How historically accurate is 'India: A History' by John Keay?
score:5
I decided to read the book anyway, after waiting for someone to answer the question. I understand this is not a place to review books, but here are my two cents.
The narrative is, in my opinion, as unbiased as it can get. While talking about unclear parts of Indian history like Aryan invasion / migration / indigenous Aryans, he explains pros and cons of each theory before explaining the generally accepted theory. Also, the narration of post-independence politics (intra-national or international) politics seems objective. As I hoped it to be, it doesn't discredit India from its achievements, nor does it over-glorify them. A must-read for anyone who is interested in Indian history.
Upvote:1
This is a partial answer relating to the book's unbiased status.
No. The book is not unbiased. The book's biases may be historiographically justifiable, but, necessarily, the book is not unbiased. Bias is as unremovable from texts as it is from woven fabric: the fabric of texts produces a bias.
Sources: historiographical theory of bias in texts, and the nature of texts as bias.
Upvote:1
Your question is the rare one that no one even bothers to ask. From the beginning of the creation of Indian history, bias has played an important role. The funny thing is, the history of India being taught in schools are created by the western people of British East India Company. The purpose of creating biased Indian history is to strengthen their rule over then India. That's how the "Aryan Invasion Theory" born. Another thing was the Christianity that influenced those historians. They set the chronology of Indian historical events according to the bible. According to bible, the creation began 4004 BC. Hence whatever historical events occurred were pushed around 2000 BC - 1500 BC and so on. You take Max Muller, H. M. Elliot, Vincent Smith, W. W. Hunter or any other, you will find the same biased view.
After the independence, Indian history department was completely filled with communists who hated everything that belonged to ancient India. As a result, they followed the earlier western historians and added more biased version while creating history books for schools, colleges and universities. Romila Thapar, Sathish Chandra, Ram Sharan Sharma are such kind of Indian historians. However, there were some historians who tried to discover the truth but were either ignored or silenced. If you want to know how they twisted Indian history, read Edi Charitra or visit this link
More post
- 📝 Is there any evidence that Celts produced chain mail?
- 📝 Was there anything like an African-American architectural style or symbolism at the beginning of the 20th century?
- 📝 Did ancient/medieval Indians produce and consume alcohol?
- 📝 Did the Roman legions wear this type of boots?
- 📝 Why are the German and French languages so different?
- 📝 Why was the ship "Palmyra" so named?
- 📝 Question about pilgrims
- 📝 Who are these people in this satirical cartoon of the Congress of Verona?
- 📝 Horses.. goats... evolution
- 📝 Is there a place in Europe that has never been Christian?
- 📝 What steps did President Herbert Hoover take to reduce unemployment during the Great Depression?
- 📝 How common were professional musicians before the advent of recorded music?
- 📝 What sources could Tacitus or Appian have used that have since been lost?
- 📝 What was this building and what happend to it?
- 📝 Can the assignment "Depot Battalion" in Hart's Annual Army List be linked to a specific regimental assignment?
- 📝 What's a good general history book on Italy, 1400-1600?
- 📝 What was the attitude of English knights towards their longbowmen counterparts?
- 📝 What is the difference between "seigneurie" and "manor"?
- 📝 What happened to sacrificed animals in ancient Greece?
- 📝 What is the "bag on a stick" Hercules is holding in this picture?
- 📝 Did the Picture Post publish the 1857 photo "Two Sepoys of the 31st Native Infantry Who Were Hanged at Lucknow" in 1939?
- 📝 Has there been a war whose declared goal was a mere land grab without any attempts to ethically justify it?
- 📝 What does this Swiss banner/blazon/coat of arms/flag stand for?
- 📝 Why was Polish king Sigismund II Augustus' coronation held when his father Sigismund I was still alive?
- 📝 What kind of evidence (if any) could be used to identify a large conquest in the time before writing?
- 📝 Did archers ever shoot over the heads of their allies at enemy cavalry? Did they ever do this during a melee?
- 📝 Were these two racist quotes written by Marx?
- 📝 What did the Baltic Fleet do in Reval in 1904 and when was it there?
- 📝 Recommended electronic versions of old public domain US history textbooks?
- 📝 Why does Edinburgh Castle's one o'clock gun fire at 1pm instead of, say, noon?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 How historically accurate is 'India: A History' by John Keay?
- 📝 How historically accurate is "Life is Beautiful" when it comes to Jewish extermination?
- 📝 How historically accurate is Les Miserables?
- 📝 How historically accurate was the Queen's trip to Ghana portrayed in Episode 8 of The Crown?
- 📝 How historically accurate was the movie "Charlie Wilson's War"?
- 📝 How historically accurate are the subplots about poison gas and false flag assassinations in Babylon Berlin?
- 📝 How historically accurate is Age of Empires III?
- 📝 How historically accurate are the Assassin's Creed games?
- 📝 How historically accurate is "Good King Wencenclaus"?
- 📝 How accurate or supported is Jared Diamond's "Guns, Germs, and Steel"?
- 📝 How accurate and detailed were geographical maps created and updated by the Romans?
- 📝 How long, historically speaking, did it take to tally and report the vote?
- 📝 How accurate is quantitative evidence included in Caesar's Commentarii de Bello Gallico?
- 📝 How accurate did medieval historians think histories to be?
- 📝 How accurate and balanced is Paul Johnson's 'A History of the Jews'?
- 📝 How accurate is Stone's "The Trial of Socrates"?
- 📝 How accurate is the book "Rifleman Dodd"?
- 📝 How accurate is the quip: "Mongols, having already conquered half of Europe, decided the other half wasn't worth it"?
- 📝 How accurate is Grossman's description of Nazi concentration camps?
- 📝 How accurate is Nietzsche's account of the birth of tragedy?
- 📝 How accurate is Russell on liberalism versus fanaticism in war?
- 📝 How accurate is the fatalistic samurai culture in James Clavell's novel Shogun?
- 📝 How accurate are ancient history busts?
- 📝 How accurate is Karl Heinz Frieser when he said that the blitzkrieg was a myth?
- 📝 How did John Duns Scotus live in England during the Scottish Wars of Independence?
- 📝 How accurate is the respresentation of York/Jórvík in the manga Vinland Saga?
- 📝 How accurate was rocket artillery in the 18th and 19th centuries?
- 📝 How accurate is Belloc's version of European economic history in The Servile State, with regards to the seizing of the monastic lands?
- 📝 How reliable and accurate is the Nuremberg Chronicle?
- 📝 Historically accurate WW2 simulation