Is the Catholic declaration of an extra biblical saint infallible?
Upvote:2
The opinion on this issue seems to be divided.
According to the Catholic Encyclopedia, at least by the beginning of the XX century (i.e. pre Second Vatican Council) "most of" theologians thought canonisation involved an infallible claim. This is partly based on St. Thomas Aquinas's view:
"Since the honour we pay the saints is in a certain sense a profession of faith, i.e., a belief in the glory of the Saints [quâ sanctorum gloriam credimus] we must piously believe that in this matter also the judgment of the Church is not liable to error." (Quodlib. IX, a. 16)
However, there are divergent opinions. This much more recent article deals a great length with precisely this question. It starts by recognising the contemporaneity of aforementioned position:
Currently, it is the opinion of a majority of Catholic theologians that the canonization of Saints by the Pope is an exercise of papal infallibility. The Congregation for the Causes of the Saints (CCS) supports this opinion. And some Bishops also believe and teach this idea.
However, the author argues that actually, canonisation is not an infallible act. The author states:
Is the canonization of a Saint a doctrine of faith or morals? No, it is a judgment and decision, make by proper authority in the Church, that a person lived an exemplary holy life and was faithful to the teachings of Christ and His Church. Canonization is not a teaching, so it cannot fall under the teaching authority of the Church.
Why?
... the Magisterium is absolutely limited to teaching the truths found, explicitly or implicitly, in Tradition and Scripture. Therefore, the Magisterium is completely unable to teach that any person is a Saint (except for those persons mentioned in Tradition or Scripture). Neither the Pope himself, nor the entire Body of Bishops united with him, can teach that such a person is a Saint. The Pope cannot teach this infallibly, under papal infallibility, nor can he teach it even non-infallibly, under the Ordinary Magisterium. Likewise, the Bishops united with the Pope, even in an Ecumenical Council, cannot teach that such a person is a Saint. For the Magisterium is unable to teach truths found entirely outside of the Deposit of Faith.
Now the Saints who are mentioned in Tradition and Scripture, such as Saint Peter the Apostle, are a separate case. Since their lives and holiness is attested to in infallible Divine Revelation, the Church can infallibly teach their holiness and can infallibly declare them to be Saints. But most Saints have lived long after the canon of Scripture was closed. For unless the life of a Saint is a part of Sacred Tradition (e.g. the mother of the Virgin Mary), or unless a Saint is mentioned in Sacred Scripture (e.g. the father of the Virgin Mary, called Heli), such a Saint’s canonization cannot be considered a part of the teachings of the Church, nor of the Magisterium, neither infallibly nor non-infallibly.
More details on the article itself.
More post
- 📝 Does Catholicism confound the role of "elder" and "priest"?
- 📝 What bible translation did the Unitarians use in 19th century America?
- 📝 Do any other denominations agree with the Jehovah Witnesses that Satan was cast to earth in 1914?
- 📝 Are there published testimonies from Christians with a diagnosed personality disorder like psychopathy about their experience of sanctification?
- 📝 Should a Baptist marry a Jehovah's witness?
- 📝 Should we love Satan since he is our greatest enemy?
- 📝 How is "their angels always behold the Father in heaven" a warning?
- 📝 Why Do Moses' Laws About Slavery and Punishment Not Align with the Teachings of Jesus?
- 📝 Are there any Christian groups or denominations that believe that non-Christians have access to the power of the Holy Spirit?
- 📝 In the "Apostles' Creed" were they referring to themselves when they said "holy catholic church"?
- 📝 Why does the (N)KJV put Jesus' name in all caps in Matthew 1:21 and Luke 1:31?
- 📝 What does it mean for a priest 'to lose faith'?
- 📝 What's the context in the "Hail" part of Hail Mary?
- 📝 What is the Biblical and Traditional basis for doing Penance for others?
- 📝 Does Jesus call himself divine in the synoptic gospels?
