death and in next life
- 📝 Does Avalokiteshvara speak through the Buddha in the Heart Sutra? Or how is it that Avalokiteshvara speaks to Shariputra?
- 📝 Paramitha vs Merits
- 📝 How did monks time their practice?
- 📝 Does karma force things to happen?
- 📝 How does the 'Great Doubt' compare to doubt?
- 📝 How is negligence dealt with?
- 📝 Satipatthana sutta in english AUDIO
- 📝 Is reflecting upon a choir conducive to the path of Enlightenment?
- 📝 How do Buddhists who believe in a non momentary conventional self during life account for karma without enlightenment?
- 📝 Sexual misconduct, what is it
- 📝 Can we be sensously aware without consciousness?
- 📝 Body state after enlightenment
- 📝 Are you familiar with a particular AN or SN sutta on bowing?
- 📝 What does Buddhism say about success?
- 📝 Is even Buddhahood itself a short straw next to material wealth and pleasure and fame?
- 📝 Is it fair to ordain a child even when they refuse?
- 📝 Please explain joy and/or the Kimatthiyasutta
- 📝 What would Buddhists say about 'pantheism'
- 📝 What are Bhavanga and Javana?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Does Yogacara and its Alayavijnana fail compared to a Permanent Self?
- 📝 How to not let the attachment to a self and its preferences influence the choice of a particular tradition in buddhism?
- 📝 In Yogacara Buddhism, is discontinuity an illusion, and does change arise?
- 📝 Does studying mathematics or science lead to a practitioner of Buddhism acquiring wrong philosophical views and mental afflictions?
- 📝 Does meditation increase productivity for software developers and related professions?
- 📝 What does Buddhism literature and tradition say about transgender folks?
- 📝 What does breaking the fetter 'Clinging to rites and rituals' actually mean?
- 📝 Does downvoting an answer qualify as divisive and harsh speech?
- 📝 Does Zen distinguish between concentration and insight meditation?
- 📝 Philosophical and Doctrinal Differences between Theravada and Zen, and its effects
- 📝 "Guard the sense doors"- What does this mean, and what is it's application?
- 📝 Does hosting guests at home with meat and alcohol (because they are fond of it) amount to aiding the guests break their Sila?
- 📝 I want to understand the technicality of rebirth and what happens to conditioned self
- 📝 Which canon and traditions does the Flower Sermon text belong to?
- 📝 How does a monk address parents and relatives?
- 📝 During insight meditation, what does the meditator note in-between the rising and falling of the abdomen?
- 📝 Does anybody know the composition of the 6th council and how the delegates were chosen?
- 📝 Through the Processes of Jhana does it have a Permanent effect or temporary effect on your life
- 📝 What does Buddhism say about creativity and spiritual development?
- 📝 Ajahn Brahm stated that he ate snakes and frogs during his training, does this mean that it is acceptable to kill animals?
- 📝 Does DN2 and MN36 provide an irrefutable statement on the fact of rebirth?
- 📝 How does a monk cope with all the bad things happening in the world if the only thing monks do is sitting and meditating?
- 📝 Why does 'thoughts' and 'memories' not part of aggregates?
- 📝 Are Buddhists supposed to feel superior compared to other people, and to brag about it?
- 📝 What does Buddha and Buddhism say about fighting against enemy of dharma?
- 📝 Where does utilitarianism sit with Buddhism and vice versa?
- 📝 Quantified Self and Meditation
- 📝 How does the buddhist teachings differentiate between reality and perception?
- 📝 Trolley problem and its variants in Buddhist ethics
- 📝 Does the Doctrine of No Soul mean there is nothing permanent to continue?