What factors prevented the legality of secession being pursued via the courts prior to the outbreak of the Civil War?
Upvote:0
No judicial but legislative ruling required to make secession legal (at least as the first step).
Secessionists could introduce secession bill to the Congress, and if they did, most likely they could get peaceful separation (considering that Corwin Amendment passed Congress even without votes of seven seceding states).
If bill failed, they could bring the case against Congress decision to the court.
If bill passed but president still don't recognize secession, they could try to impeach him or bring the case against executive branch to the court.
Without this congressional attempt, they did not have case.
Upvote:6
The main problem that secessionists would have faced in court is that the question had been settled over 40 years before the Civil War: secession was illegal.
The only argument that supports unilateral secession, where a state just decides to leave and that's sufficient, is called "Compact Theory". The theory is that the US is not a single nation, but a "compact" between Sovereign states, somewhat like a League of Nations. Any nation can unilaterally dissolve a treaty: likewise, under Compact Theory any state could dissolve its participation in the union.
Compact Theory had a long and distinguished history in American politics. Jefferson was a proponent, and at least for a while so was Madison. But Compact Theory was rejected by the US Supreme Court three times before 1820:
- Chisholm v. Georgia (1793)
- Martin v. Hunter's Lessee (1816)
- McCulloch v. Maryland (1819)
So there was no legal leg for unilateral secession. (It's interesting to note that in all 3 cases, the sitting court was majority-Southern.) If secessionists wanted to pursue a strategy of "legal" secession, it would have to be cooperative, "consensual" secession, agreed to by both parties. The only conceivable mechanism for that would probably be the formula from the Articles of Confederation and Perpetual Union: "such alteration be agreed to in a Congress of the United States, and be afterwards confirmed by the legislatures of every State." No way in hell would the legislatures of EVERY state agree to it.
And anyway, that process would be agonizingly slow. Measured in years. The secessionists were men of action who needed to strike while the iron was hot. As Oldcat writes, they were not interested in a court case, nor in a protracted legislative process. They needed to secede before anyone could stop them, and then make it stick by force of arms.
It's also worth noting that they (or most of them) thought they were too big to lose. The Confederacy was an area about the size of Spain + Italy + France + Germany + Poland PUT TOGETHER. No one thought Federal forces could conquer and hold an area that large: British and French military observers told their governments that the North would ultimately lose the war, the only question being how long it would take them to accept reality.
So the factors for the secessionists are:
- No legal basis.
- Necessity for a bold stroke.
- Strong expectation they would win in any military follow-up.
Upvote:9
Nobody was interested in a court case. Those who thought it was undoable had no reason for a suit, and those who wanted secession needed it as a bold stroke to rally the more undecided Southern factions to their banner. Secession had failed in 1832 and 1850 once people took the time to consider the matter. Secessionists in 1860 needed for it to be a reality before anyone could back down. They thought that most of the moderate Southerners would join them rather than use force on them, and for the most part this was so.
More post
- 📝 How many Manila Galleons were sacked and by whom?
- 📝 What was located at the site of Madison Square Garden in 1850?
- 📝 Were the mongol army boots of 13th century lined with fur?
- 📝 Why were bows referred to as "Indian Artillery"?
- 📝 What Happened To Men In the Soviet Union?
- 📝 What was the wage of the soldiers serving in the CEF compared to the soldiers serving in the British army?
- 📝 Is this accusation in the Declaration of Independence factual?
- 📝 Was Red Orchestra led by Jews?
- 📝 Did a German Jew in the US Army save his home district from bombing?
- 📝 How could Poles from Kresy be enough to repopulate entire regions of Poland?
- 📝 How did Native Americans defend militarily?
- 📝 In which year of the post-WWII Occupation of Japan was the Imperial Rescript on Education repealed?
- 📝 What to do about historical Wikipedia articles contradicting each other in different languages?
- 📝 What turns a man into a tyrant?
- 📝 What did medical treatments for fractured or broken bones cost in 1900-1915?
- 📝 Why is the US Independent in 1776 but the first President isn't inaugurated until 1789?
- 📝 What was the biggest empire that never had capital punishment?
- 📝 Why Italy during the interwar years and ww2 didn't devote adequate resources to develop weapons against armored fight vehicles (AFVs) including tanks?
- 📝 How did militaries dispose of their rubbish in WWII?
- 📝 What were Rommel's views on the Nazi crimes?
- 📝 What was horse population & growth in Northern UK 1500 to 1850?
- 📝 Which nations have armed prisoners and sent them to war?
- 📝 How economically profitable for Nazi Germany were the occupied countries in Western Europe?
- 📝 What kind of suspension did Roman carrucae have?
- 📝 Why do people not talk about Tokyo fire bombing during WW2?
- 📝 Was the British Empire financially capable of maintaining India as a colony after WW2?
- 📝 Was the king of England able to execute a high rank noble and his family between 1216 and 1688?
- 📝 Is there mutual significance in the year 1807, so far as abolition of the slave trade in Britain and the United States is concerned?
- 📝 How long was the Treaty of Versailles intended to be in order?
- 📝 Is it true that many great ancient warriors were vegan?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 What factors prevented the legality of secession being pursued via the courts prior to the outbreak of the Civil War?
- 📝 What are the factors that caused the new world civilizations to be less technologically advanced than the old world?
- 📝 What Factors Have Led to the Duration of US Copyrights Continuously Increasing?
- 📝 What was the longest a World War II submarine stayed at sea without being resupplied at a port?
- 📝 Japan is known for being isolationist, so what cultivated its history of interventionism in the 20th century?
- 📝 What prevented the Mongolian Empire from expanding into Europe?
- 📝 What factors enabled Europe to conquer almost the whole world?
- 📝 What was the policy on academic research being published beyond the iron curtain?
- 📝 What were the key factors to the fall of domestic socialism in the USA?
- 📝 What is the historical reason for 18 years being the most commonly accepted age of adulthood?
- 📝 What happened to all the nuclear material being smuggled after the fall of the USSR?
- 📝 What factors related to the Eastern Crisis contributed to the outbreak of World War 1?
- 📝 What were the factors that caused the world to move away from the Gold Standard in the 20th century?
- 📝 What factors discouraged the Nazis from focusing all their forces on the Caucasus region during Operation Barbarossa?
- 📝 What technological/economic factors triggered the Industrial Revolution?
- 📝 What factors contributed to Jews moving out of the Middle East?
- 📝 What were the factors that aided Margaret Thatcher in her victory against the trade unions when her predecessors failed?
- 📝 What factors contributed to the popularity of Eastern cultures in the USA in late 20th century?
- 📝 What is the origin of currency signs being placed before the numerical value?
- 📝 What Factors Contributed to the Success of Certain "Long March" Strategies?
- 📝 Approximately what was the short-term economic loss to Britain as a result of the Revolutionary War being lost?
- 📝 What is the history of the legality of polygamy in Arab states?
- 📝 To what extent did Gandhi affect the factors that led to the partition of India?
- 📝 What were the motivating factors in the Scottish Highland Clearances?
- 📝 What was the first recorded instance of sex or violence being inappropriate for children to see?
- 📝 What factors led to the 30% devaluation of pound sterling in 1949?
- 📝 What were factors that led to a decline in bond yields during World War II given that the opposite should have happened?
- 📝 What was the consequence of Gestapo being declared a criminal organization in the Nuremberg trials in 1945?
- 📝 What factors contributed to the rise of national monarchies in the high middle ages?
- 📝 What were the factors that led to stagflation in the United States during the 1970s?