If Abraham killed Isaac, would that be a sin?
Upvote:0
The (a?) definition of 'sin' is: "an immoral act considered to be a transgression against divine law."
Since, in this context, God is the originator of 'divine law' nothing he orders one to do should be 'sin' ... since not doing as commanded represents a 'transgression' THAT could be considered 'sin'.
In the context of the Abraham/Isaac story, the whole thing is a test of Abraham's commitment to his God ... it is therefore reasonable to assume that socially, killing one's children was considered wrong/immoral. Otherwise it would be no test at all.
Simply put, obeying a direct order from God cannot be a sin.
Upvote:0
First, do we consider all types of killing a sin?
We are smart enough to tell the difference between murder and killing. Soldiers are empowered to kill. People in the executive arm of government kill. When these people kill, we see them as discharging a duty of honor. We do not see them as murderers.
If God had not rescinded his order and Abraham had eventually gone ahead to obey God's command and killed Isaac, would that have been a sin? What law would he have broken?
On the contrary, if Abraham had decided not to follow God's command, would that have been a virtue? Would that have made him a God-fearing man?
Note: The people who lived before Moses lived under the natural law and understood they were not supposed to commit murder. God punished Cain for killing his brother. So, that there was no 10 commandments before Moses was no excuse.
Upvote:1
God warned Abraham not to harm Isaac just before he was about to strike Isaac.
Just then the angel of the LORD called out to him from heaven, “Abraham, Abraham!”
“Here I am,” he replied.
“Do not lay a hand on the boy or do anything to him,” said the angel, “for now I know that you fear God, since you have not withheld your only son from me.”
So, simply put, if Abraham had killed Isaac, it would not have been out of obedience, and therefore a sin.
Upvote:2
No, for the same reason that it was not a sin when the Israelites obeyed God's command to kill the Canaanites to take possession of Canaan. As the Life Giver, God is the only one who can decide when to end life without it being a sin.
Upvote:3
There's a saying in logic, that almost anything can be proved if one is allowed even a single false premise. This question starts with the false premise that "Abraham killed Isaac", so from there it's possible to conclude whatever one wants.
The point is, that Abraham didn't kill Isaac, so any conclusion based on that event having happened is meaningless.
Keep in mind that God will never encourage anyone to sin:
Let no one say when he is tempted, “I am tempted by God”; for God cannot be tempted by evil, nor does He Himself tempt anyone.
— James 1:13
More post
- 📝 St Augustine's saying on redemption
- 📝 Is Partialism a real heresy?
- 📝 Is Latin considered a holy language in the Catholic Church?
- 📝 Can a devil use one prayer to prevent us from praying different one? (Catholic perspective)
- 📝 Does Irenaeus indicate that people were raised from the dead in the 2nd century?
- 📝 Do Full Preterists believe that the perfect came and the gifts of the Spirit ceased in A.D. 70, as per 1 Corinthians 13:8-12?
- 📝 What is the Biblical Basis for Christians keeping the Sabbath?
- 📝 Catholicism - Is the TULIP Formula more or less true? (Semantics)
- 📝 Was Calvin a Nestorian?
- 📝 How is the Vulgate rendering of Romans 5:12 explained (Roman Catholic perspective)?
- 📝 Why does the RCC create modern saints?
- 📝 What was Brigham Young's teaching regarding Adam being God?
- 📝 Do Eucharistic miracles all have the same DNA?
- 📝 What is the function of permanent acolytes and lectors in the Catholic Church?
- 📝 Do Protestants appreciate the significance of Mary's genealogy?
- 📝 How do Catholics view the role of conscience in determing morals?
- 📝 Did Adam need to have faith for his salvation?
- 📝 What is "your peace" in Matthew 10?
- 📝 Should a Bible believing Christian be pleased at the death of Osama bin Laden?
- 📝 When would a Mormon choose to go to the temple instead of the church?
- 📝 How do Trinitarians interpret John 3:35?
- 📝 In 1 Peter 4:18, what does Peter mean by the righteous having difficulty to be saved?
- 📝 Where can I find official documents of Buenos Aires' Eucharistic Miracle?
- 📝 What is The Second book of Homilies mentioned in the Anglican 39 articles of faith?
- 📝 Contradiction or translation problem with Moses in Exodus?
- 📝 What is the simplest, clearest interpretation of the English text of the Authorized Version on Romans 9:5?
- 📝 According to Christians who believe that salvation can be lost, what is spiritual rebirth, what is eternal life and can salvation be regained?
- 📝 Why does Catholicism impose restrictions on receiving the Eucharist?
- 📝 I'm a practicing Roman Catholic, but considering attending a Greek Orthodox church instead of our local RC church. Will I be welcomed?
- 📝 When 1 Timothy cautions against "endless geneologies", is it talking about the Bible?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 If Abraham killed Isaac, would that be a sin?
- 📝 Did Judas Iscariot know that Jesus would be killed when he turned Jesus over to the Pharisees?
- 📝 Who learned that Abraham would even sacrifice his son in Genesis 22:11?
- 📝 Does Catholic doctrine teach that the Incarnation would have taken place regardless of Adam's decision?
- 📝 When Jesus gave Peter his name (rock) what is the significance that he then said upon a ‘different’ kind of rock he would build his church?
- 📝 Why did the people believe that no one would know where the Christ came from?
- 📝 Did Mary know that her Baby Boy would "soon deliver her"?
- 📝 Did adherents of apocatastasis in the early church believe that the devil and his demons would be restored?
- 📝 Is there a name for the belief that some individuals would always freely reject salvation no matter the world in which they are created?
- 📝 If Satan fell because of sin, then was there sin in heaven at that point?
- 📝 How do evangelical universalists reconcile their position with the designation for Judas that it would be better if he had never been born?
- 📝 Before anything was created, did God already know the events that would unfold?
- 📝 According to Catholics were Adam and Eve aware that they possessed immortal souls before Satan told Eve that she would not die?
- 📝 Did Luther ever acknowledge that his Catechism would require textual changes as language evolves?
- 📝 According to LDS, if the Fall was a positive thing why would God condemn sin in the flesh?
- 📝 How do those who hold to a literal interpretation of the flood account respond to the criticism that Noah building the ark would be unfeasible?
- 📝 What is the earliest reference to the notion that we killed Jesus?
- 📝 What is the basis for believing that 40 lashes would be deadly (especially in Roman law or jurisprudence)?
- 📝 Why did Eve say that "touching" the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil would kill you?
- 📝 Was it Adino or his army that killed eight hundred at one time?
- 📝 Is there any historical evidence that would indicate where exactly the ark of the covenant is now located?
- 📝 At what age and how do young Catholics know or be notified that they have committed a mortal sin or a venial sin?
- 📝 Why did God create Adam and Eve so that they would sin?
- 📝 Age of Isaac When Abraham Offered Him as a Sacrifice?
- 📝 Is Job's statement that his redeemer lives and would stand upon the Earth, a statement of faith or a prediction of Christ?
- 📝 Did Jesus mean that heaven and earth would actually pass away in Matthew 24:25?
- 📝 How would Catholics respond to the theory that Mary was a surrogate mother that had no DNA in common with Jesus?
- 📝 Where in the Pentateuch does it indicate that it's better to sin against God than against your spiritual director?
- 📝 According to open theism, did God know that the crucifixion of Jesus would benefit anyone after him?
- 📝 Do Mormons believe that we currently live near the time when Jesus would return?