Could a Sotapanna reject to give if asked and has?
Upvote:0
Could it be hurtful for one to answer this or is this place void of Sotapannas or advanced?
Of course he/she couldn't reject and if spoken of "hurt oneself" means that it would require to break the precepts, since such is understood as hurtful for oneself.
Having abounded all kind of maccharia and void of ingratitude (having won firm faith in kamma), with the attaining of the path, a person is unable to reject a request that does not require to hurt whom ever knowingly (e.g. goes against the precepts)
"And what is the treasure of generosity? There is the case of a disciple of the noble ones, his awareness cleansed of the stain of stinginess, living at home, freely generous, openhanded, delighting in being magnanimous, responsive to requests, delighting in the distribution of alms. This is called the treasure of generosity.
That being the reason, Bhikkhus are restricted in accepting alms form those "fit to training" to avoid that families would grow poor. More in an "alien" sphere here.
(Note that it is not given for trade, exchange, stacks or what ever binds to this wheel here, but for higher and liberation)
Upvote:4
What does one here think: Is a person, having reached the path, able, would he, reject a request of something material, incl. strength and effort in material spheres, if he could share?
I may have missed it, but i have yet to find something in buddhism that says we should give or agree on something that will be harmful to ourselves (as well as what is harmful to others, of course).
In what cases, if he could reject, would he?
I'm not sure there are any hard rules. It seems that it depends on the situation. I hope someone who knows the sutras better than me could chime in on this.
More post
- 📝 Is this the correct translation and exact meaning of these epic verses in Tripitaka?
- 📝 Is Enlightenment a momentum with a continuum or can have regressions?
- 📝 Metta and Loving-Kindness as a Team
- 📝 Intensifying sensations in Vipassana
- 📝 Choosing between wrong actions
- 📝 How to enter the second Jhana?
- 📝 Should any monastic be considered a noble one?
- 📝 Categories of Dhammanupassana (Satipatthana)
- 📝 What are proper expectations to have about a Sangha?
- 📝 Is it Vipassana?
- 📝 How did this material world come into existence if the ultimate reality is voidness?
- 📝 Sutras are in which Tripitaka
- 📝 Which Buddhist council included the conclusions that there is no creator-god and no day of judgment?
- 📝 Why we can not fulfill our desires?
- 📝 Could Lobha(craving) and Dosa(aversion) be working in tandem?
- 📝 Buddhism Supernatural feats and abilities (Part 2)
- 📝 What happens after the death of a fully enlightened being such as Buddha Shakyamuni?
- 📝 Duty to parents?
- 📝 Continuity With Meditation Practice
- 📝 How does one know that he's reached a Jhana level in Metta meditation?
- 📝 What is the cause of suffering in Buddhism, is it wanting, craving, attachment, or something else?
- 📝 Was buddha aware of future or future way of living?
- 📝 Determination and Impermanence
- 📝 Sanskrit and Pali roots
- 📝 Can a buddhist enjoy life - what are the limitations and restrictions
- 📝 Does "old karma" come from our parents, family, community, surroundings?
- 📝 What are "lower yanas"
- 📝 What is a Sangha? Do you have to be a Buddhist to join a Sangha?
- 📝 Are there differences in the way Buddhism and Theism treats scripture?
- 📝 Can this cause a rebirth as a h*m*sexual?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Could a Sotapanna reject to give if asked and has?
- 📝 What is the difference between a cula sotapanna and 'faith follower' ?
- 📝 Has Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance got anything to do with Zen?
- 📝 Could meditation help with reducing memory and concentration problems? As with ADD or ADHD?
- 📝 Could Lobha(craving) and Dosa(aversion) be working in tandem?
- 📝 According to Buddha's characteristics and teaching in Pali Canon, could he have taught Vajrayana (and Karmamudra)?
- 📝 Where in the Pali Canon does it give examples of right livelihood and it's opposite
- 📝 Why will-power could not be used to regulate kaya , vedana and citta?
- 📝 Could anyone explain: (1) What are the advantages of practicing Guru Yoga? (2) Why (or What are the reasons) practicing Guru Yoga has such advantages?
- 📝 What does "heard" mean in "I allow fish and meat that is pure in three respects: One has not seen, heard, or suspected..."
- 📝 Has Buddha Gautama ever had problems with some autorities about his teachings and way of live?
- 📝 Why would a non-dualist mind choose the Bodhisattva path once it has stopped differentiating between suffering and non-suffering?
- 📝 Becoming a monk and having to give up electronic devices
- 📝 Has anyone claimed to have reborn in Pure Land, and later returned to earth to help other beings?
- 📝 Is there a specific range of meditation styles that could help with extreme clumsiness and disconnected mind-body?
- 📝 Could the Buddha have touched goal and gems in the 7 weeks after enlightenment
- 📝 What could be some teachings that Buddha has not revealed to us?
- 📝 Can effective altruism (specifically Earning to Give) and Buddhism co-exist if Earning to Give was done to the extreme?
- 📝 Minimum common grounds for all sotapanna and all arahant
- 📝 What would be some very concise Buddhist teachings and symbols that could be on (future) coinage?
- 📝 Supposed one could give you Cockayne, would you strife for Nibbana?
- 📝 Is killing vermin and insects justifiable?
- 📝 Should one give to beggars?
- 📝 What are the differences between vipassana and mindfulness meditation?
- 📝 Relationship with bad parents (kamma and issues)
- 📝 Are Vajrayana and Tibetan Buddhism the same thing?
- 📝 Comparison of Nirvana, Tao and Brahman/Atma
- 📝 How to deal with people and handle rude language?
- 📝 As a Buddhist with a Muslim family, community, and background... how do you integrate/cope?
- 📝 How concentrated is access concentration and how would one recognise it?