If a Catholic priest absolves my sins without taking a confession, does it still count?
Upvote:6
The sacrament was invalidly administered to you because it lacked proper matter (your auricular confession of your sins).
Chapter 6 of the 14th session of the Council of Trent has good advice regarding your situation:
The penitent, therefore, ought not so flatter himself on his own faith as to think that even though he have no contrition and there be wanting on the part of the priest the intention to act earnestly and absolve effectively, he is nevertheless really and in the sight of God absolved by reason of faith alone. For faith without penance effects no remission of sins, and he would be most negligent of his salvation who, knowing that a priest absolved him jokingly [joco], would not diligently seek another who would act earnestly.
In other words: Seek another, more competent confessor; re-confess your sins to him; explain to him your desire for proper absolution (which would contribute to showing your firm purpose of amendment).
Upvote:7
Without a doubt, no.
Intention, Form and Matter
The Church teaches that a sacrament of the Church consists in three necessary things:
The intention to effect the sacrament according to the mind of the Church on the the part of the minister thereof (i.e. not with some other intention alien to the purpose of the sacrament and to the Church).
The valid form (i.e. the prescribed words used during the administration of the sacrament: e.g. "I baptize you in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost" for the Sacrament of Baptism).
The matter of the sacrament (the 'stuff' involved in constituting the sacrament validly: e.g. unleaved bread and grape wine for the Sacrament of Holy Communion).
In the case of the priest, he needs to use the valid form (words) of absolution. We can assume your priest knew the form and said it correctly. However, he did not have the matter of the sacrament, which are, in the case of confession: contrition for the sins committed (regret and sorrow for having sinned against God) and auricular confession of those sins.
A Few Reasons This Needs to be the Case
Scripture says, "If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just, to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all iniquity" (1 John 1:9). Stopping by for the priest to pray over you is not the sacrament of confession, since he can't grant God's absolution without a confession; for the same reason a man or woman cannot bring about the sacrament of Matrimony without the equal consent of their partner. This is better understood when one realizes that the priest is a mediator of God's mercy, which implies that he has one hand to Christ and the other to you: you must participateβthat's why you are there.
When Christ endows the Apostles with this priestly power of forgiving sins, he notably says "whose sins you shall hold bound, they shall remain bound" (John 20:23). This necessitates a discrimination between a confession for which he can grant absolution, and one for which he cannotβwhich requires his hearing the sins. Such an example might be if the penitent isn't... so penitent, since clear indication that the penitent is sorry for his sins is required for the priest to give absolution.
This is something about which the bishop might need to be alerted. This is quite a serious problem.
More post
- π Do all Catholic seminary schools require instruction in Latin and/or Greek?
- π Can my third class relic make other items into third class relics?
- π Is there a biblical basis for the claim that humans are shaped into the God-human Christ?
- π How do Jehovah's Witnesses define "active" membership?
- π When did the gathered church stop singing choruses?
- π Is the present-day Roman Catholic Church the same church on which it was founded?
- π How do Trinitarians who argue the 'ego eimi' at John 8:58 ought to be translated 'I AM' explain the lack of reactions to the same phrase?
- π According to the Catholic Church, can one be a heretic and still obtain salvation?
- π Is the English translation of "Book of Mormon" ever revised or updated, and if so, on what basis given that the golden plates have disappeared?
- π What is the biblical basis for the doctrine of Hypostatic Union?
- π The Cost of Salvation
- π How can I know that GOD really loves me?
- π Markβs fatherβs name
- π Where did the notion that Adam and Eve ate an APPLE come from?
- π David and Milkom wore a 75 lb crown, wouldn't that have snapped their necks?
- π Do Jehovah's Witnesses allow remarriage after a divorce? Are there any consequences for the congregation member?
- π What is the basis for the belief that the name of the Messiah is ΧΦΈΧΧΦΌΧ©ΧΧΦΌΧ’Φ· (Yahushua)?
- π How far is too far when it comes to drinking alcohol?
- π In the Latin Catholic Church, would clerics administer the last rites if the sick person's illness is contagious and deadly?
- π Why are Biblical names not translated?
- π How does one become an Apostle in the LDS Church?
- π Who resurrected Jesus - the Father, the Son, or the Holy Spirit?
- π Rules Which Govern the Excommunication of Catholic Bishops
- π Does Protestant and Christian denominations have stories to tell about bilocation?
- π How does the Catholic Church respond to the claim that its authority to interpret scripture is based on circular reasoning?
- π Why is literary style not inspired?
- π Which sects interpret "Day and Hour unknown" literally?
- π Crucifixion and the principle of double effect
- π At what point did Paul become a child of God, born of God?
- π Why is Apostolic succession required in some denominations?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π If a Catholic priest absolves my sins without taking a confession, does it still count?
- π Does a Roman Catholic priest have to intellectually understand a confession in order to grant absolution?
- π According to Roman Catholic doctrine, why does Mary refer to God as her Savior if she was born without sin?
- π Why does only the priest receive Communion under both kinds at a Catholic Mass?
- π Does the Catholic Church officially claim that the Bible is insufficient without tradition?
- π Does the Catholic Church teach that some who died before Christ are still in Limbo? Why?
- π Does a Catholic have recourse if a priest gives a ridiculously harsh or impossible penance?
- π If and When a Catholic Priest May Reveal Something from a Penitent's Confession
- π Does the Catholic church believe that God really forgives by confession alone?
- π According to Catholic teaching, what is the status of a priest who does not agree with the Church's stated teachings on h*m*sexuality and gender?
- π Does a Christian who commits sins against Christian doctrine and commandments still remain Christian?
- π Does the priest ask for reasons to prevent a marriage during a Catholic wedding?
- π How does general confession work when ordinary confession absolves you of all your past sins?
- π Does the Catholic word Priest actually mean "Presbyter?" Or is it a conflation of roles?
- π How does the Catholic Church tell us to do reparation for our sins according to Church teachings?
- π How much authority does Pseudo-Dionysus still have in today's Catholic Church?
- π How does a Catholic church support itself without Tithe?
- π How does Catholic sacramental theology explain the efficacy of the sacraments conducted by a priest who is in the state of mortal sin?
- π If we receive infinite grace through bread and wine as the Catholic theology say, why does a person still sin against God?
- π According to the Catholic Church, is Jesus a man, or does He rather have a human nature without being a man?
- π Does the Catholic Church still stand behind Deuteronomy 22:28-29?
- π Does the Catholic Church still stand behind Isaiah 14:21?
- π To what extent does the Law of Moses still apply?
- π According to the Catholic Church, are Jews saved without faith in Jesus?
- π Does the Catholic Church officially recognize Protestants as Christians?
- π Do the Catholic Church ex cathedra pronouncements about necessity of Catholicism to be saved still apply?
- π How does the Catholic church explain Matthew 19:9, which seems to allow divorce in case of sexual misconduct?
- π Can a Catholic priest adopt a child?
- π Why does Catholic Church (and possibly some other denominations) approve natural family planning and condemn different kinds of contraception?
- π What does the Catholic church teach about fate of non-Catholic christians?