Did God really "regret" making man? (Catholic perspective)

score:3

Accepted answer

At the very perimeter of this question it's important to remember that:

... God himself, who makes the revelation and can neither deceive nor be deceived.

First Vatican Council Decree

So, if he didn't deceive us by His regret at making us, then He really did regret making us.

Regret, however, is a feeling - not an action, and one thing they tell you in Catholic Marriage class is that feelings are never wrong! I'm not sure if this applies to God, but the story of the Bible is a love story between God and His Spouse the Church. Sometimes even spouses regret at having gotten married, but it doesn't make them liars all the way back to their wedding vows. Neither does it make God a liar for having created man for having regretted creating them. Nor does it mean He made a mistake. Nor does it mean He wouldn't do it the same way if He could (and He could) do it all over again.

God also appears to have changed His mind, for the better - but to no different end - in saying He'd spare Sodom if a few good people could be found there. In fact, what is the point of prayer, if not to change God's mind about the natural course of events He set in place or the divine judgment He revealed to the prophets.

“Miracles happen. But they need prayer! A courageous prayer, that struggles for that miracle. Not like those prayers of courtesy: Ah, I will pray for you! Followed by one Our Father, a Hail Mary and then I forget. No! It takes a brave prayer like that of Abraham who was struggling with the Lord to save the city, like that of Moses who prayed, his hands held high when he grew weary...”.

Pope Francis - May 20 2013

I'll give you that Numbers and Genesis seem to contradict each other here. I'm surprised they didn't have intratext notes for those two verses which pretty clearly fit together, but the footnotes in the NAB for Genesis 6:6 are as follows:

the expression can be misleading in English, for “heart” in Hebrew is the seat of memory and judgment rather than emotion. The phrase is actually parallel to the first half of the sentence

And Numbers 19:23 is as follows:

God is not a human being who speaks falsely, nor a mortal, who feels regret.

And in the context of the "feeling" regret vs having regret contradicts my earlier opinions about regret being a feeling.

A corollary of these contradictions can be found in St. Thomas Aquinas' Summa articles concerning tempting God. He states:

It is forbidden in God's Law, for it is written (Deuteronomy 6:10): "Thou shalt not tempt the Lord thy God."

and then goes on to enumerate the ways God favors those who pray without tempting Him.

Similarly, God wants us to know that He is unchanging, while still letting us know that He loves us too much to be a stickler about it.

Upvote:1

Some passages such as Malachi 3:6, James 1:17, and Hebrews 13:8 seem to imply that God doesn't change His mind.

A first-century Jewish opinion comes from Philo of Alexandria, who wrote a book on the subject. "Book 10: Philo, On the Unchangeableness of God"

Philo not only said God doesn't change, but men who said He did were as evil as those who were destroyed in the flood.

However, we have said enough on this head; let us now connect what follows with It: "the Lord God, therefore," says Moses, "seeing that the wickedness of man was multiplied upon the earth, and that every one of them was carefully studying wickedness in his heart all his days; God considered in his mind that he had made man upon the earth, and he thought upon it; and God said, I will destroy man whom I have made from off the face of the earth." Perhaps some very wicked persons will suspect that the lawgiver is here speaking enigmatically, when he says that the Creator repented of having created man, when he beheld their wickedness; on which account he determined to destroy the whole race. But let those who adopt such opinions as these know, that they are making light of and extenuating the offences of these men of old time, by reason of their own excessive impiety; for what can be a greater act of wickedness than to think that the unchangeable God can be changed?

Philo of Alexandria; Marsh, E.C.; Yonge, C.D.. The Works of Philo Judaeus of Alexandria (Kindle Locations 5675-5681). . Kindle Edition.

Upvote:1

The verse is an expression of God's suffering because of human sin. Since God is a relational God, He is affected by us. For Christians, there is no clearer example of this than God suffering on the Cross in Jesus. The important thing is that God experienced unfathomable pain because of what humans were doing.

The OT several times expresses God parental feelings of sadness because of human responses to his love:

It was I who taught Ephraim to walk, taking them by the arms; but they did not realize it was I who healed them. I led them with cords of human kindness, with ties of love. To them I was like one who lifts a little child to the cheek, and I bent down to feed them. (Hosea 11:3-4)

Is this an expression of regret? Not exclusively. Just as with human parents, God feels mixed emotions toward His/Her children. (I include the feminine pronoun here because the passage seems undeniably motherly to me.) In Genesis, the sense of regret overwhelms love, and God proceeds to wipe out most of humankind. But in Hosea, love is stronger than regret. Thus, the prophet uses a different metaphor and writes:

“In that day,” declares the LORD, “you will call me ‘my husband’ you will no longer call me ‘my master.’" (Hos. 2:16)

As a husband, how could God not regret the adultery of his wife? As a parent, how could he not regret the suffering of his children? As a master, God's regret can motivate Him to kill millions of human beings. But in the end we cannot respond to God out of fear. People of faith can believe that God's love is forever and steadfast, stronger than any temporary regrets or mixed emotions.

Catholics can recall that although a sword pierced the Blessed Mother's soul (Luke 2:35) any regrets she felt did not outweigh her love. The Sacred Heart of Jesus manifests God's boundless and passionate love for mankind. Surely this is stronger than whatever regrets God feels about our sins.

More post

Search Posts

Related post