Is discussing bad practices of monks a sin?
Upvote:2
In the above Sutta householder, Ugga declares he does not discriminate how he treats the monks based on their attainments or qualities. This is his 6th quality.
But if some monk is doing something wrong it might be worthwhile to report him to a head monk if there is a chance that proper action might be taken.
Ultimately what matters is the motivation. If you talk ill of a monk with intention breaking his good standing with other this is bad karma. If you do it for the betterment of the monk and the sasana then it is positive. In doing so you have to be tactful though so that it does not lead to unintended consequences.
Upvote:2
Remember that any yet-to-be-enlightened monk/nun is still a responsible citizen of the country they're living in, hence they're bound by the law of the land, not above it. Furthermore, they also need to observe another set of law written in the Vinaya specific to their "profession". So if they break a common law, then they're not a good citizen; if they break a Vinaya law, then they're not a good monk. And provided that the errors are well documented and backed up by evidences, it's not only fair game but also a duty for good people, both lay and monastic to bring it up, so that the error could be corrected and prevented from happening again in the future.
More post
- π Sexual thoughts coming with full pace to silent mind
- π Dealing with colleagues who hate me after mistake
- π Does the middle way apply to objects as well as the skandhas?
- π What is the doctrinal justification for Shaolin martial arts?
- π Which early canonical references help one find a skillful teacher?
- π Breach of precept term
- π How and when did the name "Buddhism" appear?
- π Meditation Without References
- π Would a wise person avoide situations where other could perform lot of demerits?
- π What Buddhist materials explain how to understand one's irrational feelings?
- π Pali question: "seven more life times at most"
- π Who were some people who attained Buddhahood after the historical Buddha?
- π Is the word 'real' synonymous with 'exists' in Buddhist doctrine?
- π VijΓ±Δna and ΕΕ«nyatΔ... How are they seen as different?
- π Physical Lethargy
- π Buddhism in the Middle East
- π Is Mind in Buddhism connected to Brain (the physical organ)?
- π Is equanimity more sublime that an excellent act?
- π Can Buddhism be called as Atheist, Agnostic or Theistic?
- π Do we need to cheat the mind to escape thoughts which would lead to bad habits?
- π There is no benefit and there is no intrinsic positive nature in a pleasant sensation
- π Can a non-Buddhist get Nirvana?
- π According to Buddhism, what separates humans from animals?
- π What kind of mental state does the meditation on four elements generate?
- π Do I get more merits if I give more?
- π Why are so many Buddhists in the west hostile to academic analyses of the religion?
- π Hatred arising after a friend tried to make my fiancΓ© cheat on me
- π Does anyone recognise this haiku?
- π Overcoming distractions in meditation as per the Tripitaka?
- π If all things are impermanent, then how can Buddhism make absolute assertions?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π Is discussing bad practices of monks a sin?
- π How does a monk cope with all the bad things happening in the world if the only thing monks do is sitting and meditating?
- π Relationship with bad parents (kamma and issues)
- π How to deal with bad past karma that makes my current life miserable?
- π What are the common buddhist practices to eliminate sleepiness?
- π Are actions in computer games bad for karma?
- π Giving up bad friends
- π Is there any such thing as a bad meditation?
- π What dietary practices are most helpful for reaching enlightenment?
- π Do lions create bad kamma for their next life when they kill?
- π Can bad kammas be eased by apologizing?
- π Do metta practices and anatta contradict each other?
- π Do monks not have responsibility towards parents and family?
- π When and why did monks stop meditating?
- π What Bad Karma Awaits Adulterers?
- π How do Buddhists justify or explain that monks and/or temples amass and use wealth?
- π Is it possible to adhere to the practices and beliefs of both Buddhist and Christianity?
- π What type of Buddhist monks are only allowed to eat two meals per day and why?
- π What practices are included in (daily lay) life for a Buddhist?
- π Can following Buddhist practices help me in my studies?
- π Drunk monks and the 5th precept
- π Are theravada monks allowed to stay in lay people's house?
- π Won't bad karma cause a chain reaction?
- π Is making art bad or sinful?
- π Do Theravada monks search for reincarnation of teachers?
- π Is curiosity, for non Dhamma subjects, a bad thing?
- π Conflict between Brahmajala Sutta and current Buddhist practices
- π Is there a Tantrayana (Tibetan Buddhism) training related to "burning" past bad karma?
- π Is the only way to deal with the effects of your bad karma endurance?
- π Are monks better teachers than ex-monks?