Is the use by old masters of camera obscura and optics in general a taboo topic in Art History, or was David Hockney's thesis wrong?
score:9
Hockney's claims have drawn at least some serious scholarly attention and experimentation.
The Art & Optics website hosted by Brandeis University reviews the theory, experiments, and arguments for and against the use of optics by old masters -- noting that evidence that some painters may have used some devices in some paintings doesn't mean they used them in other paintings.
One note is that the mechanical drawing underlying a painting is only one aspect of the painting's production and impact, neglecting choice of subject matter, composition, use of materials, application of stroke and color, glazing, and more. The documentary Tim's Vermeer drew mockery for lauding Tim Jenison's dab-by-dab work replicating the surface of Vermeer's The Music Lesson as anything comparable to the process of producing the original work.
The evolution of Western art that you note involves far more than the technical precision of using optics for drawing, and of course there have been many phases of Western art that valued less-precise, even impressionistic interpretations of scenery, still lives, and society.
Upvote:-4
Have you actually looked at any paintings from before the renaissance? There's plenty that look accurate. Besides, David Hockney, whilst he was at art school made a point of not going to art history lessons, so I'd take his ideas here with a large dose of salt.
Have art historians given Hockneys ideas the attention it deserves?
Why should they? He disrespected them all the way through art college!
Upvote:3
The Hockney-Falco thesis is NOT a taboo subject in art history.
This is not going to be regarded as a good answer because I can't cite any written sources, I've asked former art students who were aware of the theory and had been taught it at college. Also, there has been plenty of discussion of the idea over the last twenty years. When it was introduced it was very controversial and there was much discussion and research.
Over time, its importance has faded; the good parts have been retained, the bad are ignored. I'm happy to discuss the good and the bad elsewhere, this is an attempt to provide a direct answer to the question
More post
- 📝 Why did Napoleon march to Moscow instead of Saint Petersburg?
- 📝 Did Benjamin Franklin say "Holland is not a nation but a shop"? Why?
- 📝 How were native laborers on California ranchos treated?
- 📝 What is a term for cultural and social influences left by colonial power that has a long-lasting, negative influence?
- 📝 Did Victorian(-era) British officers knowingly fire their revolvers at targets clearly out of range?
- 📝 What was the first health insurance company in America?
- 📝 When did private fighting become a capital offense in Japan?
- 📝 What does it mean to "take the Cross"
- 📝 Why was the Greek alphabet not adopted by other languages, given the Greek influence?
- 📝 Was the Waffen-SS an elite force?
- 📝 What prevented the Mongolian Empire from expanding into Europe?
- 📝 How likely is it that any non-Celtic language was spoken in the British Isles when the Romans invaded?
- 📝 When did cavalry soldiers unsheathe swords?
- 📝 How do present-day Austrians look back at the 1938 Anschluss?
- 📝 Did everyone have to carry identity papers in Nazi Germany?
- 📝 Source of the Napoleon "God/Devil/immortal" quote
- 📝 When was the last time that a personal union of thrones led to an effective integration of the nations?
- 📝 What were the incentives for war during the Warring States Period?
- 📝 Voting enfranchis*m*nt in the USA in the 18th century
- 📝 How did the development in education impact the curiosity and creativity in German society pre and post WWI?
- 📝 Did the USSR have any position on global warming?
- 📝 What did Alexander Hamilton write about Aaron Burr's daughter?
- 📝 Was Rudolph Hess a moderating influence on Hitler?
- 📝 Was "leather" really a technology introduced by Europeans to the Plains Indians?
- 📝 Has there been a naval battle where a boarding attempt backfired?
- 📝 What explains this dip in Indonesian GDP growth rate in 1982?
- 📝 Is biblical Joseph story historically valid?
- 📝 Did the Roman testudo protect the sides of the formation?
- 📝 How did native Americans and European colonists conduct their trades?
- 📝 Nazi Germany - Income of low-wage workers, and prices of food and other items?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Is the use by old masters of camera obscura and optics in general a taboo topic in Art History, or was David Hockney's thesis wrong?
- 📝 Why did only the English adopt, evolve and use the longbow en masse in war?
- 📝 When and why did the use of the lifespans of royalty to limit clauses in contracts come about?
- 📝 Why, in old movies and TV series, do they always use such extremely exaggerated wheel turns when driving a car?
- 📝 How to explain the apparent discrepancy in the use of papyrus vs. clay tablets between Ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia?
- 📝 When did the round house fall out of vernacular use throughout Britain and Ireland?
- 📝 Why didn't the Persians make and use ballistas and other kinds of artillery?
- 📝 Were there any crops and livestock common to both the Old and New Worlds prior to the Columbian exchange?
- 📝 Did the Germans use the V1 and V2 missile system on the Eastern Front in World War 2?
- 📝 In the British empire, what was the difference between a Governor General and a Viceroy?
- 📝 The first use of submarines, and the appearance of "modern" submarines
- 📝 Why did the US Navy and Marine Corps use satanic symbolism in WW2?
- 📝 What was the first confirmed use of black powder to blow stuff up in war (in China and in Europe)?
- 📝 What was the currency in use in Palestine shortly before and during WWI?
- 📝 Did pagan tribes in the Arab peninsula use bells for superstitious or religious reasons before and with the introduction of Islam?
- 📝 What methods did the Old Babylonian society use for solving equations?
- 📝 In Russia, are the anniversaries of the various events that occurred in 1917 and '18 observed according to the Old Style or the New Style calendar?
- 📝 What was the difference between a WWII Engineer General Service Regiment and a Service Unit?
- 📝 Why do schools in Taiwan, Japan, and South Korea use the Westminster Quarters as school chime?
- 📝 Did Hitler and Nazi officials give interviews and cooperate with the Weimar republic general press?
- 📝 Did syphilis, polio, hepatitis, and encephalitis come to general world from the Americas?
- 📝 Did the Greeks and Romans use reputational incentives to induce people to pay more tax?
- 📝 During the Chola dynasty how extensive was the use of Sanskrit in government and by the people?
- 📝 Were the Western World's general political and ideological consensus and consequent actions primarily responsible for the global ending of slavery?
- 📝 Were Rosa Parks and Freedom Riders the first ones to use a bus to protest/change?
- 📝 Why did the Chinese not use military power to force out early Portuguese, Dutch and English trade encroachments?
- 📝 What form of cookware did Inuits use in the old days?
- 📝 What tone of voice and demeanor did Winston Churchill use in the House of Commons during his "We will never surrender" comment on June ,1940?
- 📝 How frequently did the KMT use telegrams to communicate; from where (roughly) and to whom?
- 📝 Why does the Canadian Air Force name its ranks like its Army, whilst the Australian and New Zealand Air Forces use the Royal Air Force's?