What's the first thing that arises, from which everything else arise?
score:6
Suppose you completely empty your mind of all thoughts
This is what happens when you go into deep sleep. When you don't dream, the mind falls back to the Bhavanga process. This is called the passive state of the mind. It is what keeps you alive, when there's no other thought. This Bhavanga process is the result of your birth Karma.
Suppose that in that state you make a choice to arise a thought
No, you can't make any choices when you are in Bhavanga state. The Bhavanga process should first be interrupted by one of the sense doors. Volition comes much later in the process.
A complete thought process, occurring through the physical sense doors, is made up of seventeen thought moments (citta kha.na). These are:
- A bhava"nga that flows by in a passive state when one of the five physical sense organs comes in contact with its object (atiita bhava"nga).
- A bhava"nga that vibrates for one thought moment (bhava"nga calana).
- A bhava"nga that cuts off the flow (bhava"nga upaccheda).
- A citta that turns towards the object through the sense door that has been stimulated (pañcadvaara-vajjana).
- The appropriate sense consciousness; in the case of the eye, for example, eye consciousness (cakkhu viññaa.na).
- Next a thought moment — the sampa.ticchana citta — which has the function of receiving the object.
- When the object has been received another thought moment, called the santiirana citta, arises, performing the function of investigating the object.
- The act (kamma) itself, especially if it was a weighty one.
9 to 15. The object having been determined, the most important stage from an ethical standpoint follows. This stage, called javana, consists of seven consecutive thought moments all having an identical nature. It is at this stage that good or evil is done, depending on whether the cittas have wholesome or unwholesome roots. Therefore, these javana thought moments have roots and also produce new kamma.
16 and 17. Following the seventh javana the registering stage occurs, composed of two thought moments called tadaalambane. When the second registering citta has perished, the bhava"nga follows, flowing on until interrupted by another thought process.
As you can see, decision making starts at the 8th stage of the process.
Thus, the first thing that arise is 'mental fermentations/volitions', which leads to the arising of thoughts.
The first unit of Paticca Samuppada is given as ignorance. But that doesn't mean it started from ignorance. There's no real starting point. It's like asking the starting point of a circle. It's wherever you hold it first. The standard Paticca Samuppada teaching spans over 3 consecutive lives. The past, the present and the future.
Upvote:1
"There are these four unconjecturables that are not to be conjectured about, that would bring madness & vexation to anyone who conjectured about them. Which four?
"The Buddha-range of the Buddhas1 is an unconjecturable that is not to be conjectured about, that would bring madness & vexation to anyone who conjectured about it.
"The jhana-range of a person in jhana...[2]
"The [precise working out of the] results of kamma...
"Conjecture about [the origin, etc., of] the world is an unconjecturable that is not to be conjectured about, that would bring madness & vexation to anyone who conjectured about it.
"These are the four unconjecturables that are not to be conjectured about, that would bring madness & vexation to anyone who conjectured about them."
Anguttara Nikaya 4.77- Unconjecturable Questions:
I'll go ahead and answer since you're probably on now, this question is one of the imponderable questions that will only serve to detract in your practice. Although the wording of your question in particular isn't exactly one of these four, your questions seems to lie both within the 3rd and 4th questions. I'm sure this question has been asked at least twice, though, so don't be surprised when Chris or whomever else comes along and closes it :)
Upvote:1
Great Question!
I think the answer to this question lies in the free will versus determinism debate. If you "you make a choice to arise a thought", then you are in favor of 'free will', however if you think that your "choice to arise a thought", is actually just determined by the universe and you actually made no choice at all, than you agree with determinism. Now a person that agrees with free will as the answer, will likely struggle to answer what's the first thing that arises from which everything else arises. This, however is not because the question is ignorant but because the essence of the question is so, that a free will individual cant answer it. Why? because a free will individual may also think that all their decisions are made by their own choosing and that outside factors don't have an influence.
A determinist however would argue that it is pointless asking this question because they have no say over their lives anyway so they may as well just accept these questions as if they weren't their own.
This would also be wrong, because otherwise all criminals would not be accountable for their sins. Everyone would just say, "its not his fault, because the universe 'determined' his fate.
To answer your question fully, I think a Buddha would likely answer this question by taking the 'middle way' of these extremes. Answering it by explaining, that you don't have to know "what's the first thing that arises from which everything else arises". The way out of suffering is not accomplished by knowing the answer to this question. Instead he would probably ask you to watch your thoughts of choice and your thoughts of emptying your mind too (because that is also just a thought). By doing this, your likely to realize that 'your' thoughts are actually shared amongst your family and friends. Where 'you' actually becomes a very hard question to answer. Watch your thoughts for this and also ask your family too if they have that burning question.
Hope this helps :)
Upvote:1
Well it is an an empty mind, not a stopped mind, so there's always something going on inside even if we can't know it.
It is said even the Buddha has not delved to the complete depths of the mind.
The mind is as illusory and empty as anything else - thus it leads a compounded existence, always reacting to inputs.
Normal meditative equanimity:
Internal factors: In intermediate states of meditation where the mind is resting in equanimity an increase or decrease in body temperature, a movement in the bowels, activity of various organs, circadian rhythm, change in visuddhinana cycles, change in concentration can all disturb the equanimity and cause thoughts to occur.
External factors: The mind is most reactive to noises, especially human voices, when in meditation, but also rain or an insect for example, may trigger thoughts. The connection may not be apparent, especially if the domino effect of unconscious thoughts takes a while to manifest as a visible thought.
