Was Russo-Polish of 1919-1920 a war of independence?
score:17
If Germany decided to invade Poland to get back East Prussia that it lost to Poland after WWII - would it be a war of independence?
One needs a lot of fantasy to call the Polish–Soviet War (this seems to be the official name of the conflict) a war of independence. In 1919 Poland was already independent - it gained its independence with the Treaty of Versailles. The issue was rather that Poland wasn't satisfied with the territories it gained and would like to recover all the territories it lost in the partitions. This meant first suppressing the Ukrainian independence movement in the Western Ukraine (Polish-Ukrainian War). But given that Western Ukraine had a large Polish population one could still explain it with defending the newly born Polish state.
This explanation no longer works for the Polish invasion of East Ukraine and Belarus in the course of the Polish-Soviet War. While these territories historically belonged to Poland (they changed hands a number of times actually) they didn't have a significant Polish population. So this had nothing to do with independence. Instead, there were quite obvious strategical reasons:
- The time was right, the Soviet Russia being disorganized and busy fighting a civil war.
- The Soviet government never made a secret out of its intention to invade Western Europe through Poland, a war seemed inevitable.
- Moving the state borders eastwards gave Poland an advantage in case of a Soviet aggression.
- Poland was hoping to establish a new power that would be able to oppose Germany and Soviet Russia that were threatening it - they were probably thinking of something like the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth.
And while time proved that Poland's fears weren't unfounded (Poland was once again occupied by Germany and Soviet Union in 1939) - it was a war over territory and power, not independence.
Upvote:-4
It was indeed a war of independence that was played out within the larger context of the First World War, the 1917 Russian Revolution and subsequent Russian Civil War.
Poland had been conquered by Russia during the 19th century but Polish identity and nationalism never died. Recognizing this, the Germans hoped to win away the support of the Polish people from Russia during the First World War by aiding Polish aspirations for independence in 1916, albeit in a heavy-handed manner.
After the October Revolution, Vladimir Lenin felt that a great revolution would sweep Europe and Germany was seen as the ideal epicenter. That drove the Bolshevik desire of advancing the revolution with its Red Army into Germany and to do so, it had to advance across Poland, both politically and militarily. Polish independence goals, captured in the ideas of Josef Pilsudski, envisioned a "Greater" Poland that included Vilnius and the western Ukraine. Those conflicting Soviet and Polish objectives made the conflict inevitable in 1919.
By the way, unpublished (secret) articles in the 1939 Soviet-German Non-Aggression Pact dealt with the invasion and partition of Poland between Hitler and Stalin. According to the research of Dr. Stuart Goldman, The Red Army did not cross the Polish Frontier until 17 September 1939 because Stalin had to remove the threat of the two-front war by resolving the conflict with Japan over Nomonhan in Outer Mongolia, which was not completed until 16 September when a ceasefire went into effect.
When the Soviets invaded, the British and French seized on technicalities in the language of the military alliances with Poland to avoid going to war with Stalin, acts that may have been dishonorable, but in reality, they had no rational choice. Hitler then betrayed Stalin and attacked the Soviet Union in June 1941, sealing the fate of Nazi Germany.
Upvote:-2
In my opinion, a "war of independence" is war where the very independence of a newly born country is at stake. There is no question that if Soviet Russia won the war with Poland in 1920, Poland would lose independence, which it barely gained a short while before. Therefore, from the Polish POV it was a "war of independence".
Going back in time a little, the Polish-Ukrainian offensive of early 1920 was meant to safeguard Polish independence by creating independent Ukraine under Petlura, and therefore it can also be considered a part of "war of independence".
Upvote:-2
i think that the Russia would of won if they had of came up with a better and stronger plan to defeat Poland and Ukraine in the war but Ukraine had the first horsed arm and the polish retreated when it came from the front line of Ukraine.
Russia had an advantage because they had more soldiers in the war and Poland and Ukraine had 10-20 thousand less. Poland took Russia by surprise and destroyed their front line of defense and forced them to retreat.
Upvote:12
The Polish-Bolshevik war (as it is known in Poland, I believe rest of the world use term Polish-Soviet war) is not known as the war for independence. After all, Poland re-gained independence on November 11, 1918 - when I World War ended (which was later confirmed by the Treaty of Versailles).
In this light, things like Greater Poland Uprising, Silesian Uprisings and Polish-Bolshevik war simply could not be treated as independence movements.
As for causes of the war you are asking about, as always there are few. I strongly believe, on one hand it has something to do with distrust between Poland and Soviet Russia (Polish politicians simply thought the Russians want to gain some time and their peace treaty offer is not real.)
On the other hand, it might be very strange for other nations, but there is a concept of Messianism in Poland, that is a few people really believed that "Poland is a Christ of nations", Antemurale Christianitatis and so on. These people really believed that Poland have to fight (and stop) Bolshevism (and that Poland can do that with western military aid). And to be honest, this kind of thinking is quite common in Poland, even nowadays. I came across Polish "historian", who thinks that Piłsudzki saved the world from Soviet domination during Battle of Warsaw. Many people still attribute the win in this battle to some mysterious wonders (divine intervention) rather to the fact that Polish Intelligence broke Soviet Codes and knew exactly (sometimes even better than Russians) of Soviet military movements (and of course they also knew that Stalin is not going to help Tukhachevsky.)
