Does any/every form of lying violate the precept of "not-lying"?
score:4
The motivation DOES make a difference to the karma of an action. The classic discussion about karma stresses motivation.
Karma as action denotes an act of mental volition (cetanΔ), and the bodily and verbal actions that stem from it.
This is almost literally from Vasubandhu's Abhidharma-koΕa (4th century CE).
So the mental volition (that is - motivation) is the whole point. That makes sense: everything in Buddhism is about consciousness first.
So if you lie to protect jews from the Nazis, to use a modern example - that is not necessarily negative karma. If you had taken lay vows, as a Tibetan Buddhist you would probably do some purification ritual to be sure, but since the motivation is to help someone & you are also preventing people from harming (the nazis) - on balance it is better to lie in such circumstances.
Your example is a bit less clear. I do think it is better to stay silent than to actively lie about your faith. If you have taken lay vows, you have at the very least taken on the attempt not to lie. Staying silent does not break your vow.
The vow to not-lie is also sometimes explained as follows:
Do not distort fact ... Sometimes the use of words can make something seem acceptable, when it could have been said very differently and be totally unacceptable. This is not a lie, but a distortion of fact.
Upvote:1
The simple answer is "Yes" However, there are different weight in each Kamma. A person who tells a lie to protect his life has the least weight. It also depends on the person. Monks are expected to follow the precepts more vigorously than a lay person.
See the current discussion on a similar subject.
https://discourse.suttacentral.net/t/on-the-five-precepts/5486
Upvote:1
Any statement meeting the following conditions is ling.
So there will be dilemmas like if you tell the truth someone may lose their life or similar situation. One must weigh one's commitment to the precepts and the consequences.
More post
- π Gautama Buddha and Hindu divinities
- π What is a good response when some-one says 'sadhu' to you?
- π Did any Indian Mahayana Buddhists have non-cognition as a goal?
- π Protection from tree-stumps
- π Buddhist Perspective on Value, Sentiment, Attraction?
- π How do I do "contemplation of death" meditation? And is it dangerous?
- π What is Wholesome Meditation?
- π Identification with Negative States
- π How to get along
- π What does Buddhism say about the consequences of good and bad behaviour?
- π False Virtue and True Virtue
- π Why talk and think about self as noun?
- π Mahasi Sayadaw / Yuttadhammo noting question
- π Better results when pausing meditation?
- π Are there any Suttas, Vinaya or Abhidhamma explaining sΔ«labbata-parΔmΔsa?
- π Citta experience during meditation
- π Where is recorded that the Buddha said this (perhaps about microorganisms)?
- π What did the Buddha mean in AN 5.38 with the fifth benefit to a person of faith?
- π Samsaric knowledge
- π Did the Buddha teach meditation to lay people?
- π Paradox of the ego - our desire to improve vs Buddhism
- π MN26: "not even has Alaro Kalamo..." or "not only Alaro Kalamo has ..." or "Alaro Kalamo has not only..."?
- π Normal Deep Breathing vs Buddhism Basic Meditation
- π Mindful meditation, problems with anger. Where do I find other Buddhist for learning support?
- π What was the 1st Buddhist Council about?
- π Proper way of offering
- π Do predatory animals gain bad karma?
- π Why should we stop the Samsara?
- π Ignoring thoughts vs. understanding them
- π Did Buddha ever deny the existence of God?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π Does any/every form of lying violate the precept of "not-lying"?
- π Does not keeping a promise violate the precept on lying? What if I promised myself?
- π Does illegal downloading or viewing of copyright material violate the second precept?
- π Does using a pdf for sale for free violate the 2nd precept?
- π Does the fifth precept ban smoking?
- π Does any sutta talk about the right conditions for teaching the Dhamma?
- π Does the second precept only apply to theft?
- π Does the first precept require me to check the shower for bugs and make sure to remove all of the bugs before using it?
- π Does consume eggs and fish oil violate the first precept?
- π Does every Buddha have knowledge of the past, present and future?
- π Does any other sect of Buddhism have the stages of insight?
- π How, if at all, does karma exist in the form and formless realms?
- π Does any Theravada Suttas / sources refer to Oozing orifices? What are the Suttas?
- π Are the formless jhanas without any consciouness of form at all?
- π Are there any stories dealing with stalkers or people who violate boundaries in seeking to grow close in the texts?
- π Does it make any sense to read the four noble truths parallel to the Buddhaghosa's 4 interpretations of the nidanas
- π Does the mental process of assigning subjective qualities to any phenomenon have a name in the suttas?
- π Can an Icchantika make any form of progress along the Buddhist path?
- π Does the Buddha have any practices for groups and societies that would lead society to less suffering, prosperity, not decay?
- π Masturbation: Does it break the 3rd precept?
- π Have any Buddhist thinkers responded to the critique of the Brahma Sutras?
- π Why does the Buddha call himself the TathΔgata?
- π Enlightened Lies - Can lying be the correct action in certain situations?
- π Found items and the Second Precept
- π How does one explain consistency within phenomena if the mind generates phenomena?
- π What does it mean to 'advert' to the factors of jhana after emerging from jhana?
- π Is there any significance to shaving the head?
- π Are there any alternative formulations of the five skandas?
- π What does breaking the fetter 'Clinging to rites and rituals' actually mean?
- π In terms of reliability of understanding reality, how does the scientific method compare with Buddhist insight practice?