Have interior lines ever mattered?
Upvote:2
Discarding city sieges, where encirclement is the idea, in the battlefield there are some examples.
Napoleon started the battle of Leipzig in the middle of the battlefield, and he never avoided the encirclement. He moved his forces to each flank depending of the battle development. Later on in Waterloo (Quatre Bras and Ligny), Napoleon started the battle attacking the middle of the enemy line in order to separate english and prussian forces, neglecting the risk of being encircled.
Caesar in Alesia didn't avoid encirclement, and he fortified himself in order to keep his position sieging the fortress of Alesia.
Alexander in Gaugamela fought an enemy so big that he was innevitable encircled, so he planned the battle expecting being encircled and then he attacked the weakened center of the persian line.
Upvote:3
Examples are medieval sieges, when a small defending force could stand against a large besieging army for long time, sometimes for several years.
In the modern (20 century) wars encirclement is always a disadvantage because modern armies need enormous amount of supplies to continue fighting. For this reason an encircled army cannot hold for long time.
EDIT. In this WWII Disney movie, Alexander de Seversky makes exactly this argument on the strategic level: Germany surrounded by the allies has advantage of short communication lines. But the ideas of this movie are highly controversial:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J1iPBvwaIkI
Especially minutes 40-45.
More post
- 📝 What does Spivak mean by "epistemic violence" in her paper "can the subaltern speak"?
- 📝 What was the internal Soviet reaction to the moon landing?
- 📝 Have the Arabs ever conquered Kayseri?
- 📝 Churchill's words about war escaping - any reference in his biography or memoir?
- 📝 Did any armies systemically favor axes/hammers over swords?
- 📝 How easy one could start an artel in USSR after WW2 1945-1956?
- 📝 How hard did they beat up Henry II after the murder of Thomas Becket?
- 📝 What is the date and original source of this medieval picture?
- 📝 What did parchment and papyrus cost in the Roman Empire?
- 📝 How is the oldest bank in Mongolia only 24 years old?
- 📝 Californian ocean-going ships
- 📝 Why are major streets in urban regions not build tunnel like?
- 📝 Have democratic nations with their own constitutional monarchies become republics, and in what form?
- 📝 Did any Ethiopian leaders help the Italians?
- 📝 What was the earliest professional recording of "Happy Birthday to You"?
- 📝 Cover Art of "Álbum de la Revolución Cubana"
- 📝 Was merchant Hugh McCulloch the first Scotsman to set foot in California?
- 📝 How much in total did Nazi Germany spend on their war machine
- 📝 What percentage of the population in the "Old West" actually carried handguns?
- 📝 Help identify this poster of early 1900's movie with a woman sitting on a bench and a man behind holding her arm
- 📝 Did Europe experience forest deficits prior to 19th century?
- 📝 Why would chickens be blue in the Soviet Union?
- 📝 Which event is this memorial referring to when it says WW1 ended in 1919?
- 📝 What was the most recent Catholic coronation ceremony of a king?
- 📝 How common was the German desire for revenge for the humiliation of 1918 armistice?
- 📝 How were wars financed under Islamic empires?
- 📝 What education path had to be followed to study law in 17th century Europe?
- 📝 What's a good general history book on Italy, 1400-1600?
- 📝 Was King Henry VIII, mid-late in his reformation campaign, motivated more by theology or absolutist drive?
- 📝 "You Are Now Entering the X Sector"
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Have interior lines ever mattered?
- 📝 Have American urban rioters ever looted residences?
- 📝 Have fair-skinned peoples ever been the lower/oppressed class?
- 📝 Have any kings ever been serving admirals?
- 📝 Did military operation names ever have any meaning?
- 📝 Have Germany and Poland ever signed a peace treaty after WWII?
- 📝 Was the interior of Hagia Sophia in Constantinople ever covered with mosaic icons?
- 📝 Did war chariots ever actually have blades on the wheel hubs?
- 📝 Could Thomas Jefferson have ever heard Mozart's Symphony No. 40, KV. 550?
- 📝 Have any artifacts or archaeological remains from the White Ship disaster of 1120 ever been recovered?
- 📝 Have Moscow and Beijing ever been cities under the same rule?
- 📝 Have famous rabbis ever converted to Islam?
- 📝 Did the Russian Empire have a claim to Sweden? Was there ever a time where they could have pursued it?
- 📝 Have primary voters in US overseas territories or their delegates ever had a noteworthy influence in any primary election or convention?
- 📝 Is there a record of the times the nuclear brief case or its Russian counterpart have ever been actually opened?
- 📝 Have the Romani people (gypsies) ever fought back violently against prejudice?
- 📝 Have American gangsters ever helped their government in war time out of patriotism?
- 📝 Do photos of Wernher von Braun and Neil Armstrong exist? Have they ever met?
- 📝 Have voice actors ever been used to impersonate military or political officials to trick the enemy into doing something?
- 📝 Have there ever been maximum age limits for public office in the United States?
- 📝 Have US troops ever been lawfully quartered in private homes during wartime under the Third Amendment?
- 📝 Have any spies ever managed to keep their identity secret from their handlers?
- 📝 Have atheists ever been persecuted in India?
- 📝 Have fashionable hair lengths ever been reversed from their current styles?
- 📝 Have map projections and distortions ever affected treaties?
- 📝 Have the arts ever moved borders?
- 📝 Have sanctions ever stopped a nation from starting or continuing a war?
- 📝 Prior to 1963 did a British nobleman ever disclaim or renounce his title? What would have happened if someone had tried?
- 📝 Did French ever have any special status in Austria?
- 📝 Have any large scale cultural or ideological shifts ever been successfully reversed by those who opposed it?