What would an Arahant experience, as a slave in a labor camp?
score:1
I gained more inside from asking this question than I added to the question in the EDIT section. I think that it is worthy enough as the answer to this question. At least, to me it feels that way. If hope others can find truth in the following.
I became more conscious of the fact that how I feel is a result of my mental activity. And thus in any circumstance I can feel a certain way, independent of the situation. After asking the question it came to me that those feelings are very accurate of reflecting my mental activity. And that each type of feeling (jealousy, hate, motivation, you name it) is a result of a formula. In the same way that 3+5 yields 8 as the formula of summation. Quick example of such a formula with respect to feeling motivated: the formula consists of the following parameters:
- me (or the role that I play as a human being)
- my understanding of the current situation
- my imagination of a future possible situation that I (or better: we) gain from (as in win-win) (in balance with nature/life
- and my estimation of the effort to get there.
You can imagine that if you would gain an abstract value of 10 (on a scale of 1-10) with an estimation of the required effort of value 1 (same scale). Then it is something you are willing to go for and thus feel motivated. On the other hand, if you estimate that the gain will be an abstract value of 1, and the estimation of effort value 10, then you are less motivated because of effort:gain ratio is much higher. And when you have doubt whether it is possible at all to get at that imagined, more beneficial, situation, you feel uncertainty and doubt. Which doesn't add to the motivation to go for it.
So my state of being is independent of the environment and I simply feel positive/negative depending of the parameters that I get to choose to fill in whatever formula that I get to choose. Of course, I can only choose if I see choices. So knowing which emotions exist, understanding these emotions and formulas to execute to produce them are key here. Working on something that I am motivated for feels positive. Feeling thankful feels positive.
The formula of thankfulness:
- me, or someone else.
- a current situation that is beneficial to me (or others)
- an imagined, less beneficial, situation of which I think the chance is realistically high that the current situation was like that.
And there you go! When consciousness puts all these things in relation what you get is: the feeling of being thankful for it being this way. The same works the other way around. Imagine a situation which you could appreciate more, with respect to the current situation and the result is that you do not feel thankful. Rather you would feel depreciation.
Wow!! The simplicity of this (I think) is so amazing! Just like the following metaphor: a charged battery has two poles, but by themselves the are not positive or negative. They only have a polarity when you bring those poles in contact with each other. And then energy is moving between them. The same with consciousness! Consciousness brings stuff together and then energy is moving. And dependent on the direction, it either feels positive of negative. Now add a lightbulb in between the two poles, energy needs to pass the lightbulb, feeling restance, to get there. So anything in between is causing resistance. Everything that stands between you and a future imagined situation from which you (the holistic you, not the ego you) gains from (that standing in between is a mental construct) causes resistance!
Thus an arahant in a slave labor camp can feel positive for sure! Though the environment might make it more or less challenging, but I do see now that it is absolutely possible!!
So when one is unconsciously able to apply all those formulas constantly with the correct (order of) parameters one will feel very positive, energetic, alive and blissful without a doubt!
With this in mind I wanted to put it to the test: EXPERIENCE!
And with 1,5 hour of meditation on my body and these concepts, I could really feel such a strong energetic vibe through my body which relieved pains of stress that I had (cramp around my eye and stomach and sore back). Especially that my back pain had gone away, while I did not change posture, I found so exciting and awesome. I experienced this in 3 separate meditation sessions. To me, this confirms the effectiveness of this focused mental activity. To me, this is truth.
Upvote:-1
"What would an Arahant experience, as a slave in a labor camp?"
He would experience suffering.
"What would be this arahant's view on reality?"
Life is happiness changing into suffering and/or suffering changing into happiness.
Thus, life is unsatisfactory.
Thus, with the cessation of clinging/craving, comes the cessation of suffering.
Upvote:1
I don't want to blame the victims but I suspect that, naturally, part of what's bad about a concentration camp is fear: fear that keeps you awake at night, fear that makes you labour, and so on.
You mentioned "disbelieve in any cause" and "become completely hopeless" ... and I wonder whether perhaps an Arahant might have already done something like that: i.e. perhaps see what you call "causes" as "mere constructions"; and "hopes" as (for example) symptomatic of craving.
Anyway I think that theory, at least, is fairly clear: defined in the Punna Sutta (SN 35.88).
Note too that an Aharant's life-experience might make for less a culture-shock: perhaps they're used to living with nothing; and to seeing dead bodies.
