What is the Buddhist perception of injustice, considering the law of Karma?
score:5
It's certainly been seen as a difficult question for Buddhists. I've heard it termed the Glenn Hoddle question after an ex-footballer used karma type arguments to explain disability - to quote
You and I have been physically given two hands and two legs and half-decent brains. Some people have not been born like that for a reason. The karma is working from another lifetime
He was sacked as England coach. However it is a difficult question and I will attempt a decent answer
Karma isn't cause and effect
Karma isn't just cause and effect - there is more going on. To quote the Sivaka Sutra
Now when these ascetics and brahmans have such a doctrine and view that 'whatever a person experiences, be it pleasure, pain or neither-pain-nor-pleasure, all that is caused by previous action,' then they go beyond what they know by themselves and what is accepted as true by the world. Therefore, I say that this is wrong on the part of these ascetics and brahmans.
It's not as if someone lies in one life then is reborn as with a disability in the next. Sometimes the fruits of karma (action) are immediate, sometimes they are delayed, sometimes the fruits don't come to pass at all.
There is more going on than Karma
Also in Buddhism there is the concept of Niyamas which explains outcome dependant origination (the underpinning of reality). These being
- kamma niyama: ("action") consequences of one's actions
- utu niyama: ("time, season") seasonal changes and climate, law of non-living matter
- bΔ«ja niyama: ("seed") laws of heredity
- citta niyama:("mind") will of mind
- dhamma niyama: ("law") nature's tendency to perfect
The above list is taken from here. So karma would only explain a fraction of someones present conditions.
Karma isn't blame
I guess the other thing to point out is that there is no concept of blame in any of this. The audio here is very interesting - a Buddhist nun discusses this exact issue with someone with seeing difficulties.
Even if someone's unfortunate circumstances were caused directly by their actions (which is no means as simple as that) then this wouldn't stop us feeling compassion for them. This would be true in this life or the next. If someone was run over because they didn't look both ways before crossing the road then it is a normal human response to feel compassion for them - Buddhist or not.
As I say though a difficult and interesting question. I hope that helps some.
Upvote:0
According to Buddhism, kamma and its consequences (vipaka) may not happen at the same time or even in the same life, it is hard to predict when it will create its results because it depends on other conditions, that is why people can be born with serious problems.
For example: Imagine a murderer, he creates terrible kamma, but if he lives with several bodyguards he may protect himself from being murdered, this kamma will not rippen in this life because there is cause but there are no conditions, so this kamma will go on into the next life (probably in a much worse plane)
If it helps: When someone is facing a problem at least think that he or she is puryfing some bad kamma, at least this kamma will be gone and if the person has created merit, good things are on his way!
Upvote:2
Future is the result of our actions in the past, present, future and the other 4 Niyama Dhammas.
Was there any room for the concept of unfairness when the Tsunami killed about 150,000 people in 2004? Was there any room for the concept of unfairness for all those kids born deformed after Hiroshima & Nagasaki bombing? Is there any room for fairness when earthquakes kill thousands of people? Just like that, Karma is also a law of nature. Is it fair to get burnt, if a kid puts his hand in the fire, not knowing it burns? Is it fair to get sick when mosquitoes bite you? The concept of fairness or unfairness doesn't have anything to do with the laws of nature.
Past Karma is most definitely a cause for child rape. But nothing happens by a single cause. Everything has multiple causes.
Nature or life is fair in only one way, i.e. if the right causes are present, it gives you the appropriate result.
More post
- π Are Therevada's cosmology and the Mahanaya's sutras physically impossible?
- π Is empathy discussed anywhere in the suttas?
- π Did I violate the fourth precept?
- π Does 'saαΉsaαΉαΉha' mean "arise together"?
- π Is one intention better than the other?
- π What is "thukdam"?
- π Do "and further", "again", in MahaSatipatthanasutta definitely mean "next step (aparam)"?
- π How to overcome the suffering of attachement to the body's continued existence (in Western modernity)?
- π Meditation technique proposed by the Buddha
- π What are the differences between vipassana and mindfulness meditation?
- π What is the Pali word for mundane knowledge ?
- π Due to coming together of what does the dream arise?
- π Is there any research on physiology of deep and long meditative states (i.e. days and weeks of sitting)?
- π Question about the PitΔpΕ«trasamΔgama-sΕ«tra
- π Misinterpretation of a Pali phrase - Rupan Jirathi
- π Is it possible for a human being to live without the mind?
- π How many hours of Meditation in single sitting during Vipassana?
- π Shouldn't we take Lord Buddha's word above the all others?
- π How many countries did Lord Buddha travel?
- π Nothing i seem to have flipped the switch by getting rid of everything
- π What is Inner and Outer Peace and how can I achieve them?
- π Is there any freely available English translation of the PeαΉakopadesa?
- π Devas: offerings and merit sharing
- π The Super Fast Karma - Covid 19
- π Gomchen Lam Rim Text Request
- π What if there was no one to offer food to monastics?
- π What is the easiest way to achieve a state of no physical suffering?
- π Why five aggregates instead of just three?
- π Why there is limited sharing in Buddhism
- π Are the differences between Advaita Vedanta and Buddhism merely semantic/perspective?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π What is the Buddhist perception of injustice, considering the law of Karma?
- π What Buddhist materials describe how to increase the number of people with good Karma in a geographic area?
- π What is the Buddhist point of view of the Law of Attraction?
- π What are the common buddhist practices to eliminate sleepiness?
- π What is the difference between relative and absolute truth in Buddhist philosophy?
- π What is the Interpretation of Parimukham in the context of Buddhist Meditation?
- π What is the buddhist way of responding to compliments?
- π What is Buddhist law of marriage ? Is there any?
- π Is there any mention of child adoption in any Buddhist writings and what is the view on child adoption with regard to Buddhism?
- π What Buddhist texts describe the doings of syncretized Hindu deities?
- π What is the reasoning for making a buddhist statue out of gold?
- π From a Buddhist point of view, what are the benefits of supernormal powers?
- π What was the 1st Buddhist Council about?
- π What is the Theravada Buddhist lay lifestyle?
- π What are the resources a Buddhist can use during very hard times?
- π What is the origin of the Buddhist expression "Practice as if your hair is on fire"?
- π What is the Buddhist approach of admitting a mistake?
- π Is what is taught under the term "Radical Buddhism" consistent with Buddhist values?
- π What is the difference between learning the Buddhist way and simply learning from life?
- π What is the definition of 'fool' in Theravada Buddhist text?
- π What would a Buddhist country's law be?
- π What is the reason why Buddhist monks don't work to support themselves? Do the monastic rules prohibit them from working?
- π What is the role of karma in rebirth?
- π What is the overall Buddhist taxonomy?
- π If the law of Karma is a natural law like Newton's law?
- π What is the Buddhist Way to Reform and Correct People?
- π What are the various Buddhist scriptural designations and to what do they refer?
- π What is the Buddhist Perspective on Lucid Dreaming?
- π What are the Buddhist teachings on how best to live a married life?
- π Law of Karma in the Buddha's own words