Ex-monk reliable Teacher?
Upvote:0
It simply is not correct that because someone gives back their robes/vows they have "problems with their faith." There can be many reasons why a person gives back their vows that have nothing to do with doubt. Especially for Western monastics. You would do well to put away your preconceptions.
Upvote:0
I will listen to the ex monks very cautiously. For instance, Pia Tan says it is not possible to attain Nibbana in this life. In my opinion, it is the wrong advice. Otherwise, you can learn a lot from their experience. It is no different from learning from a layperson. You can learn the theory of Buddha's teaching from anyone including non-Buddhist. However, you should exercise caution when it comes to relying on certain practices.
Upvote:1
The answer to your question is YES, an ex-monk can be a reliable teacher.
Piya Tan is a very good example. Here is another profile of him.
He was a Theravada monk from 1970 - 1990 by the name of Bhikkhu Piyasilo, but since 1990 he is back to being the lay person Piya Tan.
He is a well-known translator and scholar of the Pali Canon. The other well-known translators are either monks (like Bhikkhus Thanissaro, Bodhi, Sujato) or academics (like T W Rhys Davids or I B Horner).
You can take a look at his excellent Sutta Discovery series.
More post
- π Does the "Zen Master" from Cyberpunk 2077 accurately represent Buddhism?
- π Is Nirvana the goal, for Zen and Theravada?
- π Possible to attain happiness without support, through art?
- π Were the Zen Patriarchs reborn?
- π Can someone help me to find suttas on Self compassion
- π Vipassana meditation comes naturally; Samatha meditation incredibly hard.
- π How can the theory of emptiness be true and yet the self still transmigrates and takes rebirth?
- π Tolerance β Buddhist in Countries with a Non-Buddhist Majority
- π Is karma of arms giving depends on the reciever?
- π Is continuity just causation?
- π What is the difference between Buddhism, Hinduism and Solipsism?
- π How much concentration do I need to practice vipassana?
- π What is meant by "No limiting action remains there"? MN 99
- π Generosity in Buddhism - When does giving become unwholesome?
- π Vajrayana Buddhism relies on a teacher-pupil relationship. What in tradition or the literature explains how to find the appropriate teacher?
- π Killing a bigger animal causes more bad karma than killing a smaller animal?
- π Looking for an online resource of the commentary(SNA.ii.476; SA.i.155) which says that the Brahma Sahampati was an Anagami from the Suddhavasa realms
- π How do we guarantee the accuracy and validity of Buddhist scriptures?
- π Buddhism after death
- π Was Tirupati Balaji a Buddhist Shrine?
- π Buddhism and theory of relativity
- π VijΓ±Δna and ΕΕ«nyatΔ... How are they seen as different?
- π Mala in Zen Practice
- π Theories and Doctrines
- π Did Buddha ever deny the existence of God?
- π How can I assess the quality of a local Buddhist group?
- π What is meant by "claims the bullβs place, roars his lionβs roar in the assemblies" and was an actual loud lion-like sound ever uttered by the Buddha?
- π What are the other Theravada Councils held between the 4th and 6th
- π Where can I find the Chinese Canon Agama in English translation?
- π Why did Buddha passed away in fourth Jhana?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π Is there any way one can be a Monk without a teacher in India/Nepal?
- π What is the life of a monk really like?
- π Homeless but not a monk
- π Is it useful (and polite) to ask a potential meditation teacher about their attainments?
- π Buddhist monk education level
- π How should a lay person respond if they see a monk teaching something contrary to Dhamma?
- π What is the purpose of using a wand to hit a monk in Zen meditation?
- π What happens if a monk is called for jury duty?
- π How to find the right Dhamma teacher
- π Where is the story that Buddha was worried about a monk who meditated with a straight back?
- π How does a monk address parents and relatives?
- π Is it OK for a Buddhist teacher to charge their students an hourly rate for their time?
- π Are there reliable accounts of Buddhists who have remembered past lives?
- π How should a monk address subjective questions?
- π A question regarding the level of worldly participation for a buddhist monk
- π Meditation posture and language as a monk in Thailand
- π How does a monk cope with all the bad things happening in the world if the only thing monks do is sitting and meditating?
- π A concentrated monk discerns things as they actually are?
- π When an experienced monk meditates how much does their mind wander?
- π Can a monk choose to eat only an animal or plant that had died naturally?
- π How to get away from the desire to become a Buddhist Teacher or some influencer followed by many?
- π Is finding a teacher necessary to practise dhamma?
- π can I become a monk with schizophrenia?
- π Permission of parents to be a Monk
- π Finding a Vipassana Teacher in a pandemic
- π Is a monk allowed to receive money?
- π Virtue of monk and lay ariya
- π Should a Monk speak out in favor of doing good?
- π Which is this sutta, which describes a monk prepared to travel and to experience violence?
- π A Monk Reborn in a Lower Realm for Breaking a Leaf