Upvote:1
Being an arahant should not be confused with happiness. The arahant feels physical pain like everyone else. However, he or she has an increased awareness, understanding, and compassion. His awareness would greatly increase his awareness of the suffering of others. His understanding of karma would greatly increase his understanding of the CAUSES of the destructive behavior of Nazis. By understanding karma, it is unreasonable to blame a person for the past circumstances and suffering that causes their present behavior. Part of the increased awareness of the arahant consists of an awareness of the past experiences of another person. Bad people are bad for understandable reasons. By having increased compassion, the arahant would do his or her best to help fellow prisoners. You are mistaken to say, "You might feel pain, sadness, grief or whatever, but you no longer suffer from the experience." The truth is that, by understanding the causes of suffering, a person becomes more objective about it, thereby avoiding UNNECESSARY suffering. In point of fact, by being profoundly aware of the suffering of others, the arahant has an increased sadness. Your understanding of the mental state of the arahant is far off the mark. You claim that an arahant would have "disbelieve in any cause" in a concentration camp. You seem to think that being an arahant consists in believing in some kind of "cause." Buddhism is not a cause, it is a psychology. Similarly, you claim that the arahant would "become completely hopeless." It is not clear to me what kind of hope an arahant would have given that his or her assessment of the situation would be firmly grounded in what would be realistically possible. You seem to think that an arahant would need to "focus oneself on the teachings of the Buddha." This would not be the case. The arahant can see reality for himself or herself. Finally, being an arahant does not consist of maintaining "righteous mental activity." This is a Christian concept that finds no place in the psychology of the arahant. I have practiced mindfulness meditation and have studied Buddhism for more than 50 years. I can say from experience that the psychology of suffering and karma is very difficult to understand. You are far better off practicing mindfulness meditation in order to come to a better understanding of your own mind. Forget about speculating about the nature of arahant.
Upvote:3
First of all, Arahanths never feel sadness, grief, hate etc. They don't have wives, but they may have ex-wives.
if the Arahath has psychic powers he might fly away to spare the people from acquiring extremely bad karma or he might stay if he saw it as an unavoidable consequence of a past Karma.
Either way, he will never get upset no matter what happens. He would try to make the people come to their senses, if he sees potential in them to be better humans. Otherwise he'd remain in a meditative state when not attending to the maintenance of the body.
More post
- π What is the reason for attributing Lord Buddha's statues to days the of week?
- π If we tell lies to save lives, will that be a sin?
- π Is one intention better than the other?
- π Should I decrease the amount of time I practice concentration meditation?
- π Does this count as breaking the first precept?
- π Considering other traditions than Goenka Vipassana for better Right Effort, Right Concentration and Right Mindfullness
- π Translation of a Chinese BΓΆn book about Dzogchen
- π Is there any explanation on why only humans and animals do not remember previous life?
- π Is Buddhism a reduced version of Samkhya philosophy?
- π Doing the opposite of not skillfull things
- π Is exposing immoral behavior divisive speech?
- π Can this question be asked?
- π Can effective altruism (specifically Earning to Give) and Buddhism co-exist if Earning to Give was done to the extreme?
- π Inter-relation between the four brahmaviharas?
- π How do I make non-buddhists help understand I operate with a different view?
- π How does the force of ones karma determine where the mind stream goes?
- π Compassion and Motivation
- π The "working-ground" (kammatthana) of the five hindrances
- π What does "ease" mean in the phrase "dharma gate of ease and joy"?
- π Was Buddha/did Buddha teach Vegetarianism?
- π Should one give to beggars?
- π Does everything that happens to me happens because of me?
- π What does Diamond Way Buddhism say about obstacles at times of becoming more conscious?
- π looking for a particular sutta
- π Under what conditions does a Samyaksambuddha arise?
- π Incoherent Meditations
- π How is it wrong to believe that a self exists, or that it doesn't?
- π Why choose to attain Nirvana when we can become Brahmas (or Bodhisattvas)?
- π Losing awareness
- π Betraying People
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π What would an Arahant experience, as a slave in a labor camp?
- π What would be the motivation for an arahant to perform generous deeds?
- π What is it like to experience enlightenment?
- π What would Buddhists do to get rid of the feeling of insecurity in relationships?
- π What would one encounter at a Buddhist temple service?
- π What would a Buddhist country's law be?
- π What is Death? What did Buddha say regarding the experience of Death?
- π What would be the secular interpretation for the Assu Sutta and the Mata Sutta?
- π If you Consolidate the Satipatthana Instruction from the Tripitaka what would the additions and variation in Comparison to Maha Satipatthana Sutta
- π Is Buddhism a syncretic religion, and then what would they say on the Abrahamaic religions?
- π What would be some Japanese Buddhist/Shinto routines or rituals that households will do?
- π What would Buddha advise to farewell when one of your parents died?
- π What do you think would be a good way to explain death to a child, from a Buddhist perspective?
- π What would happen if everyone became a monk or nun?
- π What religious texts would help me understand the fundamentals Buddhism better?
- π Does an Arahant yawn? Or: What are the characteristics of the Noble Ones: SotΔpanna, SakadΔgΔmi, AnΔgΔmi and Arahant?
- π I'm fascinated by 'death': what would Dogen say?
- π What would be the karmic result of worrying?
- π As a disciple of the Supreme Buddha, what would you do with an animal that is in severe pain?
- π What would be a secular interpretation of animal rebirth
- π What specific emotion would best describe dukkah?
- π The Experience of What Arises
- π What to do when experience is different to teaching examples?
- π what is arhant's experience of 3 marks?
- π What would you say about being overly optimistic or overly pessimistic about the ways of approaching the path?
- π in Budhism, what would happen with a soul in a eventually case of succesfull cryogenic reanimation?
- π What would Buddhists say about 'pantheism'
- π What would a sotapanna do?
- π What to do that wise would not disappear again?
- π What would be the relationship between mindfulness, enlightenment and incubation?