How should a lay person respond if they see a monk teaching something contrary to Dhamma?
score:2
The word sangha is used nowadays to refer to the bhikkhus. This may or may not be true. One does not have to be a bhikkhu to belong to the sangha. An Upāsaka (male) or Upāsikā (female) - lay followers – could also be part of Arya Sangha. Upāsaka and Upāsikā are part of Ariya Sangha, once in the Path. The Ariya Sangha is described as all those who have attained at least the stage of Stream Entrant.
A bhikkhu is someone who has renounced the life of a layman to dedicate himself exclusively to practice, realization, study and teaching of the dhamma. But in the present day and age, there are a great number of bhikkus who have not come to the stage of Stream Entrant. Thus they are not part of Arya Sangha.
There were times when Hattha Āḷavaka Ugga gahapati (householder) preached dhamma to the Bhikkus at the time of Buddha, when no one else came forward to speak on Dhamma..
The Buddha does not advocate superficial unity for its own sake between bhikkhus or amongst bhikkhus and lay followers at the expense of the Dhamma. Buddha instead encourages that the Dhamma be clearly defended against non-Dhamma and that the distinction between the two be kept clear.
Buddha has described in no less than six suttas about what one should do at such an instant. In the Sangha Bedha Sutta (AN 10.1.4.7), Buddha’s instruction is to not advocate superficial unity for its own sake at the expense of the Dhamma, but instead encourages that the Dhamma be clearly defended against non-Dhamma and that the distinction between the two be kept clear. According to the Vinaya, a speaker of non-Dhamma is to be recognized as such if he “explains not-Dhamma as ‘Dhamma’ … Dhamma as ‘not-Dhamma’ … not-Vinaya as ‘Vinaya’ … Vinaya as ‘not-Vinaya’ …
Thus the ability to take a stand requires that one be well-informed about the Buddha’s teachings. A difference of opinion can be rightfully ended only if both sides are able to investigate the grounds and get to the root, and then resolve which side was right, based on the Dhamma and Vinaya.
For more about the Sangha Bedha Sutta, see the Suttas on pages 1389 through 1391 which are titled Schism(1), Schism(2), and Ananda(1) in The Numerical Discourses of the Buddha: A Complete Translation of the Anguttara Nikaya – by Bhikkhu Bodhi; and Schism in the Sangha by Thanissaro Bhikkhu & Geshe Rabten .
Upvote:0
Ignorant monk must avoid ignorant monk.
Ignorant monk must avoid ignorant layman.
Ignorant layman must avoid ignorant monk.
Ignorant layman must avoid ignorant layman.
Graduated monks/laymans must know who is possible to enlighten after listen their teaching. They also must know who will never understand their teaching to avoid them.
You must know ṭhana and aṭhana before decide to do something. See dhammaññūsutta.
What mahavihara theravada buddhist monks must memorized and learn?
see: Beginer Buddhist Course Syllabus By Ancient Pali Canon (Ganthadhura And Vipassanādhura)
Upvote:1
The suttas state in places (I can't quote all of them off-hand) that laypeople should strongly critique the behaviour of monks before establishing faith in those monks. Example, MN 95:
Here, Bhāradvāja, a bhikkhu may be living in dependence on some village or town. Then a householder or a householder’s son goes to him and investigates him in regard to three kinds of states in regard to states based on greed, in regard to states based on hate, and in regard to states based on delusion. MN 95
Misbehaviour of monks can be reported to other monks.
Note that it was often lay people's criticism that brought the monk's wrong doings to the attention of the Buddha.
The suttas rarely report the Buddha taught lay people the 4 truths but, instead, the Buddha mostly teaches laypeople to develop morality for a heavenly rebirth.
For example, in his 1st sermon (SN 56.11), the Buddha states the 4 truths are for those who have left the household life.
Bhikkhus, these two extremes should not be followed by one who has gone forth into homelessness. What two? The pursuit of sensual happiness in sensual pleasures, which is low, vulgar, the way of worldlings, ignoble, unbeneficial; and the pursuit of self-mortification, which is painful, ignoble, unbeneficial. Without veering towards either of these extremes, the Tathagata has awakened to the middle way, which gives rise to vision, which gives rise to knowledge, which leads to peace, to direct knowledge, to enlightenment, to Nibbāna. SN 56.11
DN 31 states the duty of a monk is to teach the path to heaven (and not Nibbana).