- 📝 Does the Origin of Religious Beliefs from Evolution cast doubt on Christian belief?
- 📝 How many Christians believe there is time in Heaven?
- 📝 Why did Jesus arrange his 11 disciples in two places on the way to his place of prayer in Gethsemane?
- 📝 When did the one-way monologue sermon first become a normal feature of church assemblies?
- 📝 What is the "glory of God" in Romans 3:23?
- 📝 What is Martin Luther's approach to liturgical services in light of Paul Tillich?
- 📝 What is the Authenticity of Bible?
- 📝 Why did Justin Martyr speak so harshly about Christians who ate meat sacrificed to idols?
- 📝 Was Adam's rebellion the first sin?
- 📝 What evidence does the LDS church forward for the claim that the Garden of Eden was in Missouri?
- 📝 Did Joseph Smith create any secular writings?
- 📝 What does the Bible tell us about how people knew right from wrong before the Law of Moses?
- 📝 Earliest case of pointing to heaven as consolation and hope to loved ones
- 📝 In Protestant churches, who is the authority in interpreting the Bible?
- 📝 When is it too late to ask for salvation?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Is the Catholic declaration of an extra biblical saint infallible?
- 📝 Why can the Catholic Church declare one person a saint but has never declared another damned?
- 📝 Who is the most recent saint recognized by both the Catholic and the Orthodox churches?
- 📝 What is the biblical basis for seeing Saint Peter at the gates of heaven?
- 📝 What is the biblical support that the Catholic Church is the custodian of truth?
- 📝 What is the Biblical argument used by Evangelical Christians against the Catholic doctrine of the invocation of the saints?
- 📝 What are the main differences between the Catholic and Protestant definitions of Biblical inerrancy?
- 📝 How does the Catholic Church choose the patron saint of a parish church?
- 📝 What is the Biblical basis for the special mediatorial position of the Pope, Cardinals, etc in the Catholic church?
- 📝 What is the Biblical basis for Catholic blessings?
- 📝 What is the biblical and traditional support for the Catholic Marian devotion?
- 📝 Has the Catholic Church outlined specific Biblical passages which should not be taken literally?
- 📝 What is the biblical argument used by Protestants against the Catholic doctrine of Penance?
- 📝 What is the Biblical basis for the Catholic teaching that infant baptism cleanses from original sin?
- 📝 What is the biblical basis for the argument against the Catholic teaching on the primacy of Peter?
- 📝 Does the Catholic church consider Mark 16:9-20 to be biblical canon?
- 📝 What is the Catholic biblical or canon basis saying some moral works without grace (transient or permanent) are good (or not have the nature of sin)?
- 📝 What is the biblical basis for the Catholic and Eastern doctrines of the Assumption of Mary?
- 📝 Do the notes in the NABRE accurately reflect the Catholic Church's understanding of biblical inerrancy?
- 📝 According to the Catholic Church, has Satan ever appeared on earth since biblical times?
- 📝 Remit of Defender of the Bond in Catholic declaration of nullity investigations
- 📝 Are there any examples where the non-believers demanding a miracle for the proof of Catholic faith and a saint succeeding in performing it?
- 📝 Would a person baptized by a Biblical Unitarian church be considered a Christian by the Catholic Church?
- 📝 What is the meaning of a Catholic Saint being "Raised to the Altar"?
- 📝 Where within Biblical Scripture does it mention anything similar to the official Catholic and/or Orthodox church's hierarchy of church officials?
- 📝 What is the biblical basis for the hierarchical system of the Catholic church?
- 📝 When did the Catholic definition of saint change and how is the change applied in personal study?
- 📝 What are the criteria for a saint becoming the Patron saint of something in the Catholic Church?
- 📝 Proof that Cyril of Alexandria is a Saint in the Roman Catholic Church?
- 📝 What is the biblical basis for in the catholic theology of a priest being in "persona christi"?