If someone says publicly that he has achieved nirvana , can it be true?
score:7
From a Theravada perspective, the answer is probably "no".
While not being a sutta, the Milindapanha states if a layperson attains to Arahatship they either ordain as a monk or die.
If the layperson Arahant ordains as monk, the Vinaya forbids them making a public declaration.
Should any bhikkhu report (his own) superior human state to an unordained person, when it is factual, it is to be confessed.
As for the Buddha & monks that declared arahantship in the Pali suttas, if they used the personal pronoun "I", they were only speaking in conventional language. Refer to SN 1.25.
Upvote:1
No one can declare that one cannot say he/she has achieved nirvana. Didn't lord Buddha declare that he achieved nibbana? If some one has achieved nirvana don't he/she has to declare it to others in order to teach them about the correct path to nirvana? If you say 'no', then how can he/she guide others to the nirvana? Thus it will depend on the person whether to declare it on public or not. No one can thoroughly say 'no'.
Upvote:2
Depends on the achievement of nirvana, either monk or not, in case of sotapanna, sakadagami, anagami,arahant, if they say with good intention, it is ok referring to Thera Theri Apadana. GOOD INTENTION means not for fame, not for offerings , only for the laymen to follow the proper path of Magga and attain nirvana.
Upvote:2
Mr/Mrs Larn,
Why not? "Off (good) cause" there are reasons why not and on (good) course reasons why.
It's rather foolish to say that an awakened would not share past merits if conuctive or would anybody saw the Buddha him self lived a paradox?
Since an Arahat (especially) would not "claim" such for certain low puposes, not to speak of evil, he might not violate even a precept or rule (how could he?)
For example a clear indication that such sharing of merits are not bad at first hand but has rather to do with generaly issa in certain communities believing equanimity is the highes virtue:
Then Anathapindika the householder, surrounded by about 500 lay followers, went to the Blessed One and, on arrival, having bowed down to him, sat to one side. So the Blessed One said to Ven. Sariputta: "Sariputta, when you know of a householder clothed in white, that he is restrained in terms of the five training rules and that he obtains at will, without difficulty, without hardship, four pleasant mental abidings in the here & now, then if he wants he may state about himself: 'Hell is ended; animal wombs are ended; the state of the hungry shades is ended; states of deprivation, destitution, the bad bourns are ended! I am a stream-winner, steadfast, never again destined for states of woe, headed for self-awakening!'1 ...Gihi Sutta: The Householder
[Feel personal always invited to share such merits here: "Ich bin ein Stromgewinner!" - "I am a stream-winner!"]
A maybe extended answer and also further questions and discussion can be done and found here: [Q&A] If someone says publicly that he has achieved nirvana , can it be true ?
(Note: This is a gift of Dhamma and not meant for commercial use or other purposes for wordily gains.)
Upvote:4
Maybe it's not possible for an arahant that is a monastic, because it is appropriate for monastics to follow the monastic rules (which discourage saying such a thing in public).
An arahant has no attachment to ego so it isn't as though a lay arahant's public proclamation of enlightenment would cause the arahant any bad karma. An arahant would need an appropriate reason to make such a claim though. Maybe there could never be an appropriate reason to make such a claim; or maybe there could be an appropriate reason, as simple as someone asking the arahant, "How's your meditation practice going"?
Metta :)
Upvote:4
Buddha has said that an Enlightened person doesn't go and cling with the self. So they don't have any attachment to self. But a inAn10.92` the Buddha has clearly mentioned the following.
Then Anathapindika the householder went to the Blessed One and, on arrival, having bowed down to the Blessed One, sat to one side. As he was sitting there, the Blessed One said to him, “When, for a disciple of the noble ones, five forms of fear & animosity are stilled; when he is endowed with the four factors of stream-entry; and when, through discernment, he has rightly seen & rightly ferreted out the noble method, then if he wants he may state about himself: ‘Hell is ended; animal wombs are ended; the state of the hungry shades is ended; states of deprivation, destitution, the bad bourns are ended! I am a stream-winner, steadfast, never again destined for states of woe, headed for self-awakening!’
So an Enlightened person, can say that I'm enlightenment to another person for the sake of showing that person the path of enlightenment
More post
- 📝 What is ariya or noble?