The ascetics and brahmans thus ministered to as the Zenith by a householder show their compassion towards him in six ways:
(i) they restrain him from evil,
(ii) they persuade him to do good,
(iii) they love him with a kind heart,
(iv) they make him hear what he has not heard,
(v) they clarify what he has already heard,
(vi) they point out the path to a heavenly state.
DN 31
MN 143 describes how the teaching of non-attachment was rarely taught to Buddhist lay people but to only those gone forth.
This sort of talk on the Dhamma, householder, is not given to lay people clad in white. This sort of talk on the Dhamma is given to those gone forth. MN 143
Upvote:1
You must first look to things within your own control that could contribute to or even cause the behavior you observed. A minor change on OUR part can often lead to the results you desire and not bring embarrassment to a colleague.
A person is only in our world of awareness because we choose them to be so we must always examine the weakness we observed from our own perspective first. WE control our world.
damyata datta dayadhvam
More post
- 📝 Why does the Buddha, in the Pali Canon, periodically engage in harsh speech?
- 📝 Is a Daruma doll a good motivation to meditate ?
- 📝 How important is patience in buddhism?
- 📝 What kind of vipassana retreats do you recommend in South East Asia?
- 📝 can you help translate dhammpada 183?
- 📝 How to work for liberating ALL living beings?
- 📝 What is a Tao Buddhist?
- 📝 What are the arguments behind the relatively late dating of Khuddaka Nikaya and Abhidhamma Pitaka?
- 📝 If we have the law of karma, why do we need other laws, or do we?
- 📝 Ultimate Reality
- 📝 As Buddhists, what do you make out of the tragedy of Tibet?
- 📝 How is possible that monks memorised 10.000 sutras?
- 📝 Is this nibbana or god?
- 📝 Was the Buddha a vegetarian?
- 📝 Wish to Circumambulate around Mt. Kailash
- 📝 What is the opinion of Buddhism on the caste system and untouchability of Hinduism?
- 📝 Working with cycles in meditation
- 📝 Did Gautama Buddha really intend to create a new religion?
- 📝 Computers and Buddhist monks, offering computer to monk makes bad karma to both monk and donor?
- 📝 I want to understand the technicality of rebirth and what happens to conditioned self
- 📝 Did the Buddha discourage antropomorphic representations of himself?
- 📝 Modernity and black magic can coexist?
- 📝 Where does Gautam Buddha say so?
- 📝 What would be some very concise Buddhist teachings and symbols that could be on (future) coinage?
- 📝 which is better staying in present moment or being aware?
- 📝 Was Vipassana discovered by the Buddha (Siddhartha)?
- 📝 Has any pilgrimage customs formed in North America?
- 📝 When is it love? When is it attachment?
- 📝 How do I control my mind?
- 📝 How do ethics work in Shin Buddhism?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 How should a lay person respond if they see a monk teaching something contrary to Dhamma?
- 📝 What are the guides for lay followers, as to how far they should go to be compassionate?
- 📝 How should lay buddhists respond to amoral people?
- 📝 How should a married person get ordained in Theravada Buddhism?
- 📝 How can a lay person approach the learning process of Buddhism?
- 📝 How should a monk address subjective questions?
- 📝 How should a theravada centre approach the lay people for support?
- 📝 How worried should one be about the lay precepts?
- 📝 How do I practice ' see things as they are'?
- 📝 How should a bodhisattva respond to evil?
- 📝 How should I respond to people who fake suffering?
- 📝 How to let go of something the other person involved won't acknowledge
- 📝 If a buddhist should not kill a mouse living in their home, what justification do they have to rid themselves of a parasite such tapeworms
- 📝 How should Buddhists handle prayer requests?
- 📝 How concerned should Buddhists be with the actions of others?
- 📝 How can I respond to Christians' unpleasant feedback on Buddhism?
- 📝 How and when should a child be introduced to Buddhism?
- 📝 How does one become a lay Buddhist?
- 📝 How can you see suffering in the breath?
- 📝 How should a Buddhist approach honoring parents who abused them?
- 📝 Should Lay Buddhists Teach the Dhamma?
- 📝 How does one escape suffering when they cannot provide for those they love
- 📝 When and how should someone practice Patikulamanasikara meditation (reflections of replusiveness)
- 📝 Can a lay person become an Arahant according to the Suttas?
- 📝 How does a monk address parents and relatives?
- 📝 How should I view others sufferings I cannot affect?
- 📝 Is Buddhism something that you should study?
- 📝 How should satipatthana be understood in regard to external/internal minds?
- 📝 How should I stop thinking that I am even slightly enlightened?
- 📝 How does a person enter the 1st bhumi