Was the First Apocalypse of James written after the Second Apocalypse of James?
score:2
The terms "first" and "second" in these two titles are "scholarly conventions to distinguish the two,"1 not meant to indicate the date of origin. Instead, they reflect their original ordering in Codex V of the Nag Hammadi documents, in which the First Apocalypse precedes the Second Apocalypse. Still, this ordering was no accident:
The presence and order of the two James apocalypses in Codex V are undoubtedly due to deliberate scribal organization. The two apocalypses stress different aspects of the James tradition and actually complement one another. The setting of 1 Apoc. Jas. emphasizes the period prior to the suffering of James, while 2 Apoc. Jas. describes his suffering and death in line with the predictions in 1 Apoc. Jas.2
Next we can turn to the dating of the works. There is little certainty about the dating, but the Second Apocalypse is generally dated before the First Apocalypse based on comparisons of the texts to those of other early movements. Thus Robinson writes, regarding the Second:
The absence of allusions to the later developed gnostic systems, and the almost total absence of allusions to the New Testament tradition suggest an early date for the origin of the tractate.2
Primarily on this basis, numerous scholars date the text to the early or middle second century.3 4
On the other hand, the final text of the First Apocalypse reveals some similarities to Valentinian writings:
The Valentinian theologoumena utilised in it (cf. especially the doctrines of an upper and a lower Sophia, or of 'Sophia' proper and Achamoth', which also occur in the text outside the mystery formulae quoted: p. 36.5, 8) seem to presuppose the fully-developed Valentinian system, and therefore suggest the composition of the document at the earliest towards the end of the 2nd century.5
Similarly, "the rejection of a bodily fraternal relationship between Jesus and James (p.24.15f.)"5 points to a later date.
Summary
The names of these two works are based on the order in which the appear in the codex in which they were originally found. This seems to have been the deliberate ordering of a scribe based on their contents, not the presumed date of origin.
Textual analysis points to an earlier date for the Second Apocalypse due to its lack of allusion to early Gnostic texts, as compared to the use of developed Valentinian thought in the First Apocalypse. Thus the Second Apocalypse is dated to early or middle second century, while the First Apocalypse is dated to the late second century at the earliest.
References:
Robinson, Nag Hammadi Library in English, 270
Myllykoski, "James the Just in History and Tradition," part II, Currents in Biblical Research 6.1 (2007), 54
Funk, in Schneemelcher, New Testament Apocrypha, 328
Funk, in Schneemelcher, New Testament Apocrypha, 315
More post
- 📝 Earliest case of pointing to heaven as consolation and hope to loved ones
- 📝 Do fallen angels know and understand the Bible according to the Calvinist?
- 📝 How do seventh day Sabbatarians explain the lack of Sabbath observing following Spirit led revivals?
- 📝 Why did Jesus change Peter's name, according to non-Catholic theology?
- 📝 What is a Scapular, and what theology is tied to it?
- 📝 Why did Mary and Joseph look for an inn?
- 📝 Was the Lord with whom Abraham negotiated material or Holistic?
- 📝 What is achieved by baptism in Eastern Orthodoxy (compared with Catholicism)
- 📝 What exactly was the earliest start time of a Catholic mass before 1957? - What means aurora?
- 📝 From the literal perspective, the truth whispered in the ear, are we literally to proclaim that truth from the roofs?
- 📝 How are intersex people explained by Christianity?
- 📝 Did John Calvin teach that souls 'pre-existed'?
- 📝 Why did Stephen have authority to ask God to forgive the sins of his nonbelieving executioners?
- 📝 According to Catholicism, what is the original intent of the term “virgin” in Lk 1:26-27?
- 📝 Why does Roman Catholicism reject reincarnation?
- 📝 Heart, Mind, Soul and Spirit
- 📝 Purpose of giving up a prisoner on the Passover
- 📝 How long, and in what cases did Catholics participate in the Black Fast?
- 📝 What did Jesus mean by "mustard seed of faith"?
- 📝 Where did Goliath come from?
- 📝 Did Mary have other children?
- 📝 According to the Catholic Church, if God is just and loving why is Nature so needlessly brutal and cruel sometimes?
- 📝 Where were Satan and his angels when God devastated the Earth during Noah's Flood?
- 📝 Are blessed secular objects categorically lower than or different from traditional sacramentals like altars, priest vestments, etc.?
- 📝 How does one discern a calling to the vocation of priesthood?
- 📝 Isn't CS Lewis's idea that time is still successive in Heaven frustrating?
- 📝 Has the Catholic Church ever canonized a trans-gender person with the full knowledge of his/her true gender identity?
- 📝 What is the origin of the story that James had knees as hard as a camel's, because of his praying?
- 📝 What does the Good News refer to?
- 📝 Justification for Marriage without State
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Was the First Apocalypse of James written after the Second Apocalypse of James?
- 📝 Was the first gospel written in Hebrew?
- 📝 What are the arguments that the book of Acts was written after 70 AD?
- 📝 Which was written first Noah’s Flood or the Gilgamesh Epic?
- 📝 Was James the son of Alphaeus the presiding Apostle at the first Council held in Jerusalem?
- 📝 Why was God so upset with Moses for striking the rock the second time in the desert?
- 📝 When in the development of trinitarian doctrine was the word "persons" first applied to God?
- 📝 Why are some words in the King James Bible written in italics?
- 📝 According to LDS (Mormon) teaching, who was the first God who began the eternal progression?
- 📝 Why was the New Testament Written in Greek?
- 📝 Who was the first Church Father to argue for executing heretics?
- 📝 Which NT books were written after the destruction of the temple?
- 📝 What happened to the wives of priests when celibacy was first instituted in the Catholic church?
- 📝 When was the word "trinity" first applied to God in Christianity?
- 📝 Who was the first to reject the historicity of Adam?
- 📝 What are the arguments that Acts was written prior to 70 AD?
- 📝 When was Sunday first called the Sabbath?
- 📝 Was William of Ockham the first sedevacantist?
- 📝 What was the point of the laws written to the Gentile believers in Antioch, Syria, and Cilicia?
- 📝 What was written on the two stone tablets of Moses?
- 📝 What is the Biblical basis for saying that we won't have a second chance to be saved after we die?
- 📝 Do the Dead Sea scrolls describe any prophecy which was fulfilled after they were written?
- 📝 When did the teaching that salvation can still be obtained by people after their physical death first appear in Christianity?
- 📝 What was the light of the first day of creation?
- 📝 Why (and when) did the Apostles stop requiring exactly twelve apostles? Why was James not replaced?
- 📝 What is the difference between the first and second resurrection in the book of Revelation?
- 📝 When was the first recorded account of pre-tribulation teaching?
- 📝 When was the number of the beast, 666, first identified as referring to Emperor Nero?
- 📝 What is the historical reason the King James Version was created?
- 📝 Was Zwingli the first to preach lectio continua?