What is the Protestant understanding of the Greek "anamnesis" and "poieo" in Luke 22:19?
score:9
This whole subject is dealt with, admirably and historically, by the Wikipedia article Lord's Supper in Reformed Theology and I thoroughly recommend it.
The word ποιέω in Greek (see Strong 4160 and, therein, Thayer's comments in particular) covers a variety of concepts expressed in English by 'make' 'do' 'fashion' and (notably in this case) 'cause' and 'prepare'.
The word has a very broad spectrum of concept, which can be conveyed (mostly) by the word 'effect' in English : 'cause to occur' or 'effectively cause to be so'.
Therefore 'do' this cannot be forced to mean 'cause a supernatural thing to occur' or 'make a profound alteration to be so'.
In order to understand what part of the very broad spectrum of meaning is (in context) to be attached to ποιέω one must needs observe the following noun phrase 'in the of Me remembrance' (literally, see Biblehub).
... this do in the of Me remembrance [literal Luke 22:19]
ἀνάμνησις, anamnesis - ana/mneia again/mention - (see Mounce) is only used four times in scripture, three times in connection with the remembering of the supper, Luke 22:19, 1 Cor 11:24 and 25, and once (significantly) Hebrews 10:3 :
But in those (sacrifices there) is a remembrance again made of sins every year. [KJV]
The contrast is with the remembering one's own sins, repeatedly.
Instead, Jesus institutes a memorial of his sacrifice.
I am going to repeat that, so needful is it to state it :
Instead of remembering one's own sins repeatedly, Jesus institutes a memorial of his sacrifice.
Hebrews specifically remonstrates against the repetition of a sacrifice, showing how ineffectual such a repetition is, Hebrews 10:2, Hebrews 10:14, Hebrews 10:18.
Instead, there is one sacrifice.
And it is to be remembered - not repeated.
It is a memorial, not a 'sacrament'. It is an 'again mentioning'. What is to be 'effectively caused' is an 'again mentioning'. It is not a repetitive ritual : it is an oft reminder which is 'mentioned'; the emphasis being on intelligent (and shared) communication for mutual benefit. It is a gospel matter not a ritual matter.
The Question by the OP, is a very astute one, noting the wording precisely.
The word ποιέω requires to be defined (due to its exceedingly broad spectrum of meaning) by the context of 'remembrance'.
'Effectively cause (in the context of memory) to be so'.
Thus 'remember Me' rather than 'remember your sins'.
Remember his suffering, remember his sacrifice, remember his obedience to the Father, remember his love to the sheep.
'Effect this in memory of Me'. 'This' being the taking of an ordinary loaf, breaking it open, and distributing it in a simple memorial of an utterly unique occurrence.
The alternative is to repeatedly detract from that unique occurrence by instituting a repetitive occurrence that draws attention to itself, and draws attention away from Christ.
The sacrifice of Christ purges once and purges forever. It does not need to be repeated : only to be remembered :
For then would they not have ceased to be offered? because that the worshippers once purged should have had no more conscience of sins. Hebrews 10:2 KJV.
Upvote:1
My own faith group practices complete congregational autonomy, so there is nobody who is authorized to speak for all of us, but I can tell you what has been taught and practiced in every congregation where I have attended.
For starters, we take communion every Sunday, so we spend a lot of time reading and hearing the passages involved.
The interpretation followed is that "this do" applies to what Jesus had just commanded the disciples to do: To divide up a portion of unleavened bread and fruit of the vine, and to consume them.
As for "in remembrance of Me", it is interpreted to mean that we do this in order to remember Jesus' death on the cross. It is very common for the man leading the communion portion of the service to quote from chapter eleven of First Corinthians, where Paul states that the purpose of communion is to remember Christ's death.
I have not seen even a hint of a belief that these passages establish a separate priesthood, and I am fairly confident that any suggestion of such a thing in my faith group would be seen as twisting them.
Upvote:2
The Lutheran understanding of sacrificial language in the Lord's Supper, is that to make a distinction between two types of sacrifices, namely:
- Propitiatory sacrifices
These type of sacrifices bring about (or merit before God) the remission of sins, and require the shedding of blood (cf. Hebrews 9:22)
- Eucharistic sacrifices
This is a thanks giving sacrifice, Greek eucharistia for “thanksgiving”, that do not require shedding of blood, nor merits the remission of sins.
