What did Papias mean when he wrote how Mark did not write "in order" about what Jesus said or did?
Upvote:2
Papias is quoting a first-century Christian Elder in defending the Gospel of Mark against critics. Apparently, already by this time, some were criticizing the Gospel of Mark because it was not considered "orderly".
Orderly compared to what?
The Elder's statement implies a standard against which Mark was being compared. Commonly suggested candidates include:
- The Gospel of Matthew (the document that overlaps with the Gospel of Mark in content more than any other)
- The Gospel of Luke
- Various hypothetical documents have been proposed, including Proto-Mark, Deutero-Mark, another gospel or proto-gospel (note that there is no manuscript or Patristic evidence for these documents--they have been theorized largely in efforts to solve the Synoptic Problem)
Indeed if we compare Mark to either Matthew or Luke, we find that they do not present events consistently in the same order (I suggest reasons for these disagreements in order in my video here).
--
What is an orderly account?
When we see "in order" with Western eyes, we think "chronological order". While this is a possible meaning, it is not a necessary meaning.
- As noted in the OP's quote from Lucian, an orderly account can simply mean an account that is organized for rhetorical or artistic effect.
- A document can be ordered by topic (such as the Gospel of Matthew or a modern encyclopedia)
- A document can be ordered by geography (such as the Gospel of Luke or a modern atlas)
- A document can be ordered poetically, such as in a chiasmus, a technique common in ancient Jewish writings.
--
How was the Gospel of Mark organized?
Mark presents numerous stories placed together in sequence--in the literature, these stories are called "pericopes". Various theories exist for how Mark chose to order the pericopes, including:
- Structuring the entire book as a chiasmus
- Following a blend of the order of the material in Matthew & Luke (as argued by William Farmer)
- Following the order in which Peter (and/or others) taught the gospel message (e.g. Acts 10:37-42)
--
My own conclusions
My own work on the Synoptic Problem (here and here) leads me to conclude:
- No hypothetical documents, such as Q, proto-Mark, or Deutero-Mark, are necessary in order to solve the Synoptic Problem
- The Gospel of Matthew was written first and was the principal text of the Christian movement
- The Gospel of Luke was written second
- The Gospel of Mark was written third, much of it was put together from memory, and the material generally alternates between following the order of Matthew & the order of Luke
- The Elder & Papias are likely addressing the differences between Matthew's order (more well-known) and Mark's order (less well-known), and explaining that the order in Mark is not inappropriate even though it is not consistently the same as Matthew's order. Mark had a different focus & structure in mind. Neither is strictly chronological.
More post
- 📝 Are Christians required to believe the teachings of their own denomination?
- 📝 Are silent prayers heard?
- 📝 Has there been a shift in Christian metaphysics from a unitary cosmos to a binary one?
- 📝 Does proclaiming that all non-believers won't be saved count as passing judgement?
- 📝 Was it Adino or his army that killed eight hundred at one time?
- 📝 Why did Protestants abandon Liturgy of the Hours?
- 📝 Has it always been difficult for churches to reach the next generation?
- 📝 What is the take of Catholic Church on the dream of Pilate's wife?
- 📝 Why do some Christians believe it is moral to be a h*m*sexual?
- 📝 It is possible to understand the love of God by logical implications?
- 📝 Can Orthodox Church members be extraordinary ministers in the Roman Catholic rite?
- 📝 Why did God become angry with Balaam?
- 📝 Is there any Scriptural support for claims about Jesus appearing to Muslims in dreams and visions?
- 📝 How do those who reject both predestination and purgatory justify their beliefs?
- 📝 What are some of the reasons for which Catholics are against gender-neutral secular marriage?
- 📝 Does the Catholic Church accept all the teachings of the Byzantine Church after the union?
- 📝 Does the Bible suggest that the earth is round?
- 📝 Does the Bible support Pedophilia?
- 📝 Did the city of Nazareth exist in the time of Jesus?
- 📝 Is it possible for an Eastern Rite Catholic to change over to the Roman Rite and become ordained as Latin Rite priest?
- 📝 Is communion service at the rail vs. in the pews a function of denomination or church size?
- 📝 Can a Catholic priest adopt a child?
- 📝 What is the origin of the Christian tradition of praying before eating?
- 📝 What is the Roman Catholic Church doctrinal justification of its perceived opposition or support of the independence of Catalonia?
- 📝 Was there silence in heaven when our Lord and Saviour was crucified?
- 📝 According to Catholicism, if we sin and become repentant will our sins be forgiven too like St. Peter?
- 📝 According to 21st century Catholic critics, what's so great about the Canticle of the Sun?
- 📝 Is there evidence that Jesus was a Dalai Lama?
- 📝 According to Catholics, when is Luke 22:8?
- 📝 Looking for a study
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 What did Papias mean when he wrote how Mark did not write "in order" about what Jesus said or did?
- 📝 What did Paul mean when he wrote 1 Corinthians 14:22 in the context of 1 Corinthians 14:23-25?
- 📝 What did Jesus mean by "this generation will certainly not pass away.." in Matthew 24:34?
- 📝 What does it mean that Jesus fulfilled the law but did not abolish it?
- 📝 What did Jesus mean when he said ‘Go and sin no more’ if sinlessness is impossible?
- 📝 What exactly did Jesus mean when He said "I am coming soon" and similar phrases?
- 📝 What did Jesus mean when He said we must "eat His flesh and drink His blood"?
- 📝 What did God mean when He said 'lest they live forever'?
- 📝 What did Paul mean when he called Jesus the "firstborn from the dead"?
- 📝 According to Protestants following the Reformation, what did Jesus mean when he said "do this and you will live"?
- 📝 What defined a "clean" animal prior to the flood when mankind did not eat meat?
- 📝 What does Paul mean when he says "do not go beyond what is written."
- 📝 How can apologists argue that if Jesus did not rise again then Christianity and the Church would not have lasted, when other religions have?
- 📝 What did Pope Francis mean when he said "who am I to judge" h*m*sexuals?
- 📝 What does it mean to say an original Greek manuscript did not survive?
- 📝 How did Old Testament saints show they were focused on God’s promises even though they did not know when or how their Redeemer/Messiah would appear?
- 📝 What did Jesus mean by his apparent racial taunt to the Canaanite woman in Matt 15 when he inferred that they were "dogs"?
- 📝 What did Jesus mean when He said “And I, if I be lifted up from the earth, will draw all men unto me”
- 📝 What did God mean when He said to Moses, "I have made thee a god to Pharaoh"?
- 📝 What is a Catechism and when and how did they originate
- 📝 What did Thomas Merton mean by cartesian when it comes to modern christianity?
- 📝 What did Clement mean when he said: "Fasting is better than prayer, and charity than both"?
- 📝 When Paul wrote about Jesus' birth as "born of a woman," did he not contradict the fact that Jesus was "born of a virgin" as Matthew wrote?
- 📝 What prophets did Messiah mean in Luke 16:16 when we see yet more prophets thereafter?
- 📝 What did Martin Luther really mean by saying "Reason is the Devil’s greatest who*e" and how do Protestants view this?
- 📝 How can the Son not know what the Father knows?
- 📝 How could Jesus be born during the reign of Herod, and when Quirinius was governor of Syria, if those periods were not contemporary?
- 📝 When did "tithing" come to mean "giving 10% of your gross income to the Church"?
- 📝 When and how did men and women start sitting together in church?
- 📝 When and how did the names Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John get attached to the gospels?