Did the US really consider demonstrating the atomic bomb to the Japanese by "blowing the top" off of Mt. Fuji?
Upvote:4
A 20KT warhead is probably very much on the low end of what a volcano can do and how much damage a surface explosion it would do to a mountain is debatable. Mount St. Helens was a 24MT equivalent, from the inside, for example.
Both Hiroshima/Nagasaki drops were airbursts.
A groundburst on Fuji might have turned out to be anything but benign if it churned up a lot of irradiated earth and dropped fallout in the neighborhood. Fallout profiles with bombs depend on many factors, but higher altitude bursts result in "cleaner", less-permanent radiation. However, I also really don't know how much they knew or expected regarding fallout, so it's unclear whether considerations about it would have been a factor.
Last, but not least, you and most press coverage nowadays are looking at the atomic bombs from the point of view of late 20th century aversion (relatively speaking) of civilian casualties.
In WW2 high enemy civilian casualty rates were a feature, not a bug, and the A-bomb was truly novel only in its immediacy and apparent ease of use. Wide revulsion and mutually assured destruction would only come later. Some of the Tokyo raids caused on the same order of civilians deaths in one night.
Not sure when Western countries started avoiding, or at least claiming to avoid, civilian casualties, but even as late as the Vietnam War some consideration was given to bombing dikes which might have caused near 200K deaths.
p.s. as regards the linked article, I have a really, really, hard time taking anyone seriously who cherry picks casualty estimates as they did:
As Stanford historian Barton Bernstein has noted, the U.S. Joint War Plans Committee predicted in mid-June 1945 that the invasion of Japan, set to begin Nov. 1, would result in 193,000 U.S. casualties, including 40,000 deaths.
The invasion of Okinawa, a much more limited affair, had already incurred US casualties as follows, so quoting any 40K dead estimate is raving lunacy or flagrant intellectual dishonesty.
14,009 to 20,195 dead/ 12,520 killed in action/ 38,000 to 55,162 wounded
and at 40K-150K civilians killed as well, a good deal of it due to mainland Japanese coercion, there was considerable ethical justification in wanting to avoid repeating it on the main island.
Upvote:15
"US" and "consider" are rather broad terms. I can't find any evidence that the Manhattan Project targeting committee ever considered anything other than conventional military targets, but there were plenty of other people throwing out ideas of what should be hit.
A rather informal analysis of "blowing the top off a mountain" was done in the form of the Trinity test. The verdict was that a surface detonation of a 20-kiloton bomb would produce a crater about ten meters wide and a meter deep -- a rather unimpressive outcome.
I seriously doubt any formal analysis would have been done. Any demolitions expert could give you the answer in about five seconds: detonating explosives on the surface of a solid object is completely ineffective at causing meaningful damage to that object. In order to blow the top off a mountain with Fat Man or Little Boy, you'd need to drill a hole and lower the bomb into it.
More post
- 📝 Was Julius Caesar a hippie?
- 📝 To what extent did Gandhi affect the factors that led to the partition of India?
- 📝 Were the Roman Empire provinces Alpes Poeninae and Alpes Graiae different provinces or the same?
- 📝 Perception of the state by an average person in pre-modern times
- 📝 Can anyone find an image of Henry Bolingbroke's Sovereygne Feather Seal?
- 📝 What evidence do we have to claim the Ancient Romans kept African grey parrots as pets?
- 📝 What would a Norseman in the early 11th century have worn as daily clothing?
- 📝 Why did Robert E. Lee say that George McClellan was the best general he ever faced?
- 📝 Did German aircraft operate off Lebanon in 1941?
- 📝 Did America help the Chinese nationalists to repel the communist advance?
- 📝 What is the significance of "Flappers" in American history?
- 📝 How did British people cope with damp/mould without central heating in the past?
- 📝 Why did Charles I not borrow abroad?
- 📝 Mass distribution of the Macedonian Sarissa pike
- 📝 What's the Ancient Egyptian word for "benedict"?
- 📝 What was the first recorded reference to the fact that the sun rises and sets at different times across the Earth?
- 📝 How long did it take to make a 16th century arrow?
- 📝 Was there a coup in the Netherlands in 1672?
- 📝 What happened to people who lived outside a castle when the castle was under siege?
- 📝 Did most major ancient cultures (e.g. the Mesopotamians) consider the heart as the main cognitive organ?
- 📝 Does Tanjore Brihadeeswarar Temple contain more stones than Giza pyramid?
- 📝 What was the official theoretical journal of the communist party of the USSR?
- 📝 Is there a Buddhist-Franciscan connection?
- 📝 Why has Iran's GDP shrunk over the last three decades?
- 📝 What heavy industrial work, if any, was done in USSR 1923-1927?
- 📝 Have the current polar ice caps receded further than those that existed before the beginning of the last Ice Age?
- 📝 What was the situation of h*m*sexuals in the early Soviet Union?
- 📝 Did classical Romans wear any sort of swimwear?
- 📝 Why haven't Etruscan texts survived?
- 📝 How did Lincoln know to stick with Grant before the completion of the Vicksburg campaign?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Did the US really consider demonstrating the atomic bomb to the Japanese by "blowing the top" off of Mt. Fuji?
- 📝 Did Soviet Union really consider using atomic bomb against US aircraft battlegroup?
- 📝 Did Heisenberg undermine the German atomic bomb by deliberately hiding his expertise from the Nazis?
- 📝 Did the United States have a third atomic bomb to drop on Japan?
- 📝 Why did the Germans fall behind the Americans in the development of the atomic bomb after an initial lead?
- 📝 What relief efforts did the Japanese attempt after the atomic bombings?
- 📝 What did the Japanese believe about the USA capability of making/using additional atomic bombs?
- 📝 How many times did the US experiment before dropping the atomic bomb in Japan?
- 📝 Did the third US atomic bomb disappear without a trace?
- 📝 Did the citizens of US really back the declaration of war on Japanese Empire as it was implied by F.D. Roosevelt in his Pearl Harbor Speech?
- 📝 How did the Soviet Union support the development of their atomic bomb in 1949?
- 📝 Were there high-ranking Japanese POW as witness at the Trinity Atomic Bomb Test?
- 📝 Did Albert Einstein really receive this rejection letter from the University of Bern?
- 📝 Why did the Soviet Union name their strongest bomb Tsar Bomba?
- 📝 When/how did Harry Truman give the order to bomb Hiroshima?
- 📝 Why did Meiji government consider switching from Japanese to English?
- 📝 What do the modern Japanese people think about the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki?
- 📝 When Israel won the Six Day War, did they consider expelling all Arabs from the annexed territories?
- 📝 Given their reputation for fighting to the last man in the Pacific, why did 700,000 Japanese troops surrender in Manchuria?
- 📝 Why did the Japanese expect the United States navy would attack the Home Islands?
- 📝 Did the Celts really go into battle naked?
- 📝 Did Catherine the Great really call for the abolition of serfdom?
- 📝 Why did the United States drop a uranium bomb instead of a plutonium bomb on Hiroshima?
- 📝 Why did the Japanese withdraw from Siberia in 1922?
- 📝 Did American policymakers seriously consider scaling down Lend Lease Aid to the Soviet Union after the battle of Kursk?
- 📝 Did the US and Soviet navies really come close to blows in the Indian Ocean in 1971?
- 📝 When did the Soviets get the ability to drop a nuclear bomb on the United States?
- 📝 Why did the Japanese attack the Aleutians at the same time as Midway?
- 📝 Did the Seljuk consider themselves Roman?
- 📝 Did a Japanese medieval castle withstand US battleship fire during the Pacific War?