Creating a "focused research question" for a history paper, unsure how to create a question that inspires debate
Upvote:1
Creating a history question is a fourth year (Australian “honours,” US “masters”) problem.
A historical question ought to bring theory into intersection with a gap in knowledge into intersection with a gap in literature.
“Debate,” is a pretty poor measure. Historiography documents debates amongst historians. Historians document debates amongst the people and institutions of the past.
Your second attempt at a question is facile because it requests an enumerated list. It wrongly creates a category “the south.” For historians categories have to be one of two things. Categories either have a theoretical basis, which requires a theoretical framework (“rural extraction economy planter bourgeois in a world systems framework”). Or categories need to be found in the documentary record of the past. Here we wouldn’t import a category from the past without saying whose category it is.
Finally, we should be particularly suspicious of declaring descriptive or theoretical categories as agents. Only humans and deliberate associations of humans display historical agency. Other descriptions of groups of people might have behaviour that arises from combinations and conflicts of agents, but they don’t display choice, as these descriptive or theoretical groups emerge in analysis not in self organisation.
This is an even worse flaw in a question if the existence of the category is tenuous, ie: debated or emergent only within a certain analysis. You can get away with a bit of shorthand here, “the proletariat” in a rising condition of class struggle is normally considered as the militant section of the working class whose self-conscious debates have been eliminated from the record as they were oral or recorded with all identification removed due to expected persecution. And even here doing so means you align your project with a strong theoretical tradition and then need to negotiate the limits and difficulties of such a position.
For example, in relation to the ruling vibe in Australia’s long 1950s: “Harold Holt,” was an agent in Australian history; “The Liberal/National cabinet” similarly. However “Nationals voters,” is a description from the time of a non-organised body, and “state dependent squatocracy,” is a contemporary theoretical category which wasn’t self organising at the time for deliberate decision making.
To give and explain an example question covering the above, “Does Foucaults conception of discipline as applied to education explain the State of Georgia’s funding of teacher numbers and teacher selection in public education for black children in the 1920s?”
Theory, evaluation of extent required, a specific actual agent (institution here), a knowable and limited domain (numbers and criteria), a specific subject (Georgian children who were black) and a specific time.
Crafting a question is more than half the battle. Ensuring that it is limited but presents “why” problems is important. In closing, remember that the question needs to animate your historical imagination sufficiently for you to enjoy doing the work. But do try to pick small digestible problems with a clear and easy way to complete your analysis in a timely way.
More post
- 📝 Did Tirol annex land (right flank of Val d'Avigna) from Switzerland between 1859 and 1869?
- 📝 Why is the storming of the Bastille considered the start of revolution, and not the storming of the Hôtel des Invalides?
- 📝 Was there car insurance in the USSR?
- 📝 What cult images are likely to be found in a Second Punic war era Roman field camp?
- 📝 Did Benjamin Franklin say "Holland is not a nation but a shop"? Why?
- 📝 Is there contemporary evidence for the Roman Kingdom?
- 📝 What would be the GDP of the Roman Empire?
- 📝 Why is the color red associated with communism?
- 📝 When were domesticated animals tethered on a pole with a rope?
- 📝 Which head of state had the most gaps in their rule?
- 📝 Did the 1st Marine Division use the M3 carbine on Okinawa?
- 📝 What is the difference between "diallektes" and "aesymnetes"?
- 📝 How common were fires in pre-Edo Japan?
- 📝 What was the death toll during the Inquisition?
- 📝 Why is Nazi Germany called a "fascist" regime?
- 📝 Why did Native Americans die from European diseases while Europeans didn't catch serious diseases from the New World?
- 📝 State changing its name within the United States
- 📝 Is Benedict XVI the first pope emeritus?
- 📝 How popular was Mozart in France before WWII and after it?
- 📝 How did medieval manors handle population growth? Was there room for more fields to be ploughed?
- 📝 How were large monetary transactions conducted in medieval Europe?
- 📝 Did German citizens need a visa to enter Switzerland in 1945?
- 📝 Did medieval kingdoms issue health related guidelines?
- 📝 What did the ancient Egyptians think of Khufu?
- 📝 Why did a Venetian colonel defect to the Ottomans during the siege of Candia?
- 📝 Why did marriage and multiple children make Hurrem Sultan special?
- 📝 Cultural history of Saudi Arabian rulers' uniform beard style?
- 📝 How did the South USA become more overtly Christian than the North?
- 📝 What became of Nazi Germany's embassies in neutral countries?
- 📝 How many Jewish refugee have been expelled out of Arab lands and when?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Creating a "focused research question" for a history paper, unsure how to create a question that inspires debate
- 📝 How did German unification affect existing sentences for criminal convicts?
- 📝 How did Nazi Germany produce such an impressive portfolio of officers for WW2?
- 📝 How did medieval manors handle population growth? Was there room for more fields to be ploughed?
- 📝 How was titanium transported from Soviet Union to Area 51 for Oxcart?
- 📝 Japan is known for being isolationist, so what cultivated its history of interventionism in the 20th century?
- 📝 How long did it take for a diplomat to travel between Berlin and Vienna in the 1770's?
- 📝 How come every culture on the planet has a different calendar, yet follow the same system for a week?
- 📝 How did ancient empires account for slow propagation of information e.g. in their legal codes?
- 📝 How to research controversial history?
- 📝 What historical reasons did the Nazis give for hating the Jews? How did they identify non-practicing Jews?
- 📝 How long did it take for a letter to arrive in England in the 1830s?
- 📝 In the first half of 20th century, how was gold inspected for authenticity?
- 📝 How is the discipline of History differentiated from other disciplines in social sciences or the humanities?
- 📝 When and how did the West lose its dependency on the USSR for Titanium?
- 📝 How profitable was India for the British Empire in the 1800s?
- 📝 How were taxes collected for traveling merchants in the middle ages?
- 📝 How aware were the latter Greek-speaking Romans (ERE: Byzantines) of the early history of Rome?
- 📝 How common was it for people to live 80+ years in the 17th century?
- 📝 How common was it for un-documented ships to bring settlers to the American colonies 1700-1750
- 📝 How can I properly learn the history of a country whose language I don't speak or read?
- 📝 How were the holes for the guns in battleships' turrets protected?
- 📝 For how long were freed slaves in Ancient Rome supposed to wear a Pileus hat?
- 📝 How many acres per person were needed for the early American settlers vs. the native Americans?
- 📝 How did people apply for university in the 18th century?
- 📝 Where and how did the allies scrounge enough food for the Soviets AND the British?
- 📝 How have African countries kept the boundaries divided by colonists and countries unified for decades, despite the many ethnical groups and conflicts?
- 📝 How strong a land force did Germany need for a conquest of the British Isles in the summer of 1940?
- 📝 In the Soviet Union, how was payment enforced for public transportation?
- 📝 How is progress in history made?