score:2
Tir na nOg Times Square at 315 W. 39th St. has a huge gathering of Patriots fans every week. It had about 60 fans last week but it seats 300+, so there's room for everyone and no one has to stand. It's an older and more upscale crowd than at at typical football bar, but the prices are quite reasonable because of the NFL specials.
Here is more info on the group that attends: