Were early mosques originally oriented on Petra instead of Mecca according to archaeological record?
Upvote:-1
This and other questions about the history of Islam in its first 100 years, from which very few written records survive, are discussed in Peter Townsend's book 'The Mecca Mystery' and also the debate 'Did the Mohammed of the Quran exist?' between Jay Smith and David Wood on YouTube.
The few surviving mosques from the 7th Century and early 8th Century AD (so 1st Century of the Islamic Calendar) tend to show an orientation towards the area of Petra, which in later mosques is towards Mecca. Given the lack of independent evidence of Mecca existing before the Islamic period some have argued that much of the early history of Islam is false and it may have begun as a vaguer monotheistic religion based at Petra, initially in alliance with Jews.
My own view after listening to the above debate is that this is too radical an interpretation and that it would not have been possible to move the place of pilgrimage several hundred miles in the early 8th Century without causing serious commotion within the Islamic World and probably a lasting schism. Most likely the mosques pointing roughly towards Petra were oriented inaccurately using the stars as a guide, before more accurate geographical information became known.
However, I am persuaded of the wider point that the early history of Islam is so poorly documented that some of what has long been taught may well not be true.
Upvote:11
First, there’s a Wikipedia article on Dan Gibson, and it says he is not a professional historian, and is criticized by them. The article also contains links to critical reviews you may want to read. For example, here’s a criticism from David King and Gibson’s response.
However, it’s a traditional knowledge in Islam that before Mecca, Jerusalem was Qibla. The switch happened in Muhammad’s lifetime, actually, they switched mid-prayer. See Wikipedia article for the mosque where it happened. But I never heard of any other surviving mihrab pointing to Jerusalem.
In addition to that, I’d say that early mosques were likely built with much rougher directions than later when Islamic scholars honed their astronomy for this very purpose.
More post
- 📝 What is the history of the Roman ogee shape?
- 📝 Sources on common people history
- 📝 Were British officers able to return home after the American Revolution?
- 📝 What are the intellectual roots of the "French Republican identity" pursuit?
- 📝 How did western saloons lock up for the night?
- 📝 British Diplomat's Guide to the Balkan Races
- 📝 What is this strange uniform?
- 📝 Was pie crust originally meant for throwing away in England?
- 📝 What is the earliest known reference to the phrase 'water of life'?
- 📝 Chancery vs Common Pleas vs Exchequer vs King's Bench
- 📝 Did the Romans Hold Territory in Ukraine?
- 📝 How did Victorian British conservatives resolve the tension between valuing tradition and spreading empire?
- 📝 Why was A.K.Gastev purged in 1939?
- 📝 Was COMECON involved in economic imperialism and if so, to what extent?
- 📝 How did the Romans build straight roads that stretched very long distances?
- 📝 How many stones high are the pyramids of Giza?
- 📝 Was there a noble cause to Genghis Khan's campaign?
- 📝 Catholic vs Protestant Support for Nazism in Germany
- 📝 Is there evidence to suggest that the strike of the Matchwomen in 1888 gave rise to the modern union movement?
- 📝 What kind of uniform is this? (Circa 1940s, possibly Israeli)
- 📝 Was there significant interbreeding between Romans and Native Britons?
- 📝 How many Samurai killed themselves?
- 📝 What does Deng Xiaoping mean by "Hide your capacities, bide your time '?
- 📝 When were terms for points of sail first used?
- 📝 What is the name of the Phoenician religion?
- 📝 Losses in reserve units during battles in Napoleonic wars
- 📝 Is this article on Nero even remotely accurate?
- 📝 Was there any imperial nation whose home country was conquered but was able to retain its colonies?
- 📝 How British was Barry Melbourne Hussey, Argentine Navy translator, at the Argentine surrender in the Falklands War?
- 📝 What did executioners do when not performing executions?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Were early mosques originally oriented on Petra instead of Mecca according to archaeological record?
- 📝 Why did Roosevelt and Churchill use voice-based telecommunication, instead of simpler text-based options which were easier to encrypt?
- 📝 Were there originally seats in the elevators in the Eiffel Tower?
- 📝 How aware were the latter Greek-speaking Romans (ERE: Byzantines) of the early history of Rome?
- 📝 Were US exports in the early 1800s paid for with metal or with paper?
- 📝 Were any of the early settlements in America attacked from the sea?
- 📝 How many acres per person were needed for the early American settlers vs. the native Americans?
- 📝 Why were 40,000 German troops left in Prague instead of pulled back to defend Berlin?
- 📝 When were the first mosques established in Constantinople?
- 📝 Were death camps originally intended as death camps and if not, what changed?
- 📝 Were early accounts of ancient child prostitution accurate?
- 📝 What trains were used on the Dakar-Niger Railway in the late 1950s and early 1960s?
- 📝 What demographic of people were the Ford Motor's Company biggest customers during the car boom of the early twentieth Century?
- 📝 How were enslaved girls usually dressed in Arabia in early Islamic societies?
- 📝 What were women's social conditions in early 19th century Russia?
- 📝 What advanced educational opportunities were available to native Africans in the early 1890's?
- 📝 What type of ferry boats were used in England in the early 19th century?
- 📝 How did early Judaism and Zoroastrianism influence each other, if they were so far apart?
- 📝 Were the ancestors of Malays originally from Yunnan, China?
- 📝 Were bricks instead of bombs occasionally thrown out of war planes in WWI?
- 📝 How were cities administered in the early Byzantine Empire?
- 📝 What were the duties of a scullery maid in the early 1900's?
- 📝 Why were the Japanese so much better at night flying early in WWII?
- 📝 What percentage of slaves originally brought from Africa were purchased from slave traders as opposed to having been captured by Europeans?
- 📝 In the past were there gifts on the days leading up to Christmas instead of them all being on the one day?
- 📝 How were British monarchs educated about military strategy in the Middle Ages and early modern period?
- 📝 Were the names of the 10 months in the ancient Roman Calendar originally named after ordinal numbers?
- 📝 Were life imprisonment and mental insanity the only reasons a divorce couldn't be granted in early 20th century England?
- 📝 How were British tea taxes collected in Boston in the early 1770s?
- 📝 What kings were considered to be divine by Ancient Egyptians, according to DIODORUS SICULUS?