Personally, I don't think it was fight for Great Poland, or re-born of Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, it was rather preventive war.
Although, I might be wrong - given the facts like annexation of Vilnius Region and annexation of Zaolzie, Second Polish Republic was fairly aggressive and who knows what Piłsudzki and his friends thought...
More post
- 📝 Why do the Japanese sing Ode to Joy during the Japanese New Year?
- 📝 How were the British and French Mandates in the Levantine area involved in WWII?
- 📝 How did the helmsman know what he was sailing towards with a big mast in his face?
- 📝 How did the gold of the new world cause the Spanish Empire to collapse?
- 📝 Why did this anti-communist pamphlet, from the USA in the 1950s, include UNESCO among its targets?
- 📝 Was there ever a situation where members of two warring militaries were on leave in the same neutral location?
- 📝 Did Joseph II introduce the presumption of innocence in his legal code?
- 📝 How did women give birth in middle ages?
- 📝 What is the longest effective range artillery weapon ever built?
- 📝 Instances of the UN defusing serious crises
- 📝 Was arson prominent in the Kingdom of Hawaii?
- 📝 Why was IJN apparently inactive mid-war?
- 📝 Building a house in the middle age in europe (specifically germany)
- 📝 US "destroyed" Libya: how viable is this as a reading of the history?
- 📝 Do we know who graduated from the University of Mexico in the 1700s?
- 📝 Who were the victims of the 1907 Tiflis bank robbery?
- 📝 What is a "Johnsonian world of clubs and coffee houses" in the context of 18th century England?
- 📝 Were the Nazis actually ever horrified of anything that the Imperial Japanese Army did or vice-versa?
- 📝 How many rapes did the Wehrmacht commit in the Soviet Union during World War II?
- 📝 What day and year was the first public & general confession held in the Church of England?
- 📝 Why didn't the Romans use the army to repel the siege of Rome in 410?
- 📝 Are there any surviving historical written records about Black individuals in Sub-Saharan African languages?
- 📝 Which city has had the most name changes?
- 📝 Why did Thomas Hendricks win the majority of Horace Greeley's electoral votes in 1872?
- 📝 Why is the name "Tecumseh" used for US Navy ships?
- 📝 Did the Truman Doctrine contribute to the Cuban Missile Crisis?
- 📝 Was Pericles the only famous loss from the plague in Athens?
- 📝 Were Egyptian Pharaohs literate?
- 📝 Why were there "Tributary States" to the Ottoman Empire?
- 📝 Why is the Harappa (Indus Valley) civilization considered one of the six independent cradles of civilization?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 When was the American War of Independence first called a 'Revolution'?
- 📝 Why was the Irish War of Independence in 1918 successful when other revolts failed?
- 📝 Was the factional civil war that broke out in Angola after its independence in 1975 based on tribal rivalry?
- 📝 Why was France granted an equal status among victors of World War II?
- 📝 Why was Spanish Fascist dictatorship left in power after World War II?
- 📝 Why was World War I ended on Nov 11 11:00, rather than immediately upon signing the armistice?
- 📝 What was the reason for Soviet troops to withdraw from Yugoslavia in World War II?
- 📝 Was World War I a war of liberals against authoritarians?
- 📝 Was the American Civil War the “bloodiest civil war in history”?
- 📝 What was the longest a World War II submarine stayed at sea without being resupplied at a port?
- 📝 What was the cleanest war ever fought?
- 📝 What was the Seven Years War called at first?
- 📝 How were diplomats and their staffs treated when World War II was declared?
- 📝 What was the ratio women to men after World War 2 in the Soviet Union
- 📝 Was Switzerland pressured either by Allies or Axis to take part in World War 2 at any time?
- 📝 Why was the Western Front so static in World War I?
- 📝 What was the first known war in history?
- 📝 By mid-1945, was Japan capable of maintaining the war even in the absence of further direct American attacks?
- 📝 Which was the last major war in which horse mounted cavalry actually participated in active fighting?
- 📝 Which was the first war in which photography was employed?
- 📝 Why was the Cold War carried out over the whole world instead of between Siberia and Alaska?
- 📝 What was the Hundred Years' War called at the time?
- 📝 How was beer production affected by the war during WW2?
- 📝 Was Russia the only country in WWII that succeeded in expansionist war aims?
- 📝 What was the first successful non violent independence movement?
- 📝 Why was Washington State an attractive site for aluminum production during World War II?
- 📝 What is the name and meaning of a World War 2 CCC Medal with both the Polish Eagle and British Statant Gardant Lion?
- 📝 Was the Zimmerman Telegram a ruse on the US or a way of Germany to incite Mexico to declare war on the US?
- 📝 During World War I, why were church bells stopped until the war was over?
- 📝 Why was the last battle of the War of 1812 fought fully half a year after the official end of the war?