Did John the Evangelist make a mistake in counting the post-resurrection apparitions of Jesus?
score:3
I am unaware of any specific statement by the Catholic Church on this question.
It's possible that this could be interpreted as a mistake, but I think there's a simpler solution:
What is the inner circle of Jesus' closest disciples called?
- In the Synoptics they are usually "the twelve"
- Luke 6:13 is likely the earliest reference indicating that the twelve were also called "apostles"
- John calls them "disciples"
So applying John's terminology consistently, I see John 21:14 calling out that this was the third appearance to the apostles as a group.
John himself acknowledges this wasn't the third appearance in the absolute sense--he records the appearance to Mary Magdalene, who certainly was a disciple in the general sense of the word; just not an apostle.
Putting the Gospels together, we have appearances to:
- Mary Magdalene
- Mary the mother of James & Joses, Joanna, Salome (and possibly others)
- Peter
- Cleopas and his companion (could be before #3)
- 10 of the original apostles (Thomas absent, Judas absent and possibly dead), plus possibly others
- 11 of the original apostles (Thomas now present, Judas absent and probably dead)
- The appearance at the Sea of Tiberius
(The timing of the appearance to James (aka James the Just) is unknown; this theory would suggest that the appearance to 500+ (as recorded by Paul in 1 Cor 15) probably happened after the appearance at the Sea of Tiberius)
I've bolded the appearances to the apostles as a group, and the Sea of Tiberius is indeed #3 on the list.
Upvote:3
My recommendation to you is not to overthink this. Perhaps John was simply not aware of Jesus's appearance to Cleopas and the other unnamed disciple on their way to Emmaus. Luke was aware, however, and he included the appearance (under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, of course) when he wrote his Gospel.
Remember, a basic rule of hermeneutics regarding the interpretation of the four Gospels (particularly Matthew, Mark, and Luke, the "synoptic" Gospels) is that four authors have different perspectives, based on such things as a) their purpose in writing; b) their sometimes unique experiences vis a vis the life of Jesus; and, of course, c) their being led by the Holy Spirit in what they write, whether, for example, to include or not to include a story or a detail.
By the way, your use of the word apparition is unfortunate in my opinion. A better word is appearance, since an apparition is a ghostly figure or spectre. Jesus's appearance to Thomas, for example, was definitely not an apparition, given that Jesus encouraged Thomas to touch his wounds from having been crucified. Thomas could not touch the wounds of an apparition!
More post
- 📝 How do Jehovah's Witnesses understand Hebrews 1?
- 📝 At the Last Supper what would the disciples make of what Jesus said about partaking of the bread and the wine?
- 📝 The Holy Spirit and Revelation 14:1
- 📝 Has Mark 10:39 been fulfilled? Death of John
- 📝 Reconciling Genesis 1 with Science: Order of Creation
- 📝 In Catholicism, what can the Saints be patrons of?
- 📝 Is the register where the first marriage was registered still available?
- 📝 How does a person determine whether they are a "false Christian" or "inconsistent Christian"?
- 📝 We're only in heaven for a short time?
- 📝 Where did the priests who served the Lord in Shiloh live?
- 📝 Why did Jesus and Elijah act so differently?
- 📝 Is it true that Martin Luther never considered the works of the early Church Fathers?
- 📝 Is there a biblical theory that tries to explain the mechanism of prayer?
- 📝 Did John Calvin discourage harmonies in congregational singing?
- 📝 Who is allowed to read the handbook of instructions in the LDS Church?
- 📝 Violence and Iconography
- 📝 What is the basis for Catholics believing Jesus fell three times (or seven) on his journey to Calvary?
- 📝 The New Testament teaches that Christ was baptized to “fulfill all righteousness” (Matthew 3:14–15)--what does this mean?
- 📝 Can my third class relic make other items into third class relics?
- 📝 If a Catholic priest absolves my sins without taking a confession, does it still count?
- 📝 The Trinity before the birth of Jesus
- 📝 How do the reformed theologians understand Hebrews 3:14?
- 📝 How do the Father and Son differ if they have the same particular essence?
- 📝 How were Jewish sacrifice different?
- 📝 What is the basis for saying "God bless you" when a person sneezes?
- 📝 How do proponents of the Prosperity Gospel interpret Matthew 19:24?
- 📝 Support Material for Reading the Bible
- 📝 Does the Catholic Church teach that we can choose when to use an indulgence?
- 📝 Should the phrase "God from God" in the Nicene Creed be translated as "god from god"?
- 📝 Why did David wish to send Uriah back home?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Did John the Evangelist make a mistake in counting the post-resurrection apparitions of Jesus?
- 📝 According to Catholic Church, why did John the Evangelist not mention the Institution of Holy Eucharist?
- 📝 Why did the apostle John call himself, "the disciple whom Jesus loved"?
- 📝 When and how did the names Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John get attached to the gospels?
- 📝 How did John the Baptist have the "spirit and power of Elijah"?
- 📝 How did the disciples of John the Baptist pray?
- 📝 Did Martin Luther think John Calvin is a "son of the devil"?
- 📝 Why did the soldiers go backward and fall down when Jesus said "I am he" in John 18:6?
- 📝 Did John Wesley reject the Athanasian Creed?
- 📝 Why did God make the "Forbidden Fruit" available in Eden?
- 📝 How did Luther view relics, like the 'preserved head of John the Baptist'?
- 📝 According to a ‘forgiveness in Christ alone’ framework how did ‘sin offerings’ make atonement for sin under the Mosaic Law?
- 📝 What did God make the universe from?
- 📝 Why did John the Baptist question the identity of Jesus?
- 📝 How did Swedenborg interpret 1 John 2:2: "He is the propitiation for our sins"?
- 📝 Why did John the Baptist exist? Did he have any purpose besides Baptizing Jesus?
- 📝 Did Jacob Arminius and/or the remonstrants believe they were in agreement with John Calvin?
- 📝 How did John Calvin reconcile killing followers of opposing religious views with the New Testament?
- 📝 Why did John Wycliffe oppose papal authority in the 14th century?
- 📝 Did Matthew, Mark, Luke, or John write anything other than the Gospels?
- 📝 Did John Calvin believe there was no salvation outside the visible church?
- 📝 Did John Calvin believe that the grandchildren of a believer are entitled to infant baptism?
- 📝 Did the Catholic Church make a conscious effort in re-naming the seven days of the week?
- 📝 Why did Mary ask Jesus to make wine at the Wedding at Cana
- 📝 What personal possessions did Pope John Paul II have at the time of death?
- 📝 Why did John the Baptist compare the holy spirit with dove?
- 📝 Why did Jesus favor Peter, James and John more than the other disciples?
- 📝 How did the people know that John the Baptist was a prophet?
- 📝 Why did John the Baptist preach repentance through water baptism and specifically how is that different than repentance through ashes and sackcloth?
- 📝 To the YEC, did God make a single male/female pair of each kind of animal?