Do the suttas say the "old kamma" of an Arahant continues to fruit?
Upvote:0
AN 3.76 appears to say becoming is "kamma ripening" and, for kamma to ripen, craving provides the moisture. Given an Arahant has ended craving & becoming (which are both "asava" or "mental defilements"), it would appear kamma is not ripening or fruiting for the Arahant.
AN 6.63 says the Noble Eightfold Path ends kamma. Since an Arahant has fulfilled the Noble Path, it would appear old kamma is not ripening or fruiting for the Arahant.
SN 12.37 says the five aggregates ("kaya") is not-self and that it should be seen as "old kamma" that is to be "felt" rather than identified with. Since the "kaya" is not identified with but merely felt (as Arahants experience feeling at sense contact), surely there is no becoming (per AN 3.76) therefore there is no kamma ripening or fruiting when Arahants experience merely what is felt.
MN 86 (possible mythical fake dhamma) is often the go-to sutta for the old kamma adherents. In MN 86, it appears quite obvious it was not Angulimala watering & fruiting his old kamma (given AN 3.76 says "craving is the moisture" but Arahants are free from craving) but the anger in the people who stoned him that were fruiting kamma. For example, that King Pasenadi forgave Angulimala (unlike the stoners) shows the reactions towards the Bhikkhu Angulimala were not related to internal fruiting of kamma. Surely, we cannot say "forgiveness" is a fruit of the evil kamma of mass-murder.
Upvote:0
There are several types of Kamma. There are some types of Kamma that ends with the attainment of Arahath while there are some that doesn't. ex:- Kamma of Mugalan Thero. Also no Kamma is created after attaining Arahath. Kamma is only created by attachments & attainment of Arahath breaks all attachments & therefor no Kamma is created afterwards.
Upvote:1
Angulimala -- A Murderer's Road to Sainthood
Yet there were still a few who could not forget that Angulimala the bandit, with his superior prowess, had shown them in their weakness and thus had humiliated them. Out of that resentment, as an act of revenge, they were mean enough to injure the venerable Angulimala by throwing stones and sticks which struck him when he had gone for alms. They must have done so from a safe distance.
Then with blood running from his injured head, with his bowl broken, and with his patchwork robe torn, the venerable Angulimala went to the Blessed One. The Blessed One saw him coming, and he told him: "Bear it, brahmana, bear it, brahmana! You have experienced here and now the ripening of kamma whose ripening you might have experienced in hell over many a year, many a century, many a millennium."
Being a saint, his mind and heart were firm and invulnerable. But the body, the product of former craving, the symbol and fruit of previous kamma, was still there in present existence and was still exposed to the effects of former evil deeds. Even to the Buddha himself it happened that, as a result of former deeds, Devadatta was able to cause him a slight injury. Also his two chief disciples had to experience bodily violence. The venerable Sariputta had been hit on the head by a mischievous demon, and the venerable Maha-Moggallana was even cruelly murdered. If this occurred in the case of these three Great Ones, how could Angulimala have fully avoided bodily harm β he who in his present life had committed so much evil! Yet, it was only his body that received these blows, but not his mind. That remained in invulnerable equipoise.
More post
- π Is the beginning of coming into birth described in the twelve nidanas?
- π What are the six types of equanimity based on the household life?
- π Sacca-pabba Is the reason that commentary commented "ViΓ±Γ±ΔαΉa is JΔti and PaαΉisandhi," right?
- π What are the differences between faith and fides?
- π Historically, where do the concepts of Karma, Nirvana, Dharma and Samsara come from?
- π Reunion with the loved one after death and in next life
- π Need better examples for assuming self to be non-form aggregates
- π Hate myself more and more wish to die
- π What practices are included in (daily lay) life for a Buddhist?
- π What are the boundaries of existence and non-existence in Buddhism?
- π if deities are merely creations of mind,how can there be purelands?
- π Any further question? What best to ask on one's last chance?
- π A good source to learn the Pali language?
- π how desire for cessation, never to be reborn, is different from desire for non-being?
- π Is change permanent?
- π What is the difference between approaching the idea 'no-self' and the act to 'depersonalize'?
- π Why is the Buddha described as trackless?
- π Can or should a Buddhist defend themselves physically?
- π Why are Mahayana texts in Sanskrit?
- π What is Buddhismβs beliefs on humans living with the environment ?
- π Mindfulness when on the train, underground and bus
- π Is it possible to believe (incorrectly) that one is on the path?
- π How do you practice outwardly giving?
- π Is there any point in learning meditation from an unenlightened person?
- π Conversions and former bad deeds
- π Can bodhisatta reborn as mara
- π Wholesome Actions, Three Poisons, and Dukkha
- π What are the benefits of Dhamma in this very life that could be understood by a beginner?
- π How do I practice the Dhamma in an environment where it's not supported?
- π How can anyone who hasn't realised the truth, claim that Mahatma Buddha or any other person in history realised God or the Truth?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π Do the suttas say the "old kamma" of an Arahant continues to fruit?
- π When the Pali suttas say that it is not the "same" thing that is born and dies what do they mean?
- π What do the (Pali) suttas say about "sacrifice" in general (and why it's not necessary)?
- π Where is the Buddha quoted as saying do not believe anything I say until you can prove it by yourself?
- π Did the Buddha speak Pali? Are the suttas his word verbatim?
- π Did the Buddha really say that "life is suffering"?
- π Can a arahant recognize the spiritual attainment of others?
- π Did the Buddha ever say something proven wrong later?
- π Did the Buddha say anything about attachment to meditation?
- π What are the suttas in which the Buddha provides instruction on how to meditate?
- π Which suttas in the Pali canon are relatively early or late?
- π Can a lay person become an Arahant according to the Suttas?
- π What did the Buddha say about music?
- π What is the difference between Suttas and Sutras?
- π What other suttas instruct how to do Anapanasati, apart from the Anapanasati Sutta?
- π What is Death? What did Buddha say regarding the experience of Death?
- π What does the Abhidhamma say about impermanence?
- π Did Buddha say "this is the Middle Way"?
- π Where does the Dalai Lama say '... be a better whatever you already are'?
- π How do the stages of insight before stream entry relate to the suttas
- π Anesthesia, being knocked out, unconsciousness...what does the Buddha have to say about it?
- π What happens if you drop and break a plate of fruit from the Buddha's altar?
- π In which suttas does The Buddha cover annihilationism (ucchedavΔda)?
- π Is it in line with the pali cannon suttas to accept other scriptures?
- π πWhat did the Buddha say about courage?
- π Where does the Buddha say 'you will be punished by your anger'?
- π What are the Pali's suttas commentaries on the three higher knowledges?
- π What does Buddhism say about the consequences of good and bad behaviour?
- π What do Buddhists religious texts say about the environment?
- π Does the Pali Canon say anything about duty to siblings?