Non-meditative equanimity or no-mind states:
With deep and continuous mindfulness practice one can abide in no-mind states with no apparent thoughts, and in these cases one may appear to make a conscious decision to cogitate - however even this is typically motivated by an external factor - someone asking a question of us, or a decision or plan to be made and so on.
Thus, if the mind appears to come alive it is a result of a change in its compounded condition.
More post
- 📝 What is an "enlightening being"?
- 📝 If the literal truth causes confusion, but a lie portrays the truth via a careful misunderstanding, is it really a lie?
- 📝 How does an arahant know that ignorance won't return/re-arise after death?
- 📝 Did the Buddha teach Engaged Buddhism?
- 📝 Is technology making us less mindful?
- 📝 Dualism of mind and matter in Buddhism
- 📝 Question on Phassa
- 📝 What is the difference between Anapanasati and Vipassana?
- 📝 What is correct punishment for children?
- 📝 What are the major sects of Buddhism?
- 📝 Bodhipakkhiya: Panca Indriya versus Panca Bala
- 📝 Do beings without conscious experiences have buddha nature
- 📝 Attachment vs legitimate need
- 📝 There is no benefit and there is no intrinsic positive nature in a pleasant sensation
- 📝 Is it forbidden in Thai/Buddhist religion for a woman to perform consensual oral sex on someone?
- 📝 False Speech for forming a non exist Buddhism Club
- 📝 nirodha vs nibbana?
- 📝 Abhidhamma: can dependent origination arise without any sense bases?
- 📝 How to increase will power?
- 📝 Does the Foam Sutta (SN 22.95) say there are "no things" or, otherwise, discuss emptiness similar to Nagarjuna?
- 📝 What is the invisible consciousness or consciousness without surface?
- 📝 How does a forest-dwelling dhutanga practitioner get food?
- 📝 Why intake of intoxicating substances is not included in 10 unwholesome actions?
- 📝 If a kind and generous Christian died 20 years ago, might their rebirth have resulted in there being a 19 year old person in the human realm now?
- 📝 How do we perceive pitch-dark?
- 📝 Buddhism And Dimension
- 📝 Significance of touching forheads in Tibetan Buddhism (Karma Kagyu)?
- 📝 How to get away from the desire to become a Buddhist Teacher or some influencer followed by many?
- 📝 How not to alter breathing in Anapana meditation?
- 📝 Is raping a male arahant or a non-arahant less immoral/less serious than raping a female arahant?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 What's the first thing that arises, from which everything else arise?
- 📝 How can I remedy the erratic energy-power that arises from vipassana aka cessation-contemplation meditation so I can feel more in-control?
- 📝 Looking for an online resource of the commentary(SNA.ii.476; SA.i.155) which says that the Brahma Sahampati was an Anagami from the Suddhavasa realms
- 📝 What are the texts that contain words which can be attributed directly to the Buddha?
- 📝 There is a text where Buddha says that the Dharma he teaches is not a secret doctrine so why are there sects which maintain secrecy?
- 📝 If a Buddha exists then can a private buddha arise or exist somewhere in the same world system without having learned from the current Buddha?
- 📝 How different is the lifestyle of male monks from that of the female monks?
- 📝 When the Pali suttas say that it is not the "same" thing that is born and dies what do they mean?
- 📝 How does rebirth fit with the fact that everything is impermanent?
- 📝 Why are the psychological forces that stop us from attaining Nibbana greater/stronger than those propel us towards Nibbana?
- 📝 What is it that pass from this life to the next?
- 📝 Has any Buddhist meditator claimed that the mano-vijnana has a base to differentiate it from the other consciousnesses?
- 📝 Do the scholastic sects say that chan practice is something separate from themselves?
- 📝 As a Buddhist, how shall we make sense of the notion that there is no such thing as a Soul?
- 📝 In which sutta does a lay disciple of the Buddha tell a non-buddhist mendicant that he has experienced jhana?
- 📝 Does/did Buddhism assert that everything that is/was important to know about the world is/was already known?
- 📝 Which Buddhist council included the conclusions that there is no creator-god and no day of judgment?
- 📝 How can we view the statement that “life must be understood backwards but must be lived forwards" from a Buddhist perspective?
- 📝 The feeling that one is constantly one step away from enlightenment
- 📝 When saying that the aggregate is not-self are we not predicting the existence of a thing called self?
- 📝 From which text is the quote by Buddha “My practice is the nonpractice, the attainment of nonattainment” taken?
- 📝 If consciousness arises from mental formations is it correct to say that consciousness has a specific tone or opinions with it?
- 📝 Can there be an action free from the taint of desire? If there can be, what is the nature of that action?
- 📝 Is there a separate word for pain (in Pali) which the Buddha used to differentiate pain from suffering?
- 📝 What is the sutta where the Buddha says that one breath or one bite of food is the proper timeframe with which to contemplate life/death?
- 📝 Which sutta(s) say that Rahula was the Buddha's son?
- 📝 According to Buddhism, everything that happens, happens for a reason, which is due to karma. How does Utu Niyama, Bija niyama fit into this?
- 📝 Which Sutta does Sakkra asks 14 Questions from the Buddha?
- 📝 Is there a Buddhist school / tradition wich recognizes the endless cycle of rebirth but doesn't teach that we should get liberated from it?
- 📝 Do the texts of Mahayana Buddhism or those of any other school posit that everything is to be regarded as ideation? (Idealism)