Did Thomas Aquinas rate masturbation as a greater sin than rape?
score:4
In Question 154. The parts of Lust, Aquinas orders them in descending order: masturbation, incest, rape of a wife, rape of a virgin, adultery.
The reason he gives is "In every genus, worst of all is the corruption of the principle on which the rest depend".
He's not judging based on "a sexual matter" as well as "other sinful factors". He isn't saying that masturbation is -100 for being against nature, rape is -0 because it's not against nature, but rape is -200 because it's violent.
Aquinas is saying that crimes against nature trump all other ways something is considered a sin. Nothing else need be considered, if it's against nature. Nothing compares in offense to being against nature, in Aquinas' opinion.
Upvote:18
Here is what Aquinas actually wrote:
In each kind of thing the worst corruption is the corruption of the principle on which other things depend. Now the principles of reason are the things in accord in nature⦠and therefore, to act against what is determined by nature, is most serious and base. Therefore since in the sins against nature man transgress what is determined by nature in regard to sex, the sin in this matter is the gravest kind of sin. After this is incest⦠while by the other species of lust one transgresses only that which is determined according to right reason, but presupposing the natural principles. But it is more contrary to reason to have sex not only contrary to the good of the offspring to be born, but also with injury to another. And therefore simple fornication, which is committed without injury to another person, is the least kind of lust.
Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 154, a. 12
It's from a passage where Aquinas is talking about different kinds of sin. There are, for example, sexual sins; sins against justice; sins against charity; sins directly against God. Any sinful act can fall under one or more categories.
Aquinas' point is that, considering only the sexual element, an unnatural act is worse than a natural one, and that's why he says masturbation is a worse sexual sin than rape. However masturbation is essentially only a sexual act, and rape has other sinful elements - it is also a sin against justice and a sin against charity.
It's like we are grading sins on many scales. Masturbation scores worse than rape on the sex scale, but it doesn't score at all on the charity or justice scales. Rape on the other hand scores moderately on the sex scale, but very badly on the justice and charity scales. Overall, rape is worse than masturbation. The church has never taught anything different.
Most of this answer is taken from: Aquinas on Sexual Sins
More post
- π Does the Catholic Church oppose universalism?
- π Was Jesus a separate god?
- π What could account for this 1990 radical change in belief about the German school of Higher Criticism (that began around 1860)?
- π What is the difference between Protestantism and Evangelicalism?
- π Did God create man to replace the fallen Angels?
- π Were we to remain in the Garden of Paradise forever if Adam had not sinned?
- π Is Matthew 26:32 and John 20:9 a mistake stating that Jesus told the disciples He would rise again then stating they didn't know after it happened?
- π How many children did Adam and Eve have?
- π Why does the apostle John write far more clearly about the deity of Christ than seems to be the case in the other gospel accounts?
- π Is the Militia of the Immaculata a sect within the Catholic branch of Christianity?
- π The Greatest Commandment - Loving God with all our 1) heart, 2) soul, and 3) strength
- π On what basis was Jesusβ death sufficient for redemption according Non-Trinitarians who maintain that Jesus was not eternal God as God the Father is?
- π Transcript of This Ven. Fulton Sheen Talk on the Christian Laity?
- π Can a Roman Catholic be re-catechized and re-confirmed?
- π Where and/or when did the tradition that Methuselah died seven days before the Flood (for a period of mourning) originate?
- π Where is it documented that some people didn't want Gospel of John to be included as canonical?
- π What was the "Sect of Nicolaus" and did elements of it's influence carry down to our day?
- π How do we know that Satan, Lucifer, and Devil are the same guy?
- π What does the Catholic Church mean by "beatific vision"?
- π Is being thankful for Jesus' death biblical?
- π Why did St. Monica defer St. Augustine's baptism?
- π Is the Pope the Antichrist or the spirit of the Antichrist?
- π Why didn't Protestants argue for traditional marriage by natural reason?
- π Is there a Catholic ceremony for virgins who are not nuns or sisters?
- π Did Mormons have a "blood oath" ceremony before April 1990?
- π What exactly do we know about Heaven?
- π What is an overview of how different Christian denominations deal with demon possessions?
- π What are the biblical arguments against Arianism?
- π Why would God permit divorce because of Israel's "hardness of heart"?
- π Should protestants not make the sign of the Cross?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π Did Thomas Aquinas rate masturbation as a greater sin than rape?
- π What lost bible commentary did St. Thomas Aquinas want more than an entire kingdom?
- π Did Aquinas rate rage as worse than sexual sins?
- π How did Thomas Aquinas view grace as opposed to the church fathers?
- π Did Thomas Pearne do anything other than contradict Granville Sharp?
- π Did St. Thomas Aquinas write anything about historiography?
- π What did Jesus mean by "whoever believes in me will do greater works than I do"?
- π According to the Catholic Church, what did Jesus mean by saying that the least in the kingdom of heaven in greater than John the Baptist?
- π Did Martin Luther say "There is no greater sinner than the Christian church"?
- π Where did Aquinas say that the "greatest penalty of sin is the loss of the sense of sin"?
- π Did St. Thomas Aquinas deny the Holy Spirit proceeds immediately from the Father alone?
- π Where did St. Thomas Aquinas say Mary approached the borders of the Hypostatic Union?
- π What did St. Thomas Aquinas write about Christ's passion?
- π What did Thomas Aquinas teach about the renewal of the world after judgement and what kinds of bodies will be renewed?
- π What did Jesus mean when he said βGo and sin no moreβ if sinlessness is impossible?
- π Can one sin be worse than another sin, or are all sins equal?
- π Why did the KJV translators translate ΧΧΧΧ on the extremely rare occasion as IEHOVAH rather than LORD?
- π Why did God make it a sin to eat an apple?
- π Did Aquinas believe that church bells ward off bad weather?
- π Did St. Thomas come to India?
- π Did any early church fathers, other than Augustine, condemn or write about numerology?
- π Did Jesus die earlier than expected?
- π How is love greater than faith?
- π Did Thomas actually touch Jesus's side?
- π Why did Pope Francis say, "When we encounter the Cross, do we turn to Mary," rather than to Christ?
- π What did Aquinas do for recreation?
- π At the greater emergence of democracy in Europe during the 'Enlightenment' did the papacy support democracy?
- π On what basis does Thomas Aquinas say that the Church existed since the time of Abel?
- π According to a βforgiveness in Christ aloneβ framework how did βsin offeringsβ make atonement for sin under the Mosaic Law?
- π Why did Aquinas place so much credence in Aristotle?