- 📝 Temporary Influences on Meditation
- 📝 Flickering light during meditation
- 📝 How to combat self-doubt?
- 📝 Attachment to other people and beings?
- 📝 Re-orientation in my practice from Advaita to Buddhism
- 📝 Relationship between the 5 higher fetters and the Three Characteristics or the Three Doors
- 📝 What makes Lord Buddha worthy of worshiping as to suttas?
- 📝 Four Noble Truths contradicting?
- 📝 Losing my religion, and shikantaza
- 📝 How long would it take to enter 3rd and 4th Satipatthana?
- 📝 Pleasure in Shower
- 📝 How is possible that monks memorised 10.000 sutras?
- 📝 Can bad karma be created and paid back in the same lifetime
- 📝 Which is the Buddhist holy book? Where can it be read?
- 📝 Music or ambient sounds for meditation?
- 📝 Is Nirvana the goal for all Buddhist?
- 📝 Is there a compassion only Buddhist path?
- 📝 Do Buddha represent the Cosmic Man? Does it have similarity to Brahman?
- 📝 Did anyone equate the tathagatagarbha with the past?
- 📝 Is Krishna a demon?
- 📝 Are we Mindful in Jhana?
- 📝 Helpful: Is an idea of being helpful, such an intent, a secure attribut of skilful action?
- 📝 I only know that I will know nothing: can that ever have any currency for Buddhists?
- 📝 Can thoughts materialize?
- 📝 Time and duration to meditate
- 📝 What is the origin and purpose of the alms bowl used by monastics?
- 📝 Help locating a widespread quote attributed to Chögyam Trungpa Rinpoche
- 📝 How much should one eat when following the not-eating-after-noon precept?
- 📝 Which aggregate (khandha) is or generates 'suffering'?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 If someone says publicly that he has achieved nirvana , can it be true?
- 📝 If Buddhism is about moderation, then why is it that you can attain nirvana only after renouncing worldly possessions?
- 📝 Can someone regain a Beginners Mind when it has gone?
- 📝 If someone was an Once-returner in last life how can he know that ?
- 📝 Why emphasise the EBT when anyone who has achieved Arhathood can teach from direct experience?
- 📝 Can someone point me the Sutra that explains the fall of Human civilization?
- 📝 How to know if someone has achieved nirvana?
- 📝 What is the Sutra where The Buddha says that he has taught only a fraction of what he knew
- 📝 Supposed Buddhist Scripture Predicting that only through Jesus can Nirvana be reached
- 📝 Is it possible to recognize a person who has achieved Arhatship?
- 📝 What are the texts that contain words which can be attributed directly to the Buddha?
- 📝 Can someone explain about children monks?
- 📝 How can I know that I am clear of thoughts while I am meditating?
- 📝 How can Nirvana (Nibbana) be permanent?
- 📝 Where can I find a reference for someone becoming a sotapanna through meditation?
- 📝 Why choose to attain Nirvana when we can become Brahmas (or Bodhisattvas)?
- 📝 Can a human being reside both in this world and Nirvana at the same time?
- 📝 How can the idea of reincarnation be true if all the information of who we are is already destroyed
- 📝 Can somebody remove their bad karma by believing that it doesn't exist?
- 📝 Can a being be reborn into more that one body in Tibetan Buddhism?
- 📝 If there is no self how can Nirvana be described as bliss?
- 📝 Why do I have to suffer due to a thing that a person in a past life has done that I have no control over?
- 📝 Can a monk choose to eat only an animal or plant that had died naturally?
- 📝 There is a text where Buddha says that the Dharma he teaches is not a secret doctrine so why are there sects which maintain secrecy?
- 📝 Can lokuttara citta's be defined as the true knowing essence (yathabhuta nana dassana)?
- 📝 Is it true that Physics confirms some of the Buddha's teachings?
- 📝 Can someone address this critique?
- 📝 Is it true that arahants don't have sati?
- 📝 Can anyone follow Buddhism if the person has had drinks & ate non-veg in the past?
- 📝 How can the Buddha (after he was enlightened) reflect that he was not at ease and then became at ease in seclusion?