Can we define craving without mentioning self?
score:1
When the thought arises: "I want ice cream", the "want" is fueled by craving (tanha) but the arising of the idea of "I" is attachment (upadana) and becoming (bhava) rather than craving (tanha). The Mahayana sutra you are studying says:
There are four attachments: attachment to sense pleasures, attachment to views, attachment to virtue and practice, attachment to self-theories.
The Pali suttas distinguish between craving and becoming, as follows:
The craving that makes for further becoming — accompanied by passion & delight, relishing now here & now there — i.e., craving for sensual pleasure, craving to be, craving not to be: This, friend Visakha, is the origination of self-identification described by the Blessed One.
MN 44
For self-identification or suffering to arise, craving alone is not enough. As described in MN 44, above, for self-identification or suffering to arise, the craving must lead to new becoming (bhava). The idea of 'I' or 'I exist' is becoming.
Here, suttas such as SN 12.12 and MN 148 clearly explain the idea of "I" arises after the arising of craving and that there can be craving without the idea of "I". Therefore, craving can be defined without mentioning self, as follows:
Venerable sir, who craves?
“Not a valid question,” the Blessed One replied. “I do not say, ‘One craves.’ Since I do not speak thus, if one should ask me, ‘Venerable sir, with what as condition does craving come to be?’ this would be a valid question. To this the valid answer is: ‘With feeling as condition, craving comes to be; with craving as condition, clinging; with clinging as condition, becoming…. Such is the origin of this whole mass of suffering.’
SN 12.12
It follows the non-understanding of anatta is not at the root of craving; even though the realisation of anatta, together with the realisation of impermanence (anicca) & unsatisfactoriness (dukkha), will end craving.
If the mind realises the aggregates as 'worthless' (as described in SN 22.95) there will certainly be revulsion and dispassion which is nothing but the end of craving. However the realisation of the aggregates as "worthless" is not 'anatta'. It is 'unsatisfactoriness' ('dukkha'). In other words, ideas of "I" could still possibly arise even though the aggregates are declared as worthless (asāra).
Upvote:2
An example is there in the paticca-samuppada itself.
Vedana Paccaya Tanha
Feeling gives rise to craving. So in reality there's no "I like icecream".
It should be
- liking arises due to taste
- liking arises due to sight
- liking arises due to sound etc.
There's no practicing Anatta. You practice mindfulness and the Anicca, Dukkha, Anatta natures are revealed. Practicing the noble eightfold path leads to the cutting off of craving and cessation of suffering. Mindfulness is a part of the noble eightfold path.
More post
- 📝 How to be kind when you don't like people or the world?
- 📝 To what extend should I keep doing useless stuff with my friends?
- 📝 Are there stories in the suttas of people experiencing the fruits of their karma in their lifetimes?
- 📝 Must one move through the various jhanas to realise nibbana?
- 📝 Due to coming together of what does the dream arise?
- 📝 Can I plan for future while doing meditation on death?
- 📝 Where does it say 'You Are Already Enlightened'?
- 📝 Once ignorance is removed ,is the cessation of suffering automatic?
- 📝 My job requires me to shuck oysters
- 📝 Is mano or mind function of brain? Then what we perceive is mere creation of brain
- 📝 Is there another term than "Mahayana"?
- 📝 What's the difference between having a view and clinging to a view?
- 📝 Does dreams make sense?
- 📝 Best study tools on the net or books
- 📝 The Final Moment of the Buddha's Realization
- 📝 Where did the Buddha teach about the "flow of tears"?
- 📝 Are there universal experiences associated with seeing through individual aggregates?
- 📝 What is the difference between Vijñāna, Manas and Citta?
- 📝 Is OM MA NI PADME HUM flag useful?
- 📝 Is there any proof of Karma theory & rebirth?
- 📝 What is the textual structure of original Pali versions of the suttas of the Majjhima Nikaya?
- 📝 Intentional or unintentional sexual thoughts
- 📝 How do you handle loud, meaningful family noises while trying to focus?
- 📝 Is the Sinhalese language very different to Pali?
- 📝 If you are/become very sensitive for sounds what could be the reason/cause?
- 📝 How to politely pursuade a lay person/Bhante to wear a mask?
- 📝 Is All-Is-One a buddhist belief?
- 📝 Is love in this life 'artificial'?
- 📝 From the perspective of Theravada, can a Mahayana follower attain Nibbana?
- 📝 Have you seen evidence that Gautama Buddha visited Shambhala?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Can we define craving without mentioning self?
- 📝 Can sankharas and craving arise without attachment?
- 📝 Can you attain stream entry without meditation?
- 📝 Can I practice Buddhism without meditating?
- 📝 How can there be Happiness without suffering?
- 📝 How can one define luxurious beds and seats in the eighth precept?
- 📝 What Buddha's techniques I can use to uproot deep craving for a woman's love?
- 📝 Teaching or giving advice without mentioning the Buddha
- 📝 If there is no self how can Nirvana be described as bliss?
- 📝 How can I talk to my mother (who idle-chatters) without getting angry?
- 📝 If a Buddha exists then can a private buddha arise or exist somewhere in the same world system without having learned from the current Buddha?
- 📝 Can I attain Vipassana without doing the body scan?
- 📝 Can someone help me to find suttas on Self compassion
- 📝 Can a bad karma happen just only with a thought without any physical or verbal action?
- 📝 Can new beings come into existence without this existence being a rebirth?
- 📝 Can we be sensously aware without consciousness?
- 📝 How can the theory of emptiness be true and yet the self still transmigrates and takes rebirth?
- 📝 How can an arahant still perceive without ignorance?
- 📝 Can a person without any of the five physical senses attain arhatship?
- 📝 How can I direct attention on an breath without consciously breathing?
- 📝 The "conventional" self - in what way can it be accepted?
- 📝 Can we reach Nirvana without removing ignorance?
- 📝 What am I doing to my self to make my natural state "I am trapped in pain" (This seems like a must for me and there is nothing I can do about it)
- 📝 Can we reach deep meditative states without teachers?
- 📝 Sunyata and Void. How can be the void without a super consciousness?
- 📝 Can one remove the asavas without becoming an arahant?
- 📝 Reference request: Can a king rule justly without killing?
- 📝 How can we say no without giving explanations?
- 📝 How can consciousness arise without the fuel?
- 📝 Is there any way one can be a Monk without a teacher in India/Nepal?