The Lutherans understand the Eucharsit to be the latter, nor the former.
Upvote:5
The phrase in Luke 22:19, “do this in remembrance of me” is subject to different interpretations. I will provide a Lutheran answer.
Literally in Luke 22:19, it is “do this into (Greek eis) my remembrance.” The question becomes, Who is to remember whom? The Greek allows for at least two options: (1) our remembering Christ (the dominant Protestant view), and (2) Christ remembering us (the Catholic, Orthodox & Lutheran view). In other words, the phrase can be translated alternatively as “do this in order to remember me,” or “do this as a reminder to me (so that I'll remember you).” Perhaps it is both.
A God-ward “reminder” is found in Num 10:9-10:
When you go into battle in your own land against an enemy who is oppressing you, sound a blast on the trumpets. Then you will be remembered by the LORD your God and rescued from your enemies. Also at your times of rejoicing—your appointed feasts and New Moon festivals—you are to sound the trumpets over your burnt offerings and fellowship offerings, and they will be a memorial for you before your God. I am the LORD your God.
So, who is remembering in Holy Communion? God or people?
It is not just what we do for God, but also rather what God does for us in remembrance – i.e. kind of like the days of Noah in the Bible in which the rainbow acted as a sign of remembrance for God to establish his covenant. Genesis 9:12-16 states:
When the bow is in the clouds, I will see it and remember the everlasting covenant between God and every living creature of all flesh that is on the earth.
Jesus said, “This cup is the new covenant in my blood. Do this, as often as you drink it, in remembrance of me."
Our prayers are brought before God that he may remember. Think of the thief on the cross, who said, "remember me when you come into your Kingdom." Christians take Communion with the thought of, "Do this in remembrance of me" - i.e. that God may remember me.
David prayed more than once that God would "remember" him or his righteous deeds (Ps 25:6-7; 89:50; 106:4; etc.). See Deut 9:27; Nehemiah, 13:14,22, 29, 31). Jesus urged us to pray persistently to God:
And will not God bring about justice for his chosen ones, who cry out to him day and night? Will he keep putting them off? I tell you, he will see that they get justice, and quickly (Lk 18:7-8).
God chooses to use the causality of prayer as we call upon him to remember us – especially in prayer. The Lord's Supper is not so much a "Divine Service" to God. Rather, it is mostly God's way to give "Divine Service" to us. Jesus gives us his body, blood, soul and divinity to us under the form of the bread and wine in Holy Communion. It is a sacramental union of the two natures in a Chalcedonian Christological sense - i.e. the earthly elements (bread & wine) and the heavenly power (illocal body & blood) exists, distinct but not separated.
The Lutheran Confessions speaks of how in Baptism and in the Lord's Supper Christ offered the grace of God. He "sacrifices himself" on the altar for eating and drinking so that believers can receive salvation in all its fullness. The sacrifice of praise and thanksgiving (sacrificium eucharisticum) is offered up through Christ in the Holy Spirit's power as access to the Father through Christ's sacrifice on the cross. See "Confessing one faith: A joint Commentary on the Augsburg Confession by Lutheran and Catholic theologians."
More post
- 📝 What is older: Dead Sea Scrolls or Septuagint? Which is more reliable?
- 📝 Why does communion frequency vary in different denominations?
- 📝 Where did Goliath come from?
- 📝 Which Catholic theologians say that Purgatory is a "fiery moment"?
- 📝 Did Mosaic covenants follow Ancient Near East Suzerain Treaties or was it the other way around?
- 📝 Why is “faith” omitted as a doctrinal consideration in TULIP (five point) Calvinism?
- 📝 Has the Mass ever been translated and said in Sanskrit?
- 📝 How does the Passover foreshadow the coming of Jesus as the Messiah?
- 📝 How did Christians of WW1/WW2 view the book of Revelation?
- 📝 Does the Jerusalem Bible teach that Adam had a wife before Eve?
- 📝 What did Jesus mean by 'going for a second mile '?
- 📝 How and when was the belief that a baptism late in life increases our chances of being saved determined to be false?
- 📝 Are Jehovah's Witnesses expected to follow their church's doctrines?
- 📝 Why would Jesus beg himself in the Garden of Gethsemane?
- 📝 What is the difference in original sin and our nature to sin from a Reformed or Calvinist view?
- 📝 Did Philo influence the contents of the New Testament?
- 📝 Has a pope ever been corrected publicly by a non-cleric in the presence of cardinals because of his immoral conduct?
- 📝 Why did God give man an imagination?
- 📝 According to the Catholic Church, when Jesus speaks, is he is speaking as a Man or God or both?
- 📝 How to reconcile the Council of Trent and the Apostle John regarding the post-baptismal presence of sin?
- 📝 How did Moses speak to the children of Israel & write the Torah if he was learned in all the ways of the Egyptians?
- 📝 Does the Bible stipulate priorities among personal allegiances?
- 📝 Indication of the possibility to discern the spirit of a man by/without listening to his words
- 📝 What is the biblical basis for the Eastern Orthodox concept of Aerial toll houses?
- 📝 How do young Catholics remember a set of prayers in order to pray the rosary?
- 📝 How do churches that have indefinitely suspended in-person services understand Hebrews 10:25?
- 📝 What is the general interpretation of God creating the humans "in his image"?
- 📝 Why is Rome the holy city?
- 📝 In what form did water exist before the creation of light?
- 📝 Who were the main Protestant precursors?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 What is the Protestant understanding of the Greek "anamnesis" and "poieo" in Luke 22:19?
- 📝 What is the Reformed Protestant understanding of God's Permissive Will, His Sovereign or Decretive Will and Efficacious Will?
- 📝 According to Protestant trinitarians, what is the significance of the father-son relationship between God and Christ?
- 📝 What is the Catholic understanding of the first sin committed by Adam and Eve?
- 📝 Why is the word ‘concupiscence’ so important in understanding the difference between a Catholic view and a Protestant view of ‘Original Sin’?
- 📝 What is the Lutheran doctrine of consubstantiation and how does it differ from transubstantiation and a more general protestant sacramental view?
- 📝 What were the major disagreements between Erasmus and Luther during the Protestant Reformation?
- 📝 Since when did the Catholic church accept Protestant baptism, and what was the original rationale for accepting?
- 📝 What is the difference between belief and faith, from a Protestant perspective?
- 📝 What are the main differences between the Catholic and Protestant definitions of Biblical inerrancy?
- 📝 What is the relation between the Logos of Greek Philosophy and the Logos in Christianity?
- 📝 What roles do faith and works play in the LDS/Mormon understanding of salvation?
- 📝 What is the understanding between the Genesis account and the book of Abraham account of creation? (LDS)
- 📝 What is an overview of Protestant explanations of the difference between dead faith and perfect faith in James 2?
- 📝 What do the words Catholic and Protestant mean?
- 📝 What is the Catholic understanding of "the thousand-year reign of Christ and his people"?
- 📝 What is the difference between the Roman Catholic and Greek Orthodox churches?
- 📝 What is the Calvinist and Hyper-Calvinist understanding of the "whosoever will" from Rev. 22:17?
- 📝 What is the eastern Catholic and Eastern Orthodox understanding of mortal and venial sin?
- 📝 What differences are there between the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox understanding of the sacrament of marriage?
- 📝 What did Protestant reformers think about the date and authorship of the New Testament?
- 📝 What is the basis for the idiomatic understanding of "three days in the tomb" as two nights and a day?
- 📝 What is the current Reformed and Protestant view of the 'image of the beast' (Revelation 13: 14 &15)?
- 📝 What is the Protestant view of John 20:23 and the disciples ability to forgive sins?
- 📝 What is the Catholic understanding and explanation regarding Num 11:25?
- 📝 What are the main differences between Reformed Protestant Biblical Theology and Covenant Theology?
- 📝 What is the mainline Protestant understanding of "unceasing prayer"?
- 📝 What is the Catholic understanding of Predestination and Freewill?
- 📝 What was the early Church Fathers' understanding of the "baptism with Holy Spirit and fire"?
- 📝 What is the rationale for Greek Orthodox's erection of a wall between the congregates